Old Homestead Steakhouse

Old Homestead Steakhouse in NYC offers a delightful experience with its inviting ambience, impeccable service, and delectable food. The atmosphere exudes classic charm, creating a perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. The attentive staff adds to the overall positive impression, ensuring guests feel well taken care of throughout their visit. The menu boasts a selection of high-quality steaks, cooked to perfection, catering to discerning palates. However, it's worth noting that the price point is on the higher side, reflecting the premium quality of both the ingredients and the dining experience. If you're willing to indulge in a lavish steakhouse experience, Old Homestead delivers on all fronts, making it a noteworthy choice for special occasions.

Very poor selection of champagne by the glass or half bottles. Proseco is not champagne. The chopped salad was perfect. Nicely tossed with dressing not drowned! Dry Aged sirloin for two was exceptional! Perfectly prepared. However, we ordered the sauce trio and they arrived cold as did the hashbrowns. The hashbrowns were "refrigerator" cold on the inside. Key Lime pie was excellent.

We just happened upon Old Homestead after getting into town and what a great surprise to find such a gem! The ambiance is just perfect for a bustling place and the waitstaff are just wonderful. George took care of us this evening and the recommendations and execution of the overall meal was impeccable. Everything on our plates just kept getting more delicious as we ate. We had the colossal shrimp to start and 4 apiece was too much but we made it through. My wife had the filet and lobster tale and I had the Barrel Cut Filet which were two of the best on the menu. Cremé brûlée and espresso for dessert capped off the meal perfectly. Would highly recommend Old Homestead Steakhouse to anyone!

This place is a classic! Too bad I waited so long to come here. Food was excellent and considering prices today, it was fair for what you get. Sat in the library room which was nice and quiet until it fills up but it was still pleasant. I assume it's better upstairs than downstairs. I'll definitely go back.