Lexington Candy Shop

Overall I liked this place. Nice and relaxed atmosphere, and the traditional Coca-Cola float with vanilla ice-cream is a must if you are nearby. Food is good, we tried three different sandwiches (one with tuna, one with chicken and one with beef), but average. Nothing special, especially if compared to its quite high price. Staff were super friendly.

The floats here taste just as good and cool as they look. I’m not sure how else to get a more authentic soda, so good luck trying. This place has been around almost 100 years and has the backbone to prove it. I felt pretty cool sitting somewhere that had so much history while also enjoying the best Cherry Coke Float I’ve ever had in my life. Thank you so much!

Lexington Candy Shop is a nostalgic oasis on the Upper East Side, a charming throwback to classic diners. The vintage decor and soda fountain counter evoke a bygone era, creating a unique and cozy atmosphere. The menu is a delightful journey through comfort food, with their milkshakes and old-fashioned sundaes stealing the show. It's not just a meal; it's a step back in time. If you crave a taste of retro New York charm and a sweet treat, Lexington Candy Shop is a hidden gem worth discovering.

Typical American old school diner vibes with a bunch of breakfast and sweet options. Especially famous for their old-fashioned Cola including a scoop of vanilla ice cream, which tasted surprisingly good. You are eating enough calories for an entire week here, just as a fair warning. Right next to Tal Bagels, one of my favorite bagel spits in NYC

Amazing restaurant, they are very friendly but please note as the place is not that big you might need to wait for 5-10mins to be seated on a normal day or longer is there is line. Must try and my favourite is the old fashioned style of coke, with other options as well. One of the best sandwich I have in New York City too.

A decoration from the middle of the last century, it accompanies the traditional service of soda with the nectar of coca cola, in a preparation that deserves a visit. The variety of adding cream ice cream in the glass has fans and detractors. My opinion is that you have to try before taking a position!

I found this place online and had to try it! We went on a Sunday morning and feared a long waiting time but there were few people. We were seated and helped by a very friendly waitress. The place is so authentic, after having been to Starbucks, McDo etc. it was a real treat to be thrown back into time, enjoying a real american breakfast, with great service. The pancakes were huge and very nice, we could easily have shared them. A great experience on our last day in NYC. I hope this place never gets sold or changed! Highly recommended.