What fantastic consideration, products and service! We inadvertently walked into this restaurant as tourists, (and dressed as such!), at the end of a Monday lunch service, but were still welcomed in and treated like family. Fantastic wine selection. We were treated to a special sample of the Broccoli Rabe, which is unbelievable. Highly recommended establishment
Great in every respect. It is as good as the best in Milan
Take a step back in time! The service here is what truly separates the spot from other restaurants! You are greeted like an old family friend and given the specials by your uncle! It was great! The food was inspired by rustic classic Italian fare and did not skip a beat!
Great food, salad salty but still delicious. Service was off their game, got wrong order (which was corrected) and waited 20 minutes for menus. They were clearly short staffed, but still very nice and attentive.
Lunch entree was awesome - portion more than enough.
One regret, can’t blame San Pietro for, was it was super loud. Good for celebratory meal, not so much for a getting to know you meal where I had to strain to hear my tables words.
Very expensive. I’d go back in heartbeat so long as I can expense lunch!
one of the best Italian restaurant in NewYork delicious food, excellent service and good seating.the waiter called the chef personally to be sure of our order as we decided to change the meal ingredients.prices reasonable for the quality &quantity 😀 😋
Classic Italian restaurant experience. I like the mature waiters willing to say "let me just bring you our best wine pairing for your dinner". And it's an experience just to listen to the 16 specials detailed then summarized in reverse order. We had lamb, pasta, and branzino. All well prepared. Pasta was fresh made and a highlight. Branzino is a house speciality and also exceptional. Lamb was tasty, if one minor complaint it would be that we ordered medium rare and the lamb was well done. That said, overall a delightful experience I'd recommend to anyone.
Very lovely place, the food was amazing ! No big sign outside so it's across from a parking garage..Also they did seem a bit stern in regards to having a reservation (and we did) which I found a little odd as it was a bit late and the place was mostly empty ..so not so warm and friendly..and pricey..but would definitely go again !
Delicious menu and drink, a must if you live in NY. Best place outside if Italy for sure. Get the veal and the Grappa!
Authentic Italian food. Simple, fresh ingredients with a lot of flavor. Impressive wine list.
Great. Very good place . Is the only top notch Italian restaurant in nyc ,is the only one surviving.Gerardo ,Manuele ,Jonny,frank. Etc. thank you guys see you soon for Tartufo and Barolo
A place that definitely I recommend to the lovers of Italian cuisine. The food was amazing and the staff very welcoming. I will definitely go back 😍
Long overdue review. Unbelievable experience. I don't normally take the time to post restaurant reviews but I had to for this one. I took a lot into account. Cleanliness, decor, ambiance, staff and of course...the food. I've been to Italy once and I can honestly say the feeling I got walking in there simulated that experience like no other restaurant I've been to. You can tell the owner was meticulous about creating an experience and not just a place to dine. The staff was unbelievably friendly and was very attentive. It was beyond professional...it was personal. They sincerely wanted to ensure I was enjoying myself and that I was pleased. The service was quick and the food was spectacular. The owner came down and spoke to us as well. You could see the passion and love he has for creating such a magnificent experience. I am looking forward to visiting as soon as this quarantine is over.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes