My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 20 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in United States
American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Mayville
There are 20 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Pub
92
/100 (218 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Fish
American
Dinner
"Stopped in last night during the snowstorm. Place was pretty busy but we got our food fast. And it was amazing. Easily one of the best steak..."
Casey Schallert
"It's a good place to hang out good good workers are real nice drinks are fine come see for your self you will like lt THANK..."
Gonzalo Lopez
"The place in Mayville to visit, eat, and drink! Can't beat..."
Melf Gourlie
"Great food, great service, reasonable prices. Can't wait to go..."
Blake Tonn II
"The Bacon Blue Burger is simply outstanding. Along with some onion rings & Sriracha dipping sauce, you've got the BEST meal in..."
Patricia Rinka
"Nice to have such a great place so close to home. It's kind of like one of those up north restaurants that are always good and always fun. Try the..."
Broc Fleischer
"Very good food and some super friendly people! Will for sure be coming..."
Taylee Sleeter
"Tucked away Pub with awesome food and great people. And don't forget the..."
Joseph Allen
"I love fish fry..."
Angel Hernandez
"For me The Pub has the best fish fry around this area. A very light batter that lets you taste the fish. We have only gone on Friday for their..."
steve lockwood
"Had the best experience here as an out of towner. Felt very welcomed with a super friendly staff. They had a relaxed atmosphere. Great drinks and the..."
Melissa Staniszewski
"Nice old school atmosphere. Makes a good stiff drink. Food was hot and fresh. Served quick. Friendly staff. Love the Friday fish and..."
Tricia Souder
"The BEST Fish Fry all year round! Been going for decades; have Never disappointed my expectations. AYCE Fish and Chicken - Family Style. Wear your..."
Leigh Warner
"We love the pizza always amazing! My husband goes every Friday for lunch and is always happy! (He is working his way through the menu) get staff..."
Amy Bonack
"Quintessential small town Wisconsin tavern. Good cocktails, friendly rail, great food at a great price. Nothing to complain about here, if you're..."
T Riggs
"Family style on Friday night is all you can eat chicken fish and fries. I really like their chicken, but their selection for the rest of their food..."
Casey Keller
"Fish fry was obviously very good. The Cole slaw was below expectations. No potato pancakes. Great service and good..."
Jan Corbeille
Bridge Street Eatery
91
/100 (185 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
American
"It was my pleasure to stop in after work tonight and grab the House Sub for dinner! The place looks fantastic and the sandwich was delicious. I've..."
Jennifer Clark
"The best place in town!! Nice people and great food and ice cream. If I could, I would give the Bridge Street Eatery a 10!!..."
Robin Mathias-Prust
"Had the BEST, FRESHEST strawberry shake, then Ordered the House Sub to go, I almost dropped the sandwich when the waitress served me, it felt like..."
Scott White Sr.
"Great food, great service slightly more expensive than fast food places in town but you get what you pay for which is high quality fresh ingredients,..."
Jocelyn Baker
"We stopped in for lunch. Great place, food was delicious and friendly staff and owners. We will definitely..."
Shawn Rassmann Krapfl
"House sub with a double scoop chocolate cherry bomb waffle cone and the club with a strawberry shake were a set of amazing lunches. We’ll be..."
Jake Voight
"If you haven't been what are you waiting for,all together awesome,great food,ice cream and friendly staff and awesome owners,Congrats to you both,we..."
Jennifer Mueller
"Super friendly staff, great service and awesome sandwiches and ice cream. Prices are slightly high but it definitely makes up for the quality of..."
Brianne Kay
"Chili cheese dogs are awesome and the ice cream is the best in the..."
Chris Neu
"I couldn’t have been happier! The service was warm and friendly with the Waffle Nachos being absolutely incredible. I will visit again and again!!..."
Skip Beeman
"So glad Mayville finally has an ice cream shop! Good selection and great..."
Kaitlyn Leal
"Great service and great ice cream. I am looking forward to trying the subs next time. I know the scoop sizes are a little smaller than some other..."
Angela Karel
"Beautifully done, great service, fair prices, amazing food! If you haven’t gone, you’re missing out! We will definitely go..."
Kylene Harris
"I had the house sub was very good!.. Bread was amazing... Finished it off with a Butter pecan waffle cone.. Definitely hit the spot!.. Great addition..."
jfafa treryan
"Stayed open just an extra minute or two so they could serve us these two perfect ice cream cones. These guys are the..."
Aldous Tyler
"Great food and great people. I ordered subs from them for my sister's baby shower. They took the time to make sure my order was just right. Everyone..."
Crystal Westbrook
"First time to visit. What a great venue. Plenty of seating, outside entertainment for kids of all ages, beautiful landscaping. The music was awesome...."
Diane Lechner
"Quite possibly the best toasted sub I’ve ever had. Amazing bread and amazing flavors. I’ve been here for my lunch break 5 times in the last 3 1/2..."
brendan berens
"I had the best experience at Bridge Street Eatery. As soon as I walked in the door, I was greeted so kindly by Shelly. Everything hit the spot, from..."
Mckenzie Wagner
"I truly enjoyed my first experience here. The food and service was excellent. Topped it off with one of the best ice creams I have eaten. Definitely..."
Johanna Fink
"The ice cream is soooo good! I go in determined to have ONE giant scoop...and after looking at the flavor choices, I get TWO scoops..I just can't..."
Joyce Mills
The Sweet Spot
90
/100 (141 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Soups
Vegan Options
Cafe
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Sandwiches
Cheesecakes
"Everything about the Sweet Spot is 5 stars!! The food is all homemade and out of this world!! Nothing but the best for their customers! Definitely..."
Rachel Burdett Kneer
"Great food! The salad was so yummy and fresh!! The staff is so sweet and kind. Love the products available for purchase and the cookies were well..."
Sara Kleinschrodt
"An amazing place to lunch in Mayville, NY with great people, great food and friendly service. And when I say great food, each dish is entirely..."
Susan Burkhouse Giannantonio
"Best lunch spot! Their food and baked goods are to die for! It's a cute and quiet place nestled in the heart of Mayville, I would recommend anyone to..."
Holly Whitermore
"One of the best around. Great staff, great..."
Neil Johnson
"If you want great hospitality, fresh food, delicious desserts and a fun place to visit - The Sweet Spot is the place to go!! Love this place..."
Lori Nelson Studley
"One of my favorite places in Mayville. Yummy food, great service, and good prices. A must stop and check out when in..."
Sorena Delcamp Gilkinson
"I think the Sweet Spot is one of the best places on Chautauqua Lake. The owners and employees have always given exemplary service. I would recommend..."
Michael Brown
"Love the Rosie's Sugar Cookies, paninies and staff. Great place to eat! You can tell a lot of care goes into the food..."
Megan Arnone
"Fantastic food made with high quality ingredients. The staff is friendly, prompt, and courteous, making sure that the customer is satisfied. The..."
Christopher Myers
"It's the BEST place ever!!! Lunch is always wonderful and if you are full afterwards, trust me, get dessert to..."
Susan Gressley Hurley
"The best cookies I ever ate ! If you once ate a cookie which was perfect it was probably made there !..."
Théo Zimmermann
"We drive once a week to mayville (20 miles )for baked goods and cheesecakes . The food and service is..."
Sheila Myers
"Forget the cheescake chains....Darlene has THEE BEST cheesecake hands down. Had pumpkin cheesecake for Thanksgiving instead of pie!!!! Yum!!! Also..."
Tammy Cosentino Schack
"Perfect name for a perfect place. I LOVE excellent food from an excellent small business owner. The place is a unique old repurposed building which..."
Tammy Schack
"Delicious food at reasonable prices! If your ever in the area I HIGHLY recommend this place, I had the cranberry mandarin chicken wrap and it was out..."
laura pascell
"My wife and I stopped in the morning of July 5 to purchase some muffins and whatever other breakfast pastries we could find to bring back to our..."
Rick Sullivan
"The food is delicious. The building is really neat. The owner and staff are wonderful and so friendly. They know most of their customers by name...."
Kelly Drago Amatuzzo
"YUMMMMM a gem of Erie! I dropped in here to look around and came back for lunch and some road snacks! The turkey club is SO tasty and the sweet pot..."
E. Blakely
"I have yet to find something I don't like on the menu. The tuna melt on multigrain with black eyed pea salad is my favorite! If you haven't tried..."
Adrienne Myers
"Wonderful folks with wonderful food..and interesting gifts..some hand made by the owner’s mother! Absolutely spotless! Fabulous cookies, muffins,..."
Francine Pokracki
"Excellent food and baked goods in good portions at fair prices. Nice little unique gift shop and friendly..."
Pamela Morgan
"it was great but we were actually at the mayville diner lol. had a great steak n eggs and the service was..."
Brandon Cessna
"Great food and friendly service every single time I go. I definitely recommended ordering from..."
D O
Cooper Shop Saloon & Restaurant
87
/100 (309 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
American
Bar
Brew Pub
Pub
Brew Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Burger with Blue Cheese
blt Wrap
Broasted chicken
Southern Comfort Old Fashion
Pulled Pork BBQ Hog Sandwich
Prime Rib Steak Sandwich
American
Brew Pub
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Hands down amazing food. And great kindness. This place is struggling to survive the effects of covid. So if you are looking for something new and..."
Danielle Woods
"Great food, beautiful building & an awesome view of the river! We had the bbq pulled pork, chicken & brisket. All delicious! Our daughter said the..."
Kari M
"So glad you were open Anne, it was great to see you and Zuze and I really needed a beautiful drink made by..."
rudyjai3 bell
"Nice place to sit out in the deck and enjoy some food,drink and take in the views. Very clean food is good and the waitresses we had was very nice. ..."
Chris G
"My wife and I tried this place for the first time and the atmosphere was great and nicely remodeled. The menu was very small because they just opened..."
Life On The Ridge
"Guys, they are open again!! with limited hours, staff, draft beers, and menu. This is such a lovely place, let’s help keep them open! Bring cash..."
Mary Thomas
"We had the broasted chicken dinner. You choose 2 or 4 pieces, fries or potato salad. Comes with roll and homemade baked beans and cole slaw. Chicken..."
Debbie Hill
"We have used this nice little pub and grill as our halfway point between our hometown’s of Oconomowoc and Eden, and recently my fiancé and I..."
Sam Flood
Nola North Grille
84
/100 (304 ratings)
Restaurants
French
Gluten Free Options
International
American
Cajun & Creole
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Salmon
Beignets
Crawfish
Catfish
Burger
Etouffee
Shrimp
Beef
Meatloaf
Salad
Crab
Duck
"We had three separate visits over the weekend at Nola Bar/Grill. All were very good, everything from dinners, drinks, appetizers, desserts, Sunday..."
Amanda Kabat
"Fantastic food. Brussels sprouts were amazing. Friendly manager. Was a bit put off that they ran out of my wine attempting to pour my order. But..."
Corina Brown-Eufinger
"Absolutely amazing atmosphere, food and service. The seafood boil was the best I have ever had! Desserts were out of this world! Excellent price for..."
Rebecca
"Had the pre-reserved dinner a few weeks ago. Fantastic! Great atmosphere! highly recommend trying it! Check the menu out, reserve your menu..."
Cynthia Beecroft
"We love the New Orleans style cooking and GREAT hospitality. The food is always amazing, flavorful and well plated. Try the prime rib on Saturday..."
Wes Parker
"The prime rib special was great. The owner/chef really has the best recipes! Limited hours, great atmosphere. Employees have positive attitudes, with..."
Mary Baumann
"lived in mayville for years and never tried it. Finally went there one night as Nola’s and not the audobon inn. All I gotta say it’s the best..."
Lil City
Mayville Diner
84
/100 (356 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Toasts
"Waitress was nice. Service was fast. Prices are good. The food was good the hash browns were a bit over cooked. Will come back and try..."
Tyler Durden
"We are from out of town, but stopped in here on a Sunday morning for breakfast. The wait was a little long, but the food was worth it and the wait..."
Erin Mills
"Very delicious food! My family stopped to try for the first time and we we're very pleased by the staff and the food. Highly recommend it for good..."
Jamie Rowland
"Lunchtime burger was excellent. Cooked perfectly, fresh, w hot n crispy fries. Waitstaff was busy, but fast and courteous. Will definitely stop back..."
Will B. Smilardo
"The family met for breakfast for my father's 83 birthday. Excellent food, great service. Will most definitely be back. Have heard nothing but..."
Donna Crandall
Boxcar Barney's
83
/100 (599 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Lunch
Burger
Ice Cream
Sit down
American
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Cheap Eats
"The people are so friendly. My sandwich was so good!! I couldn’t finish the whole thing, had to split it! Will definitely be going back for..."
Emilee Robbins
"You just cant beat the value and the friendly service and the great ice cream. I run the Boy Scout camp down the road and some time show up in the..."
Joe DeBiso
"Great food, friendly service. Just had a roasted turkey Panini on opening day; best lunch I've had in..."
Nicholas Holt
"Awesome place to relax! Excellent ice cream...the panini’s are amazing!!! The service is..."
Christopher Alessi
"We visited the new boxcar Barney’s this weekend and were super impressed with the upgrades! -Waffle chips in your ice cream bowl -rebranding menu,..."
Tawn Bensink
"I just had lemon soft serve yesterday. It was incredible. Trying hard not to go again..."
Sue Jones
"The panini sandwiches are amazing! Such a fun atmosphere and super friendly..."
Laurie Alessi Robbins
"What’s not to love?! Great ice cream and large portions for not a lot of money. We make daily trips there when we are on vacation at..."
Jason Jozwiak
"The best ice cream anywhere around. Hugh..."
Thomas Jordan
"Love the changes the new owners have made! YUMMY organic paninis and bigger ice cream list! Service with a..."
Jill Pacy
"Excellent had the Coconut Chocolate Almond. Can't wait to go..."
Chuck Haun
"Last visit, we enjoyed a flight. Looking forward to trying something new..."
LeAnn Jones Childs
"Boxcar Barney's has the best ice cream in all of Chautauqua County! The portions are huge and the staff is wonderful! Can't wait to get a delicious..."
Judi Goerke
"Book their ice cream it is so..."
Andrea Lee
"Good ice cream..."
Paul Clark
"Love love love this place. . Stop for drinks and snacks when we are out on our bikes. The kids love all the different choices for ice..."
Jessica M. Rumsey
"Really good tasting food & great..."
Mary Sue Tichy
"Huge portions and very good! Highly recommend. My friend loved every..."
Sue Davis
"I am so glad that I took the advice of another reviewer and got the ice cream flight! At $6 for 4 flavors, you truly get your money's worth (and..."
Amy Lindsey
"Went here while on vacation in the area and I was not disappointed. Friendly staff and quick service. Lots of delicious flavors to choose and..."
Daviyion Johnson
"Good ice cream but they lie on there menu small 1 scoop,medium 2 scoops, and large 3 scoops and that is a lie. The small is the size of 3 scoops the..."
John Rauber
"Awesome ice cream. Great service! Sometimes there's a line but it's totally worth it for the large portions and great..."
Peter Kinnally
"Ice cream is delicious, portions are generous, staff are friendly and can usually handle a long line fairly..."
Gregory Hoyt
"Visited Boxcar Barney's for the 1st time! Great Ice Cream! It was a nice way to cool down after a hot day on the..."
Joe Miller
"Delicious ice cream and great service! We pulled up and the line was REALLY long — but it moved extremely fast. Staff was friendly and the..."
Michael Push
"On our tour of ice cream places in Western PA, Eastern OH and SW NY, we happen to stumble upon Boxcar Barney's. Really nice location, you can sit in..."
Steve Churchill
"The portions are massive for the price. I ordered a baby size ice cream cone and it was gigantic! I think all of there ice cream is homemade as..."
Daniel Madson
"Biggest ice cream around!! We drive 20 minutes to go here. Love the revamp and that they take debit/credit now. Keep up the revamp it's looking..."
T (716reviewer)
"They can serve a lot of people have benches, and even a small soft serve ice cream was a really good..."
KeviN Martyn
"Great selection of hard and soft serve. Larger servings. Food options, but folks come for ice cream. Open till 9 but they stay open till the line is..."
Sky Sail
"We where in Ripley New York for the day to see family. Was looking for the Icecream place that we found last time by chance in 2016. Couldn't find..."
Robbie Reid
"A nostalgic must visit that has been updated, we love going to Barney's! Wish there was more shade and a couple more vegan flavors, but glad to see..."
Lexi Tabor
"If you like homemade hard packed ice cream and treats, you need to eat here. The servings are MASSIVE and the flavor variety is very good too. I..."
Dominic Matteo (Life By The Bells)
"We loved this place. Had the largest ice cream cones ever and it was delicious!! Must..."
John Crotwell
"Every summer evening should be this good. Enjoyed by kids from 2 to..."
E R P
Andriaccios Restaurant
81
/100 (1491 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
American
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Meatballs
Deep Dish Pizza
Eggplant
Lasagne
Pizza Logs
Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Shrimp Portofino
Salad
Pesto
Prime Rib Special
Wings
Fish
Scallops on Quinoa
Side Spaghetti
Mac and cheese
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Scallops
caesar salad
Fries
Calamari
Mozzarella
Risotto
Hawaiian Pizza
Greek salad
Calamares
Meat Lovers
Burger
Chicken parmigiana
Salmon
Seafood Carbonara
Tiramisú
Mussels
Shrimp
Veggie Burger
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Alfredo
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Lobster
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
American
Accepts Mastercard
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Television
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"We were famished and luckily stumbled upon this great restaurant. The place is quite beautiful and the menu has prices that are affordable while also..."
Ally “Bacon Coffee Mama” Greene
"The service was a little slow and there were only 3 people in the restaurant but the friendly staff along with the best Greek salad made up for..."
Terra Brown
"Nice restaurant for those wanting something more tasty than the Chautauqua standard fare across the street. Had fresh mozzarella salad, crispy..."
Andrew Lih
"We were looking for a nice meal for the two of us. I had a 10" pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. My hubby had the lasagna. They had fresh bread..."
Anthony Bateau
"Pizza rolls, pictured were amazing. I had the chicken parm and date had a traditional cheese pizza. Both were very very..."
Valentine IfYouPlease
"Ordered for the entire family. Ordered 50 mild wings, a cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, a Neapolitan pizza, and a gluten free pizza and everyone..."
Joey Ciccotti
"We vacationed for 10 days in the Chautauqua region. Wonderful waitresses that are very friendly and attentive especially Jess who is a genuine person..."
Christine Vlachos
"Excellent. We had a large party (> 15). They handled it with grace and speed. The order was taken promptly. The food arrived hot and together. The..."
Elisabeth Huhn
"so - the food was okay as expected. the porch is wonderful, servers great - unusual for most restaurants they could add anchovies to their caesar! ..."
chris mead
"I was visiting family in Sherman this weekend and we took our aunt out for dinner. It was busy, but the staff was great, it was a little pricy, but..."
Stacey Dunbar
"This is such a gem of a restaurant! From the outside it looks like a generic Italian place, but the quality of the food is exceptional and the staff..."
Melissa Erikson
"Very nice itian restaurant, didn't wait long for our food or beverages but our pasta was cold when we received it. Nice atmosphere, we will try it..."
Brian Hetrick
"Creative menu. Food tastes very fresh, with high quality cheeses. No annoying TVs blaring from the walls or fake Italian music coming through..."
rllbss2
"The calzones are amazing, they have so much flavor and cheese. The perfect lunch (and dinner) meal on the patio. I recommend stopping whenever..."
Emery Boyle-Scott
"Haven't been here in about 18mos. The first new impression was with the refurbishment of the entrance and patio seating. Very well done! Next was the..."
Milton Svetanics
"Enjoyed a nice lunch on the patio. Great service and yummy food. We had pasta and meatballs and lasagna...both were equally..."
Debbie Farantzos
"This was our first time visiting and we were celebrating our anniversary. We enjoy Italian food and thought we would give them a try. I had the..."
Randy Turner
Stedman Corners
81
/100 (338 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
American
Cafe
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
French Toast
Toasts
Breakfast Sandwich
Cakes
Café Mocha
Muffin
Eggs Your Way
Breakfast Burrito
Southwest Omelette
Pancakes
Salad
Sit down
American
Café
Table Service
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
BYOB
Seating
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Rustic country store turned five star brunch spot. The coffee and Eggs Benedict were excellent, the service prompt and friendly, the outdoor seating,..."
Scott Lau
"Great breakfast spot! Everything is made fresh and has great flavor. Coffee is their own blend and goes perfectly with everything served. The..."
Scott Woodard
"Get away from NY-394 and explore some other restaurants in Chautauqua County...like this one ! Good food, good coffee. Old general store with..."
Dave Kerr
"Best omelet around! They bake their own delicious muffins. Everything tasted great, and the atmosphere is very comfy with antiques, books, and board..."
Becky Lundberg
"The pancakes with pecans were wonderful! The Greek omelet with kielbasa - also excellent. You want a great bfast Sammie? You can't get better than..."
Steve L
"Best breakfast- eggs Benedict, and many other tasty breakfast and lunch offerings. Cozy friendly atmosphere, great service, coffee is outstanding. So..."
ann klahr
"Quaint place. Nothing around. Locals drive for miles around and park along the road for brunch. Local young waitstaff. Indoor and outdoor seating..."
Wanda Gingerich
"Hands down the best Eggs Benedict I have ever had. And I’ve had a lot. Unbelievable..."
MICHAEL GLANTZ
"Beautiful cozy little Cafe. Slightly small portions, but great tasting..."
Joe Miller
"Who would have thought you could drive out to the country and find a cafe that served eggs Benedict that were superb. Loved the food and..."
Roxanne Horn
Stocke's Backstreet Cafe, Pub And Grill
90
/100 (102 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Cafe
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Toasts
American
Café
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Service was wonderful!! Food was delicious!! Decor inside is very cute!! I'll be..."
Debbie Hill
"A great place with an amazing atmosphere. The food was delicious with great prices. The fish fry was very good and the cheese curds are out of this..."
Tim Pingel
"I went there for an open jam. Met a lot of friendly music loving people. Great to see the establishment supports local music. I didn't eat but the..."
LARRY THUROW
"Food was excellent and so was the service. Menu was diverse so plenty for everyone to choose from and be happy. Building has been totally redone and..."
Becky Buzdum
"Good food, music, fair..."
J B
"I really love this place. Awesome fish fry at a great price. Good old fashion..."
Deb Potrykus
"Delicious, fresh food! Everything is cooked fresh! Did not disappoint. Beef brisket and Rueben rolls were..."
Kendra Apfelbeck
"They have the best food.Great..."
cheryl Storms
Webb's Captain's Table
80
/100 (1976 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Steakhouse
Bar
Bar
Pub
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Cosmopolitan
Baked potato
Beef
Bourbon
Crab cakes
Lobster
Strawberry Salad
Pasta
Grilled Chicken Salad
Salad
Chicken Mediterranean
Crab
Shrimp Cocktail
Scallops
Moscato
Salmon
Lamb Chops
Chicken Parmesan
Sandwiches
Prime Rib Dinner
Cheeseburger
Filet Mignon
Walleye
Burger
The Big Catch Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Burnt Asparagus
Pesto
Friday Only Fish & Chips
Fish
Pasta with Scallops
Chicken Quesadilla
Saratoga Sparkling
Shrimp
Sit down
Bar
American
Steakhouse
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Table Service
Private Dining
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts American Express
Waterfront
Wine and Beer
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Serves Alcohol
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"It was the best prime rib I have ever had. The restaurant is stunning with a fireplace in the dining area. The staff is very friendly and attentive...."
Debbie Davidson-Corah
"Expertly done traditional fare! Everything was fantastic, from the expertly toasted rolls to the perfectly cooked prime rib. The bruschetta appetizer..."
Carlton Tanner
"We don't go too often but we've had their Baked Chicken Sunday Special a couple times already & it is Delicious & the price can't be beat for all..."
Melinda Allein Ventola
"This was our first time following an adventure through Panams Rocks. Had the veal with hollandais sauce it was fabulous! Jim was a very attentive..."
Nancy Bitner
"This was my first visit and I loved it. Food and dessert were top notch. Oh and the view of the lake was added..."
Nancy Burgos Hayes
"It was great- the food, the hosts, everything. We have had great meals there for our banquets and Ben really works with us on what we would..."
Kendrya Sheldon
"Beautiful restaurant, delicious food and great service! Enjoyed shopping in the gift shop earlier in the day also. Would definitely go..."
Ginny Curran
"We stopped in for lunch. The food was very good, and the server was friendly. It is a beautiful..."
Tim Bowman
"Husband and I have enjoyed many meals here - dinner in main dining room, up on the deck with great view of the lake , or in the bar - very cozy for..."
Mary Zenns Hunt
"We hadn't been there in a while, so with nice weather predicted we decided to plan our Valentines dinner at Webb's. It was wonderful. The service was..."
Wendy Rose Wilcox
"Spent a leisurely Saturday late afternoon enjoying a great meal in front of the fireplace as the sun was setting. From the bruschetta to the main..."
LeAnn Jones Childs
"Most reliable and best meal in town. Customer service is fabulous! Well worth the money! Service doesn't change weather it's the summer season or..."
Kelly Warner-Ulsh
"We love visiting Mayville and always choose Webb’s for our lunch or dinner destination. Excellent food with a nice variety to choose from. ..."
Michele Grace
"Had a great dinner on the deck. Had a great filet and lamb chops. Great..."
Joanne Raynow Schaus
"We had a wonderful dinner New Year's Eve. Delicious food from appetizer, salad, entree and dessert! We weren't rushed. Had awesome service. ..."
Mary Ellen Westin
"Have been coming here for as long as I can remember... my family used to have a cottage close by... now I have to drive up from south Carolina......"
Stuart Grayell
"Nice large restaurant. We sat upstairs outside so we could have a view of Lake Chautauqua. Arrived at 4 pm when they opened on a Friday evening, so..."
Lisa Frederick
"Our waitress Julie was the best from start to finish. Food was good. Love the seasonal decor and oil lamps on the..."
Beth Smialek
"Brynn made our entire experience at Captains table restaurant one to remember. As a young mutant filled with radioactive oooze, Brynn dabbed some of..."
Kaylee Taylor
"We stumbled about this restaurant when we realized another local spot was seasonally closed. We didn’t realize it but it was a little more formal..."
Paul Barina
"Me and my family dined in tonight and our experience was enjoyable on a very high bar. The food was prepared perfectly and presented extremely well...."
Zerø
"Wonderful meal to celebrate our 52nd anniversary after a cruise on the Chautauqua Belle. We dined outside on the upper deck and had a great view of..."
Sue Moore
"Delicious food, great service, and a wonderful atmosphere. The Chicken Chautauqua is worth trying. The rolls they serve are spectacular. They..."
Nichole Kretz
"I had the Filet Oscar and our guests had the Chicken Parmesan . The presentation on both entrees was fabulous. And the food was extremely delicious!..."
Candace Maguire
"Came here for lunch on a road trip after everything in one of the towns we drove through was closed. Was hesitant about some previous reviews I saw..."
Ryan Ballow
"My dinner was called th Oscar, I think. It's totally delicious. I will order this again. I love how they pair the wine with the dinner. Wait staff..."
Martha Pascarella
"Went for Lunch with my wife and mother, sat on the balcony and it was a great view and awesome food and service. Joe provided superior service. I..."
Zachariah Ingalls
"This is my favorite restaurant. We love the food, atmosphere, and especially the captain's table. We went here for my son's birthday, as well as..."
Tammi Elkin
"The food was a little pricey but well worth it. There was more than enough food in the portions we received. Nice view of the lake if you are..."
Rick George
"Food was great. Service was a good. Atmosphere was great. They were very busy today because of the chocolate walk. ..."
Sandy Soyke
The Watermark
80
/100 (605 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Crab
Scallops
Calamari
Risotto
Mussels
Tuna
Calamares
Crab Cake
Shrimp
Haddock
Cakes
Pesto
Lobster
Fish
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
American
Seafood
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Waterfront
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Richard JH was amazing. We came over from Erie pa for a camping trip and after a long work week we decide to treat ourselves to a nice dinner outside..."
Beckie Jackson
"This is one of our favorite places to go for seafood in the area. Food was delicious and the service was great! There's a great view of the lake..."
Stephanie Martin
"Food and service were great! Nice place for a date night or the whole family. Def recommend the grilled lobster and the crab balls...."
Kerry S
"Amazing food Beautiful views Would go back Great..."
maureen chapin
"There were six of us, so we made a reservation in advance and were able to get patio seating. The food was top notch. Prime Chicago beef tenderloin..."
Joni Lehman
"Gluten and soy-free diner here. What a stupendous meal my dining companion and I had last night. To start I had the Basil Hayden, she tried their..."
Cosmic Fitness, LLC
"This place was amazing. The seafood here was the best I’ve ever had. All the fish tasted fresh and delicious. Plus portion sizes were amazing! The..."
Ebaad Meer
"We were visiting from Toronto, Canada and were brought to your restaurant for dinner. I ordered a dish with haddock in sauce and topped with to die..."
Khalid Kaiser
"Spent Saturday evening on the back patio for a dear friend's 90th birthday celebration. All the staff was FANTASTIC - shout out to Sue, who helped us..."
Lisa B
"We were impressed with the level of service even with the recent staffing issues everywhere. Enjoyed the lobster tail, scallops, mussels, plus the..."
Matt Bohach
"We stopped here hoping for a nice meal beside the lake and we were not disappointed! The filets my husband ordered were delicious and my dish of..."
Twila Heckler
"Service was decent considering how busy they were. Sat outside and it was very enjoyable. I ordered soft shell crabs with risotto and it was great...."
Barb V
"We loved our dinners and the view right there on the lake is awesome. I had the steak and soft shell crab - my husband had the scallops, shrimp and..."
Total Contentz Training Academy
"Their first night of the season. We had an experienced server who was great and knew her business, taking great care of us. We had a party of 8 and..."
Lew Meckley
"We just recently dined there for my birthday and for the most part it was a great experience. The restaurant itself is very inviting and has a..."
Kelly Shaw-Hewes
"Appetizers and entrees were delicious. Service was excellent and the view of the lake was spectacular. Great way to celebrate our..."
Debbie Nageli
Chautauqua Harbor House
79
/100 (484 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Diner
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Salad
American
Diner
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Mid-range
"Our first time there. Service was excellent-- Very quick and food was great! I had the BLT club which was huge and very tasty!! Price was very..."
Connie Erdman Brucato
"The fries are the best and atmosphere is always friendly. We had bourbon stake tonight that was..."
Beth Maxwell Boyle
"Great food, friendly staff. Would highly..."
Jennifer McCormick Kilbarger
"My grandchildren & I had a very nice lunch at this little diner yesterday & it was an experience we definitely wiil repeat. It was a beautiful day..."
Kathy Lynn Hanold Seblink
"dave (chef) is very creative and a master with soups. the Brussels sprouts,chicken and mushroom soup and the mushroom brie soup are perfectly..."
Caroline Van Kirk Bissell
"Good service, great food. Pleasant atmosphere and very creative..."
John A Endres
"We used to come here occasionally when it was Dick's and was very happy to see that it had been reopened under new management. We had the fish fry..."
Deborah Ann Seastrum
"We had breakfast there last Sunday. The food and service were wonderful. It's so much better than the place that was there before. We'll be..."
Patti Fortin
"Great food, great staff and great owners. They also make the best quiche I've..."
Dawn Lloyd Gillian
"We took our son for a birthday brunch ( a few days early). We had simply awesome meals. The eggs were tender and delicious. His "Monte Cristo " was..."
Lili Pintea-Reed
"The food is very good and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly,making you feel right at..."
Jean Stortzum Eckert
"If your looking for a cozy little breakfast place, this is it! Nice portions reasonably..."
Pe
"Great breakfast! Really enjoyed my veggie..."
Jennifer Reboul
"Omg this place was amazing. I felt like I was at my grandmother's for breakfast and the food was amazing! Lobster eggs Benedict will be ordered every..."
Jamie Benge
"Breakfast can be ordinary regular priced favorites to unusual options...priced higher of course. Coffees good. View is nice...."
Nancy Johnson
"We came on a weekday between breakfast and lunch. Service was quick, friendly, and our food arrived quickly. Portions were generous! My hash browns..."
Matt Jones
"Good fish fry this time, service very good and considerate. The fish was cooked perfectly, the fries were a lil dark but tasted ok, tartar sauce is..."
Scorched Cat
Heirloom Restaurant
78
/100 (157 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Iced tea
Chicago Hotdog
Watermelon Bisque
Humus Appetizer Sampler
Sit down
American
Mid-range
"Fast, friendly service. The food was presented very well, delicious and on the smaller size in terms of portions for lunch. We sat outside on the..."
Lisa Frederick
"My server Marcy was terrific. She was attentive without hovering. She took time to describe dishes and told me items that she thought i would enjoy...."
tom kiebala
"The food was simple, yet exquisite and flavorful! The wait staff were extremely welcoming, friendly, and..."
MzFabu
"Had drinks with my girlfriends. Bar open during off season 4-8pm in lobby of the hotel. Great time. Stop by and see Bartender..."
Brenda Lucy
"Separate ratings ... Food was 4 stars, service 3 stars but I'm giving the benefit of the doubt. The food that was served for a Saturday night dinner..."
Tom Wojcik
"My server Erin was fantastic! I sat on the porch and was enthralled by the gorgeous view of the lake. I've been around the world and I've really..."
Josh Ferreira
"Candice did a nice job on our table of 5 middle aged trouble makers, especially my brother in law who always challenges any server with orders of..."
Paul Miller
"Went here for a soft opening. Excellent service, very friendly waiter who was able to help me in all of my confusion about the menu. I was very..."
Dylan Lydell
"Finally got it right! We have been eating here once a week for the past 6 years..This year we are here 3 times. The menu was great with plenty of..."
Kimberly Boehm
"So wonderful to now have a place to have a drink by the lake in Chautauqua Institution. So glad they have extended their hours,..."
Gail Martineau
"A wonderful setting with good food, and a pleasant, helpful..."
Dan Muldoon
"Three of us had salmon entree, which was delicious. Fourth person had beef fillets that she thought was very good. Great service. Deelish creme..."
Pat&Cats
"Beautiful setting, diningroom and hotel! Kind of complicated to get into, and short staffed when we were there, but who isn't; would recomend a..."
Becca
"Absolutely, the most breathtaking views you can experience while dining and the food is amazing! Check out amazing history of the Hotel and make sure..."
Lillyandthecupcake
"Exceptional dining and service with an unforgettable view/ambiance! The salmon was delicious. Service is bar none. We loved it and highly..."
Kathleen Dahl
"If you find yourself lucky enough to explore the grounds of the Chautauqua Institution, dinner at Heirloom is the cherry on top of what I can only..."
Brianne Roesser
Olives
75
/100 (175 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Private Dining
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We ate breakfast here after spending the night at the attached hotel. They had a better than average breakfast buffet. Not a huge buffet but..."
John A
"I just dined at Olive's last night, and I have to say the whole experience was great. We had reservations, which was good, because as soon as we..."
Brandon Cessna
"So glad to be able to get back to Olives for our anniversary. Great meal great service. Make a reservation soon you won't be..."
Joyce Kelly
"Had lobster ravioli with shrimp! It was to die for! Best meal I've eaten in ages! Service was excellent..."
Bruce Berry
"We had a great meal and excellent service. Well worth the price for such an enjoyable..."
Kevin Hadley
"Food mostly good. Odd hours when I went. Off..."
John Moriarty
"The Prime was great and the deal was great! Had an amazing lemon cake😉- not always..."
Greg Wieszczyk
"Buffet was excellent with an attentive staff. Great food and..."
John R Weinhold Jr
"Super comfy and relaxing... great drinks and food. Prices are reasonable... plenty of parking..."
john brinkley
"We have been coming to Olive's for over 10 years, and have always enjoyed it..."
Jennif S
"Always good food. Enjoyed the music from a class reunion..."
Michael Zembryski
"Food is great. They often have issues with their draft..."
Ronald S.
"Wonderful food and excellent service from our server..."
Jodie Sisley
The Lakeview Hotel & Restaurant
74
/100 (354 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
American
Bar
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Burger
Beef
Salad
Wings
Fish
Bar
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Table Service
Accepts American Express
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Subway
73
/100 (2125 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sit down
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"Ordered a large order online. When we picked it up and brought it back to work, we were missing a few drinks and chips. We called the store and they..."
Susan D
Subway
73
/100 (1815 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sit down
American
Fast food
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
"Love their..."
Lori Wheeler
""
Emily Caffey
""
Belinda Sziber
House On The Hill Restaurant
70
/100 (26 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Breakfast
Salad
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Amazing view of Lake Chautauqua! Amazing food at great prices. We both ordered a Chautauqua Stinger thinking we’d take half home for lunch..."
Janis Rosenburg
"I am a Mayville/Chautauqua local, and I love to go to the NEW House on the Hill, which I understand is under new management. Which is good, because..."
Brandon Cessna
"Great sandwich...great customer..."
Flash it Cellular
""
Laura Ondreako
Docks
70
/100 (179 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
American
Seafood
American
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Fish
Salad
Crab
Crab Legs
Sit down
Seafood
Bar
Pub
American
Outdoor Seating
Waterfront
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Clean, respectable, friendly staff. Awesome endless crab legs. First time dinning, will be back..."
Desiree Manning
"Jordan's peanut butter pie and bar steaks are the best! Jordan and staff are very nice and make you want to come back for more food, fun and..."
Stephanie Ballistrea Banas
"2 of the best servers we had all day, twins Connie aka Constance, and younger sister on the right Bonnie aka Bonita. Great service, great food, great..."
Bill Lehmann
"It's a mix of plenty! Antiques, vintage, modern and retro. Lots to..."
Brenda B
"They had several specials and a few of us had the crab-stuffed walleye. It was absolutely excellent. The others in our party had the prime rib..."
Kari Wendel
"All you can get crab legs and chicken malinise. Food was delicious. Didn't have to wait for the next bunch of crab legs. Serve was timely. Out..."
Sarah B
"We had a large group. They handled us nicely. The food was nicely presented and fresh. The server Charity was nice too. The atmosphere was good, laid..."
Scott Kalb (SKalber)
"Excellent food and great..."
Pat Taylor
"Great food, and all you can eat Crab Legs. We've never had an issue with waitstaff, the drinks or the food. Nice portions as well. Lots of local..."
Aimee Bajdo
"It was cery nice and the service..."
Brunilda Bardhi M.D “VenusDerm” Dermatology & Laser Clinic
"The food is always good. Thank you for always preparing delicious food and your best service. Recommended to so many friends and..."
Alyna Yuan
"Wait staff was friendly and food was delicious. Can't go wrong with "all you can eat" crab..."
Grigasaurus
"All I could eat crab legs , Fantastic !!! Beer very reasonably price. Service was excellent. Thank you, Waitresses Denise and..."
Karen Heintz
"The food was great, the band playing was not my choice but people seemed to be happy. The food carries the restaurant to the 5..."
frank leone
"Came here on Friday had good customer service the people at the bar were great the patronage was awesome good friendly atmosphere Quick Service great..."
jennifer feldt
"Service was good,lobster bisque was good,wife's cheeseburger was good,the best part of my fish sandwich was the..."
Michael Jabczynski
"Sweetest people I've ever seen.... That sweetheart can..."
Todd Van Horn
"Nothing complicated. Good food and service. Always a good time in a homestyle..."
Jennif S
"The food was wonderful, the view of the lake made it relaxing and comfortable,,going again..."
Cathryn Bowling
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes