Great Hawaiian pizza which is my husband’s favorite. We also love the Bruschetta pie, the chicken bacon ranch and the white pizza. They make excellent calzones (I always ask for
Extra garlic and spinach), service is always fast and friendly. Place is always very clean.
Pizza was better than expected. Thin crust, crispy and better than most locally on the PA side. Nothing atmosphere wise but no issues. It's a pizza joint!
We get take out from here regularly. It’s reliable, rock solid NY pizza for reasonable prices. Never had any problems with the food or service.
The place has changed. Biggest problem was the owner. Had bad attitude and was very unpleasant. Well that has changed. The owner is no longer rude to people. Great pizza for the area. Give it a try
Most solid pizza place around. Fresh ingriedients and the crust is perfect. No complaints.
This place rocks. Born and raised in Bay Ridge Brooklyn and I can honestly say these guys make the best calzone I ever ate. That's a bold statement. The cheese to dough ratio is perfect. Its filled with delicioucness and the dough is thin but doughie and encases the cheese perfect with a perfect dough to crisp ratio with cheese saturation. The size is perfect. Good lord. There dinners are all fantastic. Pizza everything. Narrowsburg is truly blessed to have this amazing pizzaria right there. I know I am. Keep up the great work Carini.
Best Grandma pizza in the entire world. My favorite pizza place
Carini's Pizzeria is the best pizzeria in Sullivan county. My son who is now going on 12 has loved it since he started teething. When he turned 5-6 he was able to eat almost a whole pizza by himself. I have tried most of their dishes and I have about 3 favorites. The calzones are amazing as well as huge. Linguine and clam sauce is incredible and their baked ziti is fantastic. They are reasonably priced. If you are in Sullivan county you have to try Carini's Pizza!
It may be the only pizza joint in town but luckily for the town it's a great one! I've been a couple of times and always see the same guy. Hes probably the owner because he seems to take great pride in his work. Everything always is cooked great and tastes great. Every time I'm in town I stop by Carini Pizza. Even if it's just for a slice or two, he always seems to have some ready which I love!
Update: this has become a staple at our house. The lasagna and caesar salad are pretty good as well.
If you’re in the mood for a New York style type of pizza, this place is pretty good! Especially if you haven’t been to Manhattan in a while. A large pizza is pretty big. We’ve had luck with pepperoni and mushroom pizza, the caesar salad, and the garlic knots are good not great. Regardless, there aren’t a ton of place in this town to get pizza so if NY style is what you’re looking for, you’ll probably be satisfied with this.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Narrowsburg
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes