🍴 Italian ✕

Italian Restaurants in Monticello

Discover 15 italian restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated August 2026.

🍴

20

Cuisine Types

15 of 15 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Solaia Restaurant

Solaia Restaurant

$$$$ 💬 437 reviews

📍 3317 State Route 42

Monticello Pies

Monticello Pies

Italian American

💬 62 reviews

📍 865 N Jefferson St

Colosseo Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

Colosseo Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

$$ - $$$ 💬 1171 reviews

📍 28 Raceway Rd

Papa Luke's Pizzeria

Papa Luke's Pizzeria

$$ - $$$ 💬 265 reviews

📍 42 Kitz Rd

Thatzza Pizza

Thatzza Pizza

$ 💬 289 reviews

📍 201 South Main Street

Albella Restaurant

Albella Restaurant

$$ - $$$ 💬 922 reviews

📍 50 Jefferson St

Mafia Pizza

Mafia Pizza

$$ - $$$ 💬 525 reviews

📍 850 N Jefferson St

Ciao Bella Restaurant

Ciao Bella Restaurant

$$ - $$$ 💬 574 reviews

📍 46 Forestburgh Rd

Brother Bruno's Of Monticello

Brother Bruno's Of Monticello

$$ - $$$ 💬 542 reviews

📍 951 Ny 17B

Mazzio's Pizza

$$ - $$$ 💬 753 reviews

📍 509 Highway 425 N

Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food

Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food

$$ - $$$ 💬 406 reviews

📍 200 S Market St

Brother Bruno's Of Monticello

Brother Bruno's Of Monticello

$$ - $$$ 💬 534 reviews

📍 951 Ny 17B

Cellaio Steak

American Steakhouse Italian

$$$$ 💬 475 reviews

📍 888 Resorts World Dr

Siena's Pizza

Siena's Pizza

$ 💬 296 reviews

📍 321 E Broadway

Siena's Pizza

$$ - $$$ 💬 306 reviews

📍 10 Mountain Mall Plz

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 72 Pizza 28 Bar 25 Pub 23 Fast Food 20 Mexican 20 Cafe 16 Italian 15 Asian 11 Chinese 9 Diner 7 Barbecue 5 Deli 5 Seafood 4 Spanish 4 Sushi 4 Brew Pub 3 Soups 3 Steakhouse 3 Caribbean 2

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

0 Browsable Menus

📅

Aug 2026 Last Updated