Benny's Ice Cream
2933 Rt. 28, 13420 - Old Forge
American
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (7)
Photo 1 / 7
100%
Google Reviews (8)
Wonderful reasonably priced ice cream! The owner and the girl working there were super nice too.
Google
Good ice cream, plenty of benches and tables for seating in a pretty small area. Fair price and the woman working both nights we came was so friendly.
Google
Very Good Ice Cream. Friendly Staff, we stop by several times when on vacation I Old Forge NY. I had to include NY, Because there's a PA, old forge but all they have is pizza. OH. And the Nutty Putty Miniature Golf ⛳ Course is right next Door.. But Definitely Drop by for the Ice Cream
Google
Last summer some friends and I visited Benny’s, and we all had a lovely experience, I’ve been back multiple times since. The service was extremely quick even with a line waiting, and not to mention, the workers were nothing but amazing to us. Locals, tourists, or anyone passing through Old Forge, I highly suggest Benny’s if you’re looking for great service and ice cream!
Read more
Google
All the kids played mini golf and their ice cream looked excellent
Google
This is a nice place. On our recent trip they had the order incorrect multiple times but it is still pretty decent. During Coronafest most everyone in line has a mask on so it's pretty good. They do have a $300 five gallon soft ice cream Sunday which requires 2 hours notice. I have never witnessed it. I'd go to DiOrio's Grocery store across the street and get 5 gallons of ice cream for 30 bucks first 🤣a
Read more
Google
Great little ice cream place. It is a small shack with a decent selection of both soft and hard ice cream. There are also specialties such as sundaes. The only bad thing is there is only one employee. Literally because the shack is so small.
Google
The employees are always nice and friendly and the ice cream is always delicious. What more could you want?
Google
📊 Compare with Other Restaurants
| Restaurant | Score | Tripadvisor | Reviews | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pied Piper | 72% | 4.3/5 | 4.0/5 | 375 |
| Pizza Hut | 70% | - | 2.5/5 | 6 |