Lazzara's Pizza Cafe

The service & food here are outstanding. Not only did the host go above and beyond with the entire process, even though we unknowingly walked in right before closing, but the food here is unbelievable and a must try if you’re in Manhattan. Pizza is an untraditional square slice, and it might seem a little expensive for the quantity of the slices, but WOW is it good!! Penne vodka was out of this world as well. We ended up taking it to go since they were closing, even though the host insisted it was fine to stay, but if they were still open I would be walking back to get some more. A++ restaurant and would definitely be back, only recommendation is eat the pizza right away or at the restaurant.

The margarita looks absolutely crazy. I was very hesitant when I saw it, and really wasn't expecting much. The pizza was tasty though!!!! The cheese was good and the sauce was acidic and salty - in a good way. With that being said the true shining star of Lazzara's Pizza Cafe was the arancini. By far one of the tastiest things I've ever eaten. I honestly can't believe how good it was. It came sitting in tomato sauce but was still nice and crispy on the outside. Come to Lazzara's for the pizza, but get the arancini for sure.

What a gem this place is! We came across it accidently and remembered seeing a review on it, so we went up....and we're kit disappointed. Definitely artisan, and definitely fantastic! Rich and smooth sauce you could taste the freshness of on a super light and crispy crust with perfect sauce to cheese to crust ratio. Will come back again!

We came here based on Bar Stool (Dave’s) pizza review. It was great, but not as amazing as I thought based on the rating. I fully respect Daves's reviews as I'm from New Haceb CT and agree with his ratings there. I think he was a bit overhyped based on the cool atmosphere. That said food and location were great!