Best Ice Cream Sandwich in New York City

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Meatball Shop - Hell's Kitchen
The Meatball Shop - Hell's Kitchen
91/100 (1943 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Contemporary
Italian
Gluten Free Options
American
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Balls Biscuits and Gravy
The Kitchen Sink
Sandwiches
Polenta
Chicken Parm Parm Hero
Meatballs
Cavatappi Chicken Pesto
Baguette
Parmesan Cream Balls
Beef
Focaccia
Pesto
Mac'n'Cheese Meatballs
Pork
Lasagna
Pasta
Manhattan
Salad
Ice Cream Sandwich
Risotto
Meatball Sandwich
Seasonal Risotto
Creamy Tomato Soup
Pomegranate Lemonade
Just Meatballs
Sit down
Italian
American
Contemporary
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Wine and Beer
Accepts Discover
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Reservations
Delivery
Seating
Table Service
Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This is one of my favorite places to take out of state people. It's simple but the food is delicious. It's a small place, but the tables turn over..."
Sookram Ramsaroop
"First time here and it didn’t disappoint. I ordered the classic meatball and pasta. The meatballs are very juicy and tasteful. Not salty at all..."
G G
"Love this location very much! Always sit at the bar and regardless of whether it’s day or night I’m always treated well. Today had the ramen..."
Executive Thrillseeker
"Really great meatballs!! The menu is fun and easy to navigate, this is the perfect spot to go to before and after the party!! My only critique is the..."
Benjamin La Madrid
"Hearty and delicious dishes. Made a great First Breakfast the next morning, too. Extra kudos for a killer drink menu and for playing all the best..."
Madeleine Maccar
"Definitely worth the walk/wait/trip or whatever else. Tasty meatballs, options for all but kept it simple and the waitress/bartender was just enough..."
Danielle King
"Spicy pork parmasean cream.....no other words are needed! Top of my happy list and if ever a last meal..that is definitely on the list. If this..."
Kevin Morris
"I love this place. Their meatballs and sauces are great. But my favorite is their ice cream sandwiches! The vanilla ice cream is..."
Ravi Tulsi
"Always delicious! Over estimated how much we could eat though, it was good to have leftovers for later. One thing is my food was slightly on the cold..."
Helen Fong
"Came here late night. Had the naked classic balls with pesto. Really really good! Liked the pine nuts with the pesto, which added a nice crunch to..."
Robbie Shaw
"Tasty Meatballs- Be sure to try the Buffalo Chicken ones! Super Friendly staff and easy ordering menu. Kid friendly and easy to..."
David Romaine
"Cozy place. Great meatballs. Had the spicy pork balls and spicy meat sauce on pasta.. they were pretty great. Place is pricy.. but I'm not used to..."
KyleRappa
"I ate the pork meatballs with parmesan sauce over risotto. It was AMAZING. I washed it down with the rose sangria. The staff was warm, I was..."
Roz Mays
"Great food. Good service. Amazing taste in music. Love eating..."
J Cheverez
"The most delicious meatball sandwich I’ve ever had. Perfectly cooked meatballs, delicious rich sauce on a crusty roll. Will definitely be..."
C K
"The specials of the day can be a hit or miss... Everything else is fairly consistent "Everything but the kitchen sink" is my go to order... The wait..."
Raymond Yip
"I wasn't sure what to expect for brunch but it didn't disappoint! A little crowded but worth the..."
Stephanie Grossman
"I liked the simplicity of the menu and the assortment of options when it came to selecting the meatballs and sauce. Definitely made it easier to..."
Haramritjot Singh (Haram the Milkman)
Jolly Goat Coffee Bar
Jolly Goat Coffee Bar
91/100 (786 ratings)
Coffee & Tea
Coffee & Tea
Cafe
Cafe
Breakfast
Smoked Salmon
Ice Cream Sandwich
Iced Chai Latte
Sea Salt Caramel
2 Oz dbl Espresso
Toasted Bagel with Salted Butter
Cold Brew on Tap Iced Coffee
Bagels
Hot Caramel Macchiato & Croissant
Flat White
Goat Coffee Bar
Iced tea
Quad Oatmilk Latte
Lovelvet
Café
Café
Takeout
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"My favorite coffee shop in NYC. Friendly staff, amazing coffee, and a lovely bagel. Also- the music is delightful. ..."
Colleen DeFour
"The coffee is fantastic! My favorite place in Hell’s..."
Juan Munguia
"Granola & coffee � intimate friendly place elderberry..."
Diane Ponder
"Possibly the best espresso-based drinks I've ever had. Great, friendly..."
Steve Burch
"Clearly the best coffee I had in all NYC - I highly recommend..."
Glenn Turnbull
"Friendly people, great coffee! � Love the decor as well! Lots of charm, much better than the..."
Christine Doud Ledger
"What a little gem of a place. Obviously a locals bar. It was a fun find in a crowded city. Oh, and the flat white was..."
Graeme Ward
"This is the best coffee you can get in NYC, no..."
Henry Shymonovych
"Excellent coffee and really nice staff. Reasonable..."
Marina Privorotsky
"Best coffee in NYC so far. A great little spot to get a coffee hit and chill out at the same time...."
Linda Hall
"Beautiful tasting of coffee and nice latte..."
Ai-Ting Chiu
"Notre nouvelle adresse fétiche avant de partir à la découverte de Manhattan..."
Elsa Orus-plana
"Fantastic bagels coffee and service. ..."
Susan English
"Really loved the JG! Coffee was delicious and it was small but cozy. Looking forward to another..."
George A. Rodrique
"Legit. They have good espresso, hot employees. they were bumping Kendrick when I went in there. 10/10 would go..."
Joanna Leah
"Cute coffee shop with excellent coffee! They make amazing granola, I even had them ship a few bags for me as holiday gifts. My go to coffee in the..."
Taylor Krause
"A barista was very very busy today but he stayed positive and he tried his best!!! Really appreciated his work, coffee was made really nice and..."
Yana
"The cashier was so nice, everything was reasonably priced for new york prices. Croissant was so good, very flakey, the cream cheese everything bagel..."
None No
"Best coffee in New York. I order an espresso macchiato from coffee shops to check quality (nowhere to hide with those). But omg, they delivered...."
Nigel Hanson
"Had a great time at the Jolly Goat! Their H&H bagels are fantastic and the smoked salmon is so fresh! We enjoyed their cold brew and the chai latte..."
Michael Guertin
"Local coffee stand with character! They use local Brooklyn Urban Roasters beans. Pretty standard list of coffee drinks, not many fancy preparations,..."
John a
"Great coffee, great barista, still New York prices, but OK for the city. I loved the ambiance and the decor of the coffee..."
Lilou
"Great little coffee shop serving stumptown brews using lamorzocco linea for espresso & selection of pourovers (chemex/kalita) + nitro cold brew..."
Omer Moghraby
"Coffee was perfect, not too sweet (which is #1 for me, the vanilla latte was great), and the barista was so kind. Definitely hope to come here again..."
Ariana Denni
"Small place with minimal seating BUT the coffee is great and the guy who made my coffee was very nice. It was a nice change from the grumpy people at..."
Isabel
"Awesome little spot. Not sure the guys name who served me every morning but he was great. I even bought the growler so I can always remember the..."
Marco Rinaldi
"Coffee was great, small spot and seems to have a line most of the time. Worth the..."
Robert Torres
"Great coffee. Small selection of good quality drinks and pastry. Coffee (Americano) is not too bitter - just the way I like it. Very small place -..."
Dejan Kulpinski
"Small, local coffee shop in Hell's Kitchen. They roast their beans. They also know a LOT about coffee. Ask them all the things. The coffee is pretty..."
Daniel Tasman
"Great cute tiny place, for coffee lovers and much more, always plant based milk, and some space to sit..."
Sonia Givray
Kochi
Kochi
91/100 (587 ratings)
Restaurants
Asian
Korean
Asian
Korean
Dinner
Vinegar-Cured Mackerel Onion Soubise Gamtae Mugwort Dashima Glaze
King Salmon Bbimbap
Korean Espresso Martini
Shrimp Twigim
Pork Belly
Pumpkin soup
Short Rib
Kimchi
Ice Cream Sandwich
Scallop
Squash
Red wine
Bossam
soju
Froyo
matcha
Halibut
Pine Nut Soup
Asian
Korean
Seating
Table Service
Gift Cards Available
Reservations
Dinner
Cheap Eats
The Meatball Shop
The Meatball Shop
90/100 (2083 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Meatballs
Sandwiches
Baguette
Lasagna
Manhattan
Beef
Ice Cream Sandwich
Meatball Sandwich
Seasonal Risotto
Creamy Tomato Soup
Pasta
Pomegranate Lemonade
Salad
Just Meatballs
Risotto
Balls Biscuits and Gravy
The Kitchen Sink
Chicken Parm Parm Hero
Cavatappi Chicken Pesto
Parmesan Cream Balls
Mac'n'Cheese Meatballs
Polenta
"The staff at meatball shop is always so welcoming and entertaining! They recently upgraded their menu and rolled it out at this location; so happy we..."
Andrea Connors
"Came here as second option due to wait times at another place but we were so glad we came here! Service was very quick and sandwiches were much..."
jeremy bouchard
"Expensive, but worth every penny. I got the spaghetti and meatballs, not too much spaghetti but I never knew I needed meatballs with pesto sauce in..."
Sanchit Batra
"Sunday brunch was perfect. Comfy and cozy. Drinks on key! Meatballs, salad, cauliflower, etc...all perfecto! Great meatball sampler. Kids were happy..."
John Lee
"ThiS place was amazing !!! I had their Parmesan classic meatball. you can order it with a side in case you want to eat more than just four..."
Jacqueline Aguilar
"Food was fine. Some what comforting but a bit salty. I've cream and cookies were better than the meatballs. Service was very good. We stayed for 2..."
J
"The meatball shop in Chelsea. If you love the meatballs this is the place to go. The service was quick and easy. The menu is very practical, easy..."
stephen raynolds
"This is a really good place. It's a good place to walk into because you want to see a menu and then a guy walks up to you and asks you if you've..."
Justin Schwartz
"First time here. The food was amazing. The service was top notch. Food came out quick. Must save room for dessert, the snickerdoodle cookie with..."
Vincent Lam
"Great atmosphere very friendly and laid back staff. Love the tailored menu and the side options. Additional plus that they source..."
Marie Richard
"We came in about 30 minutes before close in November. We were the only people in the restaurant and felt awful so we sat at the bar and the bartender..."
Angelle Bevier
"Not at all what I expected. I was in Times Square and had heard about The Meatball Shop. We walked up to Hell's Kitchen to their location but that..."
Evan
"I spend a lot of time in Chelsea but this was first time trying out The Meatball Shop. I had a Moscow Mule to start which was very good though did..."
Rob Myles
"Yummmmmm should say it all! So the large seat is family style. Your very well may not know yourneighbor next to you and that’s fine. It’s NYC..."
Andrea W
"New menu is amazing! They’re so great with dietary restrictions, and I couldn’t recommend them more. Great for takeout,..."
Alison Yuhas
Melt Bakery
Melt Bakery
88/100 (440 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Lunch
Ice Cream Sandwich
Sandwiches
Taiyaki
Peanut Butter Cookies
76'Er
Ice Cream
Muffin
whoopie pie
Sit down
American
Takeout
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Mint ice cream tastes homemade - not too sweet. Chocolate chip cookie is delicious and warm. Service was friendly. We will be..."
Roberta Piket
"All I can say is yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum! We had the red velvet today at The High Line and it was amazing :) My husband is actually on the website now..."
Tracie Smith
"I Had the cinnamax he had the classic... Both were..."
Trena Hill
"This company rocks!!! I'm from out of town, Waaaay out of town, and just curiously emailed them about ordering cookies and the whatnots and was able..."
Ellen McCraw
"Great Place for summer sweet treats. The most amazing Ice Cream..."
Kyma TheDiva
"You'd be a FOOL not to fall in love with melt..."
Vicky Modica
"All I can say is..."
Heather Ziehl-Fitch
"Fantastic ice cream sandwiches that couple unique..."
Lesley Sigall
"Great service and interesting choice of ice-cream sandwiches at $5 each. Their Mocha flavoured ice-cream sandwich was amazing, however the Cinnamax..."
Irena Savchenko
"Stopped by for a snack, on a beautiful 90 degree day. All of our ice cream sandwiches were delicious — the cookies were soft and the ice cream was..."
Melissa O'Connor
"The ice cream sandwiches are delicious. Well made, substantial for the price - overall worth the..."
John Angarano
"They make ice cream sandwiches! They are about 8 different options, each with a different type of cookie and ice cream flavor. You can't mix and..."
Jon71992
"Their presence in Hester Street Fair last year brought many of fans, and their ice cream sandwiches did not disappoint at all. PHENOMENAL sandwiches..."
Aristotle
"Creative and delicious ice cream sandwiches! I tried the variation with snicker doodle and cinnamon ice cream--it tasted like Cinnamon Toast Crunch..."
Rob Yu
"Been to several of their carts in the city. Wonderful full of flavor and the cookies are crisp and match well with the flavors of ice cream. Not sure..."
Kevin Chan
Schmackary's
Schmackary's
83/100 (5698 ratings)
Quick Bites
Coffee & Tea
Dessert
Bakeries
Coffee & Tea
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Oreo
Bakery
Iced coffee
Ice Cream Sandwich
Banana
Iced Latte
Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut Butter Cookie
Carrot Cake
Cookies and Milk
Red Velvet Cookies
6 Cookies
Caramel Apple Crisp
Dirty Peppermint
Cookie Butter Cookie Sweet Corn Cookie Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Carrot Cake
Sch'Mores Cookie
Maple Bacon Cookies
Oatmeal Scotchie
Cupcakes
Macarons
Macaroons
Cakes
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Cheap Eats
"Worth the wait! Lots of delicious cookies to choose from. Reasonable pricing. They stay fresh too - two days later they were still soft and..."
Jackie Fiedler
"Solid cookie spot with some charm. While I do prefer the other places in the city for a cookie fix, this is higher in quality than let’s say..."
Alcy Leyva
"Great cookies. I’ve had most but the dirty peppermint is the best. Great chocolate cookie with just the right amount of frosting and peppermint..."
Dan Wunderli
"Where I am: @Schmackary's . Location Reviewed: 362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036 . Menu Includes: Cookies, coffees, milkshakes . Items..."
Harry Sandhu
"Words can’t describe the fulfilling flavor that Schmackary’s delivers to your taste buds. It was so good I had to comeback a second time only to..."
Kevin Sapp
"Amazing customer service. Amazing cookies. Super cute inside and out. One of the best cookies I have ever had. I ordered the funfetti one and my..."
Libby Conn
"The Wizards brew cookies (butter scotch) is one of the best you may try aswell as the oatmeal..."
Naser
"In the heart of the bustling city lies a small but mighty cookie haven that could easily be Cookie Monster's dream come true. The place may be..."
Eric Amaral
"Visited this store whilst on vacation from the U.K. and loved it so much we ended up visiting daily! The staff are incredibly lovely and the cookies..."
Alex Smith
"Our first stop as soon as we arrive in NYC. Best cookies..."
Tina Holt
"ordered at their website. choose 2 day shipping. Schmackary's Christmas cookies arrived in 2 days. Chilled the cookies in the refrigerator. Ginger..."
google user
"Went for ice cream but I went too late. Fortunately, instead, they had a 2 for 1 cookie sale. These were some of the best cookies I have ever had...."
Damion Browne
"Really neat little place, they had candied bacon cookie which was my favorite and tbh I can't wait to go try more flavors. I also had the cookies and..."
M B
"Amazing cookies and even better people! Max guided us through the best cookies and the funfetti one was the best along with the oatmeal scotch and..."
Geoffrey Zureikat
"Employees are really pleasant and helpful. The cookies are super delicious fresh and can be restored to their former glory very easily by reheating...."
Dani S
"The person who served us was absolutely adorable, the cookies were delicious and not overpriced at all, the chai latte was tasty although a bit too..."
Pauline
"Good traditional style cookie not oversized, many flavors to choose from, plus a few good GF cookies 🍪 to choose..."
Steven Deollas
Eggloo
Eggloo
75/100 (2647 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fusion
Fusion
Central Asian
Central Asian
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Iced coffee
Ice Cream Sandwich
Strawberry Ice Cream
Green Tea Ice Cream
Oreos
Bubble Waffles
Gelato
Strawberry Waffle Sundae
Campfire S'Mores
Berry Summer Float
Oreo Waffle Cone
Green Tea Bubble Waffle
Ice Cream Egg Waffle
Waffles
Original Waffle with Pumpkin Ice Cream in the Shape of a Flower
Eggloo Cone
Ice Cream
Cookies & Cream with Whipped Cream Coconut Flakes and Caramel Drizzle
Ice Cream w Mochi
Pizza
Affogato
Fast food
Fusion
Central Asian
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
"The shop has two tables and one island for indoor dining. Its relatively small. Decor is nice and modern. Menu is on a tv. The egg waffles were..."
Eric Rivera
"Although the place is a little small, it’s one of those spots in the city where once you indulge, you’ll be absolutely glad that you did. And the..."
T S
"Talk about a hidden gem. Found this place after coming across an Instagram post about it and had to try. The only thing better than ice cream, is ice..."
Vicky Conroy
"A little EGGcentric for an ice cream @myeggloo uses bubble waffles as their cones for their amazing ice cream creations, similar to Hong Kong style...."
Arielle Barr
"Small store that's easy to miss on the side of the street. It seems like they're known for the ice cream and egg waffle combo but I just wanted a..."
Ian Chou
"I wasn't expecting much, but came out given all the instagrammable hype. What surprised me the most wasn't the waffles, which were good but they were..."
Steve M
"Awesome awesome awesome!!! Find this plug you love ice Cream Find this place if you love waffles Move here if you love both. This is a hidden gem..."
Dwayne Banks
"Amazing!!! And the waffle tastes even better, just like heavenly taste, so delicious also try the rose one and don't take any syrups the syrups..."
Tasha Ruhi