Never judge a book by its cover, the outside is nothing special unlike their pizzas which are amazing, the best we have ever tasted 🍕🍕and we've tasted a few. Definitely worth a visit, can't recommend it highly enough 👏👏
Easily some of the best pizza in the city. I love the sausage and red peppers. I NEVER order those things on a pizza but here at Waldy’s it’s amazing!
Yum yum! Delicious pizza at a good value! It’s easy to see why Wally’s gets such a great rating. We needed a snack before checking into our hotel and this place hits the spot!
This pizza joint was right around the corner from our hotel, and we had to try it. They don't serve boring round pizzas - theirs are shaped like oars (of different lengths), and they'll put just about anything on them!
the crust is thin and tasty, and the pizza comes out really quick.
The girl behind the counter was very patient with us, because we couldn't figure out what we wanted to do, but when the food came out, it was fantastic! It was so good, both families that were there bought another one to take back to the hotel for later (or breakfast the next morning)!
Thoroughly recommend.
Beautiful Pizza is how I can describe the delicious margarita pizza. Thin, crisp and yummy. Lovely crust, not chewy at all. A must eat if you love Pizza.
So good! We ordered the classic margharita with pepperoni and it was delicious. The wine was very good also(trapiche from mendoza argentina)
Would go back 4sure
Chicken with Bacon and Chipotle Peppers Pizza. Super thin, super crispy cracker crust.
I ate here 3 times in 8 days! Translate that to scrumptious! It was near to my HGI hotel, that is how I chose this shop the first day. It was so delicious with its wood fired taste, I was in love wirh the flavor. Atmosphere relaxed. All sorts of creative combination toppings, different than the midwestern selections I am accustomed to. You even get to chop onto your own pizza some fresh herbs rish from their live herb selection. I will be back on my next trip to NYC! Might I alao add, besides the great pizza, it is a great value!! Staff friendly and accomidating, as well. A+
Waldy's Pizza. I'm a native from Brooklyn, but I've been living in New Oleans for the past 20 years. Let me tell you as an old native, this is great pizza. I'm not kidding when I say you can close your eyes and pretend you're in Italy. Just a little place so eating in can be a problem. We were staying at the Double Tree in Chelsea so it worked out perfectly. I wish this was a chain.
Awesome thin crust pizza...but who runs out of Pilsner on a Thurs. night in NY!
Best pizza I've had in NYC. Friendly staff. Great place!
It was very delicious! We had the chickeb chipotle large for the three of us. Bit hot and spicy, but very very delicious!
Fantastic taste and fresh ingredients.. I would give this place a 5 star for food but 3 star for dine in.. the place needs tidying up and also some furniture upgrades..
as they have wood fired options, there is no option for a slice.. there small pizza which serves one is also of good size so its a super value for money. i had the Margherita pizza.
they so give free drink on dine in if u order between 11-4pm
The pizza had the thinnest crust that I ever seen. The crust was as crispy and thin as matzo. The sauce, mozzarella, goat cheese, garlic, & mushrooms on my custom pie were delicious. There is no restroom available here and the dining area leaves much to be desired. It may be a good idea to plan carryout or delivery from this place.
If you find yourself in midtown Manhattan craving a slice, Waldy's is a great spot. The restaurant feels comfortable and their staff are extremely friendly! Pizza was delicious, served hot. If you're coming to visit on a summer day be prepared to sweat because they don't have AC. But the pizza was worth it!
Freshly baked and very affordable for the quality of pizza they serve! They also prepare it fast too. Had an enjoyable meal with their pepperoni pizza with broccoli and will definitely be back for more! Delicious 🤤
Very welcome staff, good place to eat thin crust pizza... may be they should use another cheese type to make more delicious. Good prices.
One of the best pizzas I’ve tried in NYC! Amazing taste and staff is nice and helpful.
Jackie Shaab (AbiteOUTwithJACK)
+5
Follow me on Instagram @AbiteOUTwithJACK
This place SUCKS if you're looking for a New York 99cent slice...
If you're looking for the freshest, tastiest, thinnest, yummiest pizza... This is your spot!
Fried eggplant, zucchini and olives!
I'm drooling from this post...
BTW... Pizza in the photo is the pizza for two... (I ate the whole thing!)
JS10!!! I can't wait to do it again!
Waldy is seriously our favorite place in NYC! Any pizza combo is good; and the Caesar salad too. Everything is so fresh and tasty. We 2 people easily kill the large one and never minded leftovers though that rarely happens.
Good pizza, cheap drinks, nice low-key spot. Love how thin the pizza crusts are also, and the toppings options are varied and all very good!
Delicious!! Best pizza I had in NYC. Hope it opens again.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes