Nypd Pizza Hunters Creek

I would have rated this restaurant a “5” had it not been for order at the register and taking a number to your table, AND using paper plates and to go containers for salads. However, they use stainless steel silverware, so a broken dishwasher isn’t the reason. These prices certainly aren’t adjusted down to compensate for use of paper plates, plastic cups and plastic to go containers. The food is excellent and the store was packed. So the reasoning behind the lack of proper dinnerware is mind boggling. If we return, it will only be for take out until they fix the dinnerware issues.

I really like this restaurant. We order from them regularly now, their garlic knots are probably the best I've had anywhere. I haven't personally had their pizza, but my husband likes the pizza, he is a fan of the hot honey. He was not happy with the Italian Combo Hero, as it looked like it was a big thick sandwich with lots of toppings, but there was actually very little toppings and a lot of bread, he ended up putting everything on one half of the bread and threw the other half of bread away. The Cheesecake & Chocolate cake are both great, The Zeppolis not so much. I don't like that they come in a paper bag, as the paper bag has ripped on us both times, and the second time we got them, I switched it up and got the cinnamon sugar, and I believe too much cinnamon was used because everybody's mouth was burning and they couldn't be eaten. Overall we have become a regular there and enjoy the food and will continue to enjoy them!

The atmosphere and service was incredibly friendly and helpful! Food was absolutely delicious. Would definitely recommend! We got the garlic knots and they came out hot and tender with crispy edges and a side of marinara for dipping. The cheese steak was perfect filled full of creamy steak, peppers and onions on a super soft fluffy bread. The calzone was the perfect size and not too doughy. Loved it!

First time ordering from here, I did a DoorDash delivery. The pizza was still hot nice and fresh. The garlic 🧄 knots was the best. My daughter and I was out here and wanted pizza 🍕. Being from NY you know some spots say NY pizza out here in Florida but is not good at ALL and taste nowhere near like New York pizza but NYPD pizza is spot on.