First time eating here came strictly by other reviews. First appearance was lil disappointing but once we ordered they promptly prepared all fresh pizzas which have great flavor and appearance the toppings were more along the line of what you'd get a gattis . Drinks were included in the price 3 all you can eat buffets were $36. Very friendly staff nice local spot for good pizza and calm clean open atmosphere.
Dec 09, 2023: The pizza at this place is tasty with a variety of options. You can request a customized pizza with different sauces. The place is clean, offering a calm atmosphere with a pleasant aroma. Many toppings are fresh and flavorful. Keep in mind that some pizzas might be salty for certain tastes, and fruit toppings like pineapple are not available.
I have only been here for the buffet, but dang. This place is incredible. A large variety of pizzas for such a small bar and they have pasta options, dessert, salad, and a soup! I love coming here because the staff is so welcoming, the tables are clean, they never run out of plates, the pizza is hot, and the food is amazing. I think they have the perfect amount of cheese on their pizza and it’s quality cheese. You really cannot find a better deal for the quality of the food anywhere else. This place is doing it right!
Was out running errands with my wife and saw Fat Jimmy's Buffet. We decided to stop for lunch and give them a try. My wife's garden salad was huge. She loved it. I opted for the pizza buffet and was not disappointed. There were many choices available and I tried most of them. They also had garlic butter bread balls as well as sweet bread balls. Excellent! I will stop again the next time I'm in Middletown
We love the buffet at Fat Jimmy's! The pizza is consistently delicious, the salad ingredients are fresh, and don't forget to try the tasty Taco soup and the yummy sweet balls.
Family-friendly staff. Nothing fancy about the restraunt, but it's clean.
I cannot say enough about this place.
As a customer, the food is consistently great! They have a buffet, a drive-thru, eat-in, carry-out, and a picnic table out front... lots of choices! Food options include salads, subs, pastas, pizzas and a buffet (where the food's actually tasty & you can request a pizza type)!! Tonight, before heading home, I stopped by to say hey and pick up a 14" Tito and a 14" All Meat.
As a former employee (18 or so years ago/a past life), the owner is top notch!! It's a family friendly establishment where the owner truly cares about the employees, customers and community.
If you're looking for a local, small business to support, look no further. The food is great & the atmosphere is even better!
Tasty for a buffet meal...good variety of pizza, nice salad, breadsticks & garlic knots. The guy running the place was greeting all his customers, bussing tables, great customer service which is hard to find anymore. Nice price including soft drink...$12.
The place was packed! That’s always a good indication for what to expect. The stall was friendly and very active keeping tables clean for new customers to have a place to sit. The buffet was always full of fresh pizzas, that were delicious! I left stuffed. Great value!
Was googling inexpensive places to eat out Middletown and Fat Jimmy's popped up. I'd passed it several times but never went inside.
I didn't know what to expect but I was beyond satisfied. The restaurant & buffet line are extremely clean. The staff was very friendly and prompt. Most of the buffet was full, and when I asked for something to be refilled it was done quickly.
I tried the pepperoni, bacon ranch & veggie pizzas. The veggie was my favorite. The sweet balls are amazing.
The only suggestion I have is maybe having some grilled chicken available to add to the alfredo. Other than that everything was very fresh and tasted great.
Consistently awesome! Great food, Friendly staff and fair prices. The place is always clean. Done the buffet and take out many times and never disappointed
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Louisville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes