Lots of options for a pretty small place. My sugar free black cherry ice cream was delicious! Creative ice cream desserts that looked yummy were also sold in the freezer.
I'm always greeted with a friendly smile and the service is always courteous.
Whenever we need our chocolate shake fix only one ice cream shop comes to mind...
BRAINFREEZE !
Thanks for keeping us cool all year long.
I love brain freeze! I love the fact that they have a drive-thru which late night is great. The combos that they have for ice cream seem unlimited. And the staff is genuinely friendly and I've never had a problem with them.
Easily my favorite ice cream in Bergen County, NJ! The Cookie Monster flavor is amazing and is my go-to. The ice cream is SO good that I've been door dashing it to my house for three weeks in a row now (lol!)
So happy I finally found my go-to ice cream spot in Bergen County. 1000% recommend.
Decent amount of choices, would be great to have a few more dairy free other than 2 Italian Ice flavors. Also, bring cash for tip, couldn't put it on card and now I feel bad because the workers were very sweet.
Welcoming staff. Sitting area available. Handicap accessible & easy experience
Brain Freeze!
Located in the Madison Plaza strip mall in New Milford this colorful and fun-loving ice cream shop has it all. Including... pause for effect, a drive thru! Really! Yes, it's true!
Serving ice cream, sherbet, Italian ices, ice cream cakes and pies. This place seems like the perfect setting for your child's birthday.
We got shakes, fantastic by the way, which came with a pleasant customer service experience. Would definitely go again!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New Milford
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes