Angelo's Pizza

First night in NYC and this was a must on our list. The pizza is delicious and a must have. The sauce is soooo good and the toppings are just as good. Pizza is fresh, cooked to perfection, not soggy! Pretty good wine selection too! Customer service was great and we were seated quickly. You have to stop by and won't be disappointed!

Not sure if you would typically need a reservation but we were here over the Thanksgiving holiday so we had to wait (without a reservation) maybe 15-20 minutes for a table but it was well worth it. Their prices are typical for NYC but the pepperoni pizza... Amazing! 10/10. The staff is very nice as well!

This pizza was the BEST pizza we have ever had!!!!!! We thought we were just getting some quick regular pizza. We walk in, and it is set up like a fancy Italian restaurant. Don't worry though, it was still quick! We were in and out in about 40 minutes. We sat upstairs, which was very nice. We got the old-fashioned margarita pizza with the mozzarella sticks as our appetizer. I can say we were flabbergasted by the fact that the mozzarella sticks were $13 when we only got THREE! That seemed to just be ridiculously overpriced compared to everything else on the menu. I can say we will be getting them again! If they were cheaper, we probably would have gotten another order of them as well. But seriously, 3? Anyway, the service was great, our waitress was very attentive, and all 3 of us agreed it was the best pizza by far. Coal oven cooking is the way to go. We will be coming back next time we go to the theater as this is very close by.