Angelo's Pizza

Food/Pizza: Dined here due to incredibly high reviews on their pizza. The pizza crust was perfectly crisp with little to no flop. Only note is we felt it could have been a little bit more flavorful (seemed to be light on the sauce/cheese). Overall fantastic pizza and would recommend if a good crust is most important to you. Other Info: The place was packed when we arrived and we had a short wait. The service was pretty average for the crowd, but the tables felt a little cramped. Also with a full restaurant, the 2 restrooms have quite a long wait and the line flows into the top dining room which can lead to some tables being hovered over.

Found this place through a google search… best google search I’ve ever made. Amazing, amazing, amazing food and amazing service as well! This is hands down the best coal fired pizza I have ever had. We came in around 8:30 on a Friday, got seated immediately, and were immediately greeted by our server. Service was quick and attentive without being overbearing. Now.. the food.. oh my goodness. The pizza was perfect, along with the meatballs. The sauce was perfect, not too sweet and not too heavy at all. If you’re in the area, the walk is worth it for Angelo’s.

One of the best coal fired pizzas in NYC. If you are a fan of coal fired pizza, you must give Angelo's Pizza a try. The sauce is incredible - a hearty, robust style sauce with a touch of sweet. It's perfect. The crust- also excellent. Soft yet crispy with the perfect amount of char. I typically judge a new pizza by first trying cheese only, but I went with half cheese, half pep/sausage this time and I'm so glad I did. My experience was fantastic. Service and atmosphere were perfect. Very Italian, pizzeria ambiance. Will definitely be back.

We were lucky enough to stay in a hotel very close to this pizza spot. Great and fast service, friendly atmosphere and it was packed with lots of people but we were able to get in without a reservation. The pizza is delicious and very authentic, great crust. Would recommend the pepperoni pizza and the cannoli for dessert!

We came here because we heard it was some of the best pizza in New York. They were right. This pizza was ridiculous. We got the white pie which is different cheeses. My husband never eats ‘just a cheese pizza’ but this was so good we couldn’t stop eating it. We also got a sausage and mushroom pizza that was also made perfectly. You have to go here!!

This was my very first pizza I had in New York. After trying all the “best“ pizza places in New York. This place is probably still my favorite. I absolutely love the sauce. The service is always excellent. The waitresses are extremely friendly. The restaurant is clean and definitely has an authentic Italian feel to it. I can only review the pizza because it’s so good. I can’t bring myself to try something else if I ever do I’ll review that as well but for now, I’ll just say the pizza is outstanding. Paul