Worth the wait!
Lots of delicious cookies to choose from. Reasonable pricing.
They stay fresh too - two days later they were still soft and tasty.
Solid cookie spot with some charm. While I do prefer the other places in the city for a cookie fix, this is higher in quality than let’s say Insomnia. I liked the service and the ambience inside. Small space so not many places to eat, but good for a grab and go. Coffee and drinks served as well
Great cookies. I’ve had most but the dirty peppermint is the best. Great chocolate cookie with just the right amount of frosting and peppermint crumbles. Good price. Just grab yourself a cookie
Where I am: @Schmackary's
.
Location Reviewed: 362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
.
Menu Includes:
Cookies, coffees, milkshakes
.
Items Reviewed;
Apple caramel cookie - LOVE IT!
Oreo milkshake - DECENT
Their Apple caramel cookie -$3.75
Oreo milkshake - around $12
The cookie was fantastic. Crispy and flavorful. Would definitely go back and try more of the flavors.
The Oreo shake was average. Tasted quite similar to the one you can get at a five guys.
.
Customer Service: On Point!!
.
Online Navigation: Easy
.
Parking:Rough
.
Recommendations: Apple Caramel cookie
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️=LOVE IT
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️➕=LIKE THAT
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️=DELICIOUS
⭐️⭐️⭐️=DECENT
⭐️⭐️=PASS
⭐️=NAH
Words can’t describe the fulfilling flavor that Schmackary’s delivers to your taste buds. It was so good I had to comeback a second time only to find out they had different items that I did not see the day before. I had the Cereal Krispy Treat, Carmel Blondie, Oreo Cookie, Dos Leche Cookie, Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie, and S’mores Cookie that left me hankering for some mores cookies.
Amazing customer service. Amazing cookies. Super cute inside and out. One of the best cookies I have ever had. I ordered the funfetti one and my daughter got the oreo. Will definitely be back the next time I am in NYC.
The Wizards brew cookies (butter scotch) is one of the best you may try aswell as the oatmeal cookies
In the heart of the bustling city lies a small but mighty cookie haven that could easily be Cookie Monster's dream come true. The place may be compact, but it's bursting with flavors and warmth, much like a cookie fresh out of the oven. The staff here deserves a special shoutout for their superpower of keeping the line moving faster than Cookie Monster says "Me want cookie!"
As for the cookies, oh, they're good – so good that you might start wondering if they've secretly hired the Cookie Monster as their taste tester. Each cookie is a delightful blend of crunch and chew, with flavors so rich and satisfying that you can't help but feel a little bit mischievous, like you've just snuck into a cookie jar.
From classic chocolate chip to some excitingly unique flavors, this shop proves that good things indeed come in small packages. It's the perfect spot for anyone in NYC looking to indulge their inner Cookie Monster. Just remember to share – or not; we won't judge! 🍪👀
Visited this store whilst on vacation from the U.K. and loved it so much we ended up visiting daily! The staff are incredibly lovely and the cookies are insane! The cookies here a must have if you are visiting NYC. When Schmackary’s goes international I hope Hyde Park Corner is the first international location, it will go down a treat (excuse the pun)!
Our first stop as soon as we arrive in NYC. Best cookies around
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes