Nothing fancy here but you can rely on great tastes that haven't changed for decades. Sadly there aren't a lot of locations in the SE WI area these days. Their menu always adds a limited item to keep ideas fresh. Fiesta Chicken is a legitimately tasty sandwich! If you haven't eaten here yet, you could be missing out on another option to add to your list of places to eat. If you have been here and it's been years, you should come on back and have one again.
I used to go to Schlotzsky's regularly but since I stopped eating meat not so much. They've closed a lot of stores in my neighborhood. Their small pizza is well worth the price.
The store was clean and the staff friendly.
I got the vegetable pizza and added jalepeños. Very good. I especially liked the crunchy crust. I think they added a spice I couldn't quite place. I thought it was interesting I didn't notice it until I had eaten over 3/4 of it.
Great food. We were served quickly as well. Could definitely use a touch up on the inside, but everything was clean even when it was busy. The cashier didn't seem like she was having a good day, but overall a good experience.
Great food...some employees could be friendlier. It's always too warm inside due to ovens, I imagine. There's also a haze...like smoke from the ovens. For me with allergies, it's not someplace that I want to spend time eating in, especially in winter, when everything is more shut up. I won't be back til spring/summer.
Everything is Always delicious. Soups sandwich and chips for 2 was $30. Could have finished my medium sized sandwich, but I saved it for another meal. Still great reheated. Tuscan sandwich was good. Beef bacon smoke cheesy was good
Drove 70 miles just to eat here. The original is yummy and the pizza is too. Pizza is tiny btw. Kind of a weird atmosphere though so be prepared. Note....If you want water they charge you a dollar for the cup.... Ridiculous!
Unique sandwiches and pizzas. Wish there were more Schlotzsky's around. Get it a try.
Always love the Schlotzsky's Original (medium, the large is frickin' huge). Great hot sourdough buns with a bit of crunch, meats, olives, cheeses... it's just a fantastic sandwich. I've barely tried anything else on the menu.
When I went in today there was a worker who was seemingly having a rough day, but despite the rough day, he was singing and was extremely kind. He made me smile and he even took an order out to someone. Outstanding service.
We ordered Chicken Cesar Salad and it's made fresh on the spot. The salad amount was enough for two people to eat. Great customer service!!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes