Best Restaurants in Old Forge

Discover 70 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated December 2025.

⭐

80/100

Avg Rating

🍴

15

Cuisine Types

20 of 70 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Blue Line Coffee House

Blue Line Coffee House

📍 3109 Ny-28

Dough A Deer Bakery

Dough A Deer Bakery

Italian French American

💬 88 reviews

📍 3018 State Route 28

Mary Lou's Pizza

Mary Lou's Pizza

💬 257 reviews

📍 209 Dunn Ave

The New Elio G's Pizza Shop

The New Elio G's Pizza Shop

💬 109 reviews

📍 843 S Main St

Cuzzos

💬 16 reviews

📍 219 W Mary St

Grappa

Grappa

💬 15 reviews

📍 112 S Main St

E-lane's Diner

E-lane's Diner

💬 112 reviews

📍 10 Lonesome Rd

Benny's Ice Cream

Benny's Ice Cream

💬 142 reviews

📍 2933 Rt. 28

Five Corners Cafe

Five Corners Cafe

💬 571 reviews

📍 3067 State Route 28

Candy Cottage

Candy Cottage

💬 156 reviews

📍 3031 Main Street Old Forge

Wisk Baking Company

Wisk Baking Company

💬 102 reviews

📍 117 Crosby Blvd

Mary Lou's Pizza

Mary Lou's Pizza

📍 843 S Main St

Cafe Rinaldi

💬 1709 reviews

📍 426 S Main St

Misters Bistro

Misters Bistro

💬 172 reviews

📍 Main Street

Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill

Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill

American Bar Barbecue

💬 404 reviews

📍 5074 State Route 28

Keen Kitchen Cafe

Keen Kitchen Cafe

💬 56 reviews

📍 3067 State Route 28

Anthony's Restaurant

Anthony's Restaurant

💬 565 reviews

📍 202 S Main St

Billy G's

Billy G's

💬 61 reviews

📍 112 South Main Street

Bella Faccias Personalized Chocolates & Gifts

💬 17 reviews

📍 512 S Main St

Domino's Pizza

💬 251 reviews

📍 213 N Main St

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 26 Bar 12 Italian 12 Pizza 11 Pub 8 Fast Food 4 Cafe 3 Diner 2 Mexican 2 Soups 2 Barbecue 1 French 1 Grill 1 Seafood 1 Sushi 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

22 Browsable Menus

📅

Dec 2025 Last Updated