Cellaio Steak
888 Resorts World Dr, 12701-4185 - Monticello
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#10 of 31 restaurants in Monticello
Updated on
American
Steakhouse
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
65/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 845-428-7497
🌐 Website:
http://www.cellaiosteak.com
📍
Address:
888 Resorts World Dr, Monticello
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
72
Google reviews
First time dining here, and I couldn't be happier with the atmosphere, the menu, and the steaks were perfect! But nothing left a better impression than the service we received from Selina, who's recommendations were spot on, and who's energy was so very warm and pleasant... She is an asset to the establishment and an accomplishment for whomever hired her.
Thank you! See you soon!
Read more
Google
This is my fourth time here and every time we have had a great experience. The food is always five stars so just expect really good food! I always get steak but tonight I had the duck and it was cooked perfectly. My 16 month old enjoyed the crab legs and duck and loved the carrots!! Tyler was our waiter and he made our experience extra special! I honestly have to say he was the best waiter we have ever had! Extremely informative, kind and paid attention to all the fine details. I needed paper napkins because you moms know how toddlers can be and they left the restaurant to get paper napkins!! They also brought out a dessert for my husbands birthday which was so amazing!! Just amazing all around!!! Thank you!!!
Read more
Google
We had Rudy as our waiter and he was absolutely on point the entire night. The drinks were also fantastic. My party had the lobster vodka pasta, steak, & lobster tail. The lobster tail was the best thing hands down. The pasta was loaded with lobster which made the price somewhat worth it. However, the pasta itself lack some flavor. For $60 I would expect a better tasting pasta. I didn't try the steak but was told it hasn't bad at all. Pull apart rolls as the appetizer was pretty good as well.
Read more
Google
Cellaio was exactly what a steakhouse and restaurant should be. Our waitress was phenomenal, and the Chef top notch. They caught wind of my anniversary and delivered a world class desert ending to a fantastic meal and evening. Thank you!
Google
I spent my birthday here and had an amazing experience, I never write reviews but I had to give them their flowers because I appreciate the friendly staff the fresh delicious food (ESPECIALLY THE CREAMY SPINACH) and when I got home I enjoyed the strawberry cheesecake I got to go…. Ohhhhh and they brought me out a nice sherbet shaped as a cupcake 🧁 for my birthday 🥳 it had a little candle in it 😊super sweet! I’m only ten minutes away so I’ll definitely be back
Read more
Google
Great ambience, very crowded. Reservation is necessary. Salmon dish was very good, steak was mediocre.
Google
We were lucky enough to come on a night Scott was in the building. He was so gracious with his time and energy. Scott went above and beyond for hospitality.
The food was delicious and the service was excellent. I’m excited to come back.
Google
Food was good
Server was okay
Service was good (food runners & hostess)
Server never told us the specials (overheard them after we ordered from another server) and seemed to be rushing our dining experience. Only asked if we were ready to order and didn’t check on us very often only to see if we wanted to order more. Not the type of service I experienced from fine dining. Staff who delivered bread, dinner & dessert were helpful and pleasant. Don’t even know servers name just long hair with tattoos. Celebrating honeymoon and food was good, not amazing. Lobster pasta- pasta was hot, lobster cool to touch. For the bread spread liked the Parmesan one the most. Would go back again if in the area, but drove over one hour from Mt. Tremper and wouldn’t do that again. Calamari was good and so was the ribeye. Corn side better than asparagus side.
Read more
Google
From drinks to sides to steaks. 100/10. Best expresso martini(not sweet), lemon drop martini, and TOMAHAWK STEAK we have ever eaten. I had to write this review while sitting here in the restaurant because it was THAT good. Tyler was our waiter and went above and beyond- truly made our experience perfect. You must go here!!
Read more
Google
I liked everything about the atmosphere and service. I enjoyed my meal and especially the drink Moscato. The only complaint I have is my partner ordered his steak well done and the chef made it medium rear. Besides that the meals were delicious and our waitress was polite and attentive.
Google
Explore more in Monticello
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: