Sugar Beach Bake Shop

Great coffee and Malasadas. Our favorite was the coconut cream filled Malasada. The lilikoi was also great, it had a nice bit of tartness, not too sweet. They were all soft and airy with high quality fillings. We also had the quiche, the flavor was delicious but the filling was kind of a custard type texture that was not what we were expecting. Also just watch out for the chickens that roam around outside, they can be a bit daring stealing a bite of your malasada if you aren’t paying attention. It’s a must try though, we stopped by twice!

We went twice on our trip! Malasadas one day and pies the other! We have been here many times but never had the Malasadas! We stopped early in the morning on our way to West Maui on a day trip from Kihei. They were absolutely delicious and I think we decided perhaps our favourite on the island! The staff was really friendly and loved our choices! We had the lilikoi and coconut ! They were both amazing!! We didn’t plan on eating two each but they were too good not to! The ube sounded intriguing as well! They only take credit card! We had the pies the other time! The lilikoi was by far our favourite! We will be back!

The ladies here went above and beyond for us! We were able to visit sugar beach as a big family group. My husband and I have a little boy who is going to be a big brother. We were so excited to be able to share the gender with the whole group and reached out to sugar beach bake shop to see if they could help us do so. They were excited to help us and they made 32 malasadas with one containing the gender. Turned out to be another boy! This was such a fun way to tell our group and support an awesome local shop!

Such a wonderful place! This is one of the best bakeries in Maui! A must try! Be prepared that there is normally a line due to how incredible this place is and they do not take cash so have a card to use! They have a fantastic, large selection. Their staff is kind, patient, and makes the experience even better! Mahalo Sugar Beach Bakery! We will be back!

The staff were Super lovely. This place is dangerously good. I understand why there was a line!! The cream-filled Malasadas were excellent, especially the Lilikoi and coconut ones. The strawberry coconut muffin was delicious too! I wanted one of everything but got out while I could 🤣! Definitely give them a try!!