Did we step back into 1993? Salad bar and potato comes with the stake? Well it worth the visit the prime rib was done perfectly and had lots of flavor. The streak was slightly over salted for my test but still tender. The salad bar was a fun throw back. The onion soup was slightly disappointing lacked bold flavor and little watery. The service was excellent. For 5 us with a bottle of wine and two cocktails it was $350. So perfect pricing. Don’t be afraid of the nondescript building with no windows.
When you arrive, you’re greeted with the sounds of Gregorian Chanting outside to set the mood. Inside there isn’t a bad seat in this restaurant but grab a booth if you can - you may need to space to lie down after dinner. Service was excellent. Salad bar (included with most meals!) was clean and delicious. The steak was excellent and not as expensive as ‘fancy’ steakhouses. One of the best dining experiences in Omaha and it won’t break the bank. Highly recommended!
Everything was excellent!! Our group ordered a wide variety of appetizers for sharing, and they were all great. My fillet was perfectly cooked medium rare as I asked and was outstanding. Others in the group were extremely happy with their entrees. We had a group of 15 and our waitress was unbelievable! No one waited for drinks, refills, or anything. Outstanding service! And after you're done eating, make sure you look around at the rooms in this building. From stained glass windows to the monastery bells in front- it was an absolutely beautiful atmosphere. Highly recommend visiting if you're in Omaha!
The salad bar here was great for lunch with my smothered chicken sandwich. My husband enjoyed their chicken fried steak and my son thought the New York Strip was very good also. Neat atmosphere-we sat at a cozy booth right by a wall of books. Great service!
Marielis Enid Ramos Rivera
+4
This place is pretty cool, loved the uniforms! Food was exquisite and tasty. I give 4 stars because its quite pricey. But overall it was nice. For me, a place to go just for very special ocations.
Great moody atmosphere, super knowledgeable and attentive staff, and delicious food all make Brother Sebastian’s a great date night destination. I had the best steak of my life there—a filet that was perfectly seasoned and cooked and tender enough to barely even require chewing. The only complaint I have is that the bread loaf they give you at the beginning is not good. Everything else was perfect though!
This place was well worth the money. We spent just over $500 for 7 people. (Which included a $100 tip). The food was excellent, choices were good, and the atmosphere was unique, comfy, cozy, and had a great ambiance. We all had variations of steak that were delicious. The chocolate martinis, ciders, ales, and scotch didn't disappoint. Our waitress was amazing. She was fast, friendly, and super helpful and knowledgeable. Great place to go for a fancy night out. Highly recommended!
Wow, this was our first time here and it more than met all expectations and all reviews that we have seen.
The multitude of small rooms for dining and the fireplaces that were in our room simply make the ambiance wonderful. We had the New York sirloin steak and the walleye and both were superb, as was the French onion soup for appetizer. The service was outstanding,Tom served based on where we were with the particular appetizer or salad so the main courses came out at the exact right time. With salad vegetable and potato coming with the main entree as a one price item, this is much cheaper than some of the regular steak houses that we visit.
Took a group of nine colleagues. Good salad bar, great appetizers, and excellent prime rib. Has a super wine list, not over priced like many other steakhouses in Omaha. Service staff was very friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. Had not been there for a very long time, missed the monks.
First went here in 1993, and went back many times after that. I just went again today with my daughters after the opera. Nice to know that some things never change. Outstanding in every respect! The prime rib was exquisite, and a huge portion. Fresh bread, delicious salad bar, wine, dessert. Cozy semi-private booths in small dark rooms with fireplace. All was as good as I remember. Yes, a little pricey but I don't mind at all paying for value and great service.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Omaha
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes