Absolutely amazing pizza, so many fresh ingredients, locally sourced cheese dough made daily. What's not to love? If you're hankering some dessert, their cheese cake is seriously the best I've had in a long time. An astounding meal at such a nice venue. Staff was extremely friendly and attentive.
The food is always awesome, and the staff is super friendly. We really enjoyed ourselves and definitely ate too much!
Great place to grab some great pizza. Amazing drink selection, I counted over 40 beers from 20+ breweries. 15+ specialty pizzas, as well as the option to "build your own". Their take on a buffalo chicken pizza absolutely blew my mind. Mac and cheese pizza is killer too!
Go. Eat pizza. Drink beer.
You won't regret the stop.
Handmade, fresh, absolutely delicious pizza!! Very impressed with everything we ordered! Pizza was amazing- even the wheat crust pizza was amazing!! Clearly take pride in the food. And very friendly service. Extensive beer and wine menu too. Will be back ASAP.
Always great pizza! Outdoor seating along the Sugar River trail is so relaxing. A must if you're visiting or traveling through New Glarus.
Rough Night and Happy New Year!
Last night was a rough night at Sugar River Pizza. They ran out of a few main ingredients and even lost our order. However, that will not be the end of our visits to this amazing restaurant. Each time we have been there the food has been excellent, the staff are great and friendly and the location has been clean. So for all those folks, who were waiting and/or did not get what they thought they wanted last night. Head back, show your support and in this time of hard times for restaurants and local businesses, let's keep supporting our local folks!
Pictures are from a prior visit... GREAT FOOD
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New Glarus
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes