Carr's Restaurant
50 W Grant St - Lancaster
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#20 of 477 restaurants in Lancaster
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
76/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
172
Google reviews
Birthday celebration. Everything was spot on! Corn crab chowder beautiful presentation and delish! There were 3 of us - each with a different entree all were sublime! Dessert and coffee too.. I believe this business is one week open but felt like a well run team. Jamie thank you for your hospitality! Definitely will be back.
Read more
Google
Wonderfully inspired food. New management has even improved the menu. We both had the specials- one fish and one meat, both excellent and I novative. The dessert of baked bread pudding with rosemary and vanilla ice cream was sublime. Excellent customer service as usual. We'll be back.
Google
The food was delicious and the dishes were unique, great service and worth the price. The charcuterie plate featured a triple cream brie that was so soft it was like butter and a chicken liver pate that was incredibly flavorful. The small plates were large enough to be meals and each one was extremely well put together from the tenderloin medallion to the lamb meatballs. In dessert, I ordinarily don't enjoy creme brulee but the chocolate creme brulee was so delicious that I would go back just for that. All in all, a great value and a great place!
Read more
Google
First time visiting this place and have to say it was an amazing experience. Service was top notch and food was delicious. The wild mushroom pizza was by far the best pizza I have ever eaten. You can tell all ingredients are fresh and perfect blend of flavors. We also loved the chocolate fondue dessert. My wife and I are vegetarians and the waiter and waitress were both extremely accommodating. We had a great time and will definitely be returning. Be sure to reserve in advance. It gets booked up on weekends.
Read more
Google
Great food and drinks! Our dinner was perfect. Crab cake well seasoned but not too much filler, filet very tender and perfectly cooked. The Christmas Mule was the best cocktail I've had in years, half our table ordered it after trying ours. Good service, and we were there during the Santa Stumble so they were packed.
One odd thing, they apparently have a policy of not offering their specials to parties of 6 or more. They made an exception at our request, which we appreciated! But strange policy and I hope they reconsider for the future; I almost always go with a special at a place like this.
Read more
Google
My girl friends and I shared a meal and some drinks at Carr's last Saturday. Our food was exception. I had the wild mushroom ravioli and between the ravioli itself and the fresh veggies that were abundant on the plate, it was probably one of the best meals I've had in some time. Our drinks were delicious and the gentlemen who waited on us was attentive and so much fun. Wonderful experience, we will definitely be back.
Read more
Google
I never had a bad meal here. Menu is always interesting and fresh. Good selection of beers. Really not all that expensive; you can have a really great dinner for two and a drink for around $80 to $100. Service is always good.
Google
5 stars isn't enough! Tim Carr and his staff knock it out of the park every time. Our 40th class reunion went off without a hitch. Excellent service, atmosphere, food and beverages. Cleanliness was meticulous and the unexpected special "class drink" was much appreciated. Other restaurants just can't compare.
Read more
Google
Great family or date night! Quiet, well placed tables, soft lighting, and artistic comfortable environment...that's just to start the evening! The food was prompt and delicious, not an over complicated menu but quality ingredients were used by an obviously well-oiled machine that is the kitchen team! Definitely well priced for all the accommodations and convenience of 2 hour prior reservations for 4 on a Saturday evening! Excellent cocktails by a well seasoned and personable mixologist! Our server and assistant were engaging and very cordial, definitely not helicopters and yet on point for refills and requests! Highly recommend this staple of Lancaster City, popular well before the current influx of new restaurants in the area, there's a reason they have the tenure they do! Well done! Try thier Central Market Stand, right next door! Tues & Fri 7-4, Sat 7-2
Read more
Google
Took my mother here for her birthday, and was SO not disappointed! The atmosphere could have used a little music, but other than that it was clean and we'll decorated. The menu had an amazing variety, our server Lauren was on point without being overbearing (been serving 20 yrs, and I will request her every time now), and the food was flawless.
Thank you Carr's Restaurant, for making my mother's 66th birthday perfect, just by being yourselves!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Lancaster
Help improve this page: