Connolly's Pub & Restaurant

Really cool and cosy pub. We sat in the main pub because there weren't any tables in the rooftop seating area and we actually preferred it there as the roof top seemed very busy and noisy - not a complaint at all, just wasn't what we were after at the time. I can tell up there is a really cool place to hang out if that's the kind of night you're after. My wife ordered the Gaelic burger and she enjoyed it while I had the potato & leek soup. We also shared some pretzels. Thoroughly enjoyed everything and appreciated the kind and attentive service by our waiter, Cian. I'm from Scotland and it's the kind of place that makes me feel at home. Definitely recommended!

We went on NYC Marathon weekend and the pub was packed with runners. We had reserved a table on a Sunday at 6:30 to listen to live music but the crowd was loud and standing shoulder to shoulder so that it drowned out the musicians. I don't know if this was the Sunday norm or not. However, the servers were exceptionally attentive and the food surprisingly very good. Things started quieting down at 8:00 yet most customers still seemed to ignore the musicians. I am not sure that this is the best venue for music but we had a good enough time and we will try again with later reservations.

Went for a birthday celebration and had a great time. Food was typical bar food and it was good. The fish and chips were delicious, it was battered perfectly with the right amount of crunch. The portion. Size was shareable as well which makes it a good value for the money. Keith is a great bartender and serves the drinks up with smile and light banter which makes you feel like you're at your neighborhood pub and not in Times SQ.

Brighter inside than a typical Irish pub! Service and food were fantastic. Went here on a Saturday night at 6pm and literally got a table without a wait. I had a chicken sandwich with bacon and it was delicious. Fries were cooked perfectly and prices are reasonable for a place in NYC. Definitely worth checking out.