Bennett’s Ice Cream

Yummy! I love ice cream and this place just hit the spot. Their milkshakes are pretty good and I'd recommend it. Quick and friendly service. One thing I'd wish was better was the signs? We noticed a decent amount of people got confused where the line starts and if there was a separate one just to get fountain drinks.

I am absolutely gonna miss this place. Hands down the best ice cream I had in my life. Try their Choffee flavor if you’re a fan of chocolate and coffee!! And their mint chocolate is refreshing! The staff are also super nice. Also, I have asked them if they use alcohol-extracted vanilla and they said no.

Not all ice creams are equal, this ice cream is definitely more equal than others. Bennets is a testament to that. Old fashioned handmade ice creams are really something special. On this day I had a hand pressed stick vanilla ice cream coated in chocolate and almonds. The vanilla was not too sweet, the coating slightly salted, the chocolate slightly dark, maybe 50% cocoa. Ffs this was really really good. Its an ice cream that I will miss till I get to have it again.

Fantastic ice cream! I had the pumpkin ice cream which was to die for, I can’t wait to come back and creat/try new ice cream dessert combinations. The ice cream is creamy and good quality! The service was pretty quick, but be warned they charge about 4% extra on your tab if you’re paying with a card, I died a little on the inside. But hey! I was happy with my ice cream and it brought a smile to my face 😂.

Bennett's Ice Cream is an old time classic ice cream shop located at the historical Farmers Market, a local and international tourist spot. I was there on a day where they were giving free ice cream scoop's to the first 50 guest. Yes, the serving size is small and the prices are high, comparatively speaking. For me, the "Fancy Nancy" favor tasted good. Not overly sweet and I could easily make out the coffee, caramel and banana flavors... nice. Would I have paid the high price for the small scoop.... No. Would I recommend first time guests to the Farmers Market to try them, as least once, yes! 31 Favors is my go to ice cream parlor. But, the price for me was right (free) that day! Although, I spent about $6 in gasoline to get there and back home.