Grabbed a slice while walking around Duval Street. Not bad, but not a favorite either. Staff was a lot of fun though (challenging my Galaga skills).
Good pizza. Went on a cruise in March 2014. Took the Duval pub crawl and stopped here for a bite. Pizza was very good. Going back to Key West May 2014.
Key West's 2:00 am place for pizza. Funky pizzaria on the western end of Duval Street...aroundthe corner from Capt. Tony's... across the street from Sloppy Joe's... located on the courtyard that leads to DurtyHarry's... deserves its reputation as Key West's 2:00 am place for piazza.
No ac... open to the street... When the outside temperature's hot, the piazza ovens are going full blast and Angelina's full of hungry people, this place is hotter than the hinges of hell.
You can get a whole pie or order by the slice.. The crust is hand tossed... Your pie or slice is made to order... The toppings are abundant... The food is delicious (its not gourmet food... but you don't expect gourmet food in this joint).
Go late at night and watch the circus on Duvall Street while you eat your piazza.
Decent pizza when you need drunk food
Good street pizza.... Street pizza is any pizza sold directly over a counter or from a truck and consumed outdoors. This street pizza is among the best in KW. Always good and you get a fair sized slice for $3.50.
Good pizza...workers are A$$HOLES...try harder next time ya pricks.
Pizza was good. Good prices also, 3.50 a slice, and the slices are big. Cool atmosphere and awesome music
Great Little Place. I loved this place, and I am much harder on judging pizza joints than any other place, it was a little pricey for slices but given the location it was in it was expected but non the less still a little pricey. The slices were still great, I even came back a second and a third time and the guys working there were extremely friendly even at 1am with all the drunks and long lines they still were pleasant and kept the hot slices coming, ill deffinately come back next time im in the Keys, hopefully they might have a 2 slice and a soda special by then.
A Favorite among the Locals. This is one of the favored pizza restaraunts preferred by the locals. It is a step above most other pizza places, they do pile on the toppings, and the quality of the sauce and cheese you can really taste.
Good Pizza for the Crawl. Not necessarily the best pizza on the rock (I vote Big Johns for that), but it is a good slice to grab while doing the Duval Crawl. I don't know how many times I have grabbed a slice while hitting the bars on Duval. Plus, the kids love the pizza here.
This pizza was exactly what we needed as we ended our night on Duval Street. Slices are huge and delicious. Service was fast and the employees were friendly. We also enjoyed playing the video games while we waited for our orders to come out!
Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had, don’t know why this place isn’t closer to 5 stars, but whatever. If you’re in key west and want some pizza, come here. Don’t waste time at a chain restaurant.
Growing up in NY/NJ and eating pizza weekly this pizza hit the spot! Traditional NY style with a crispy under-carriage and a nice flop. Mr.Portny needs to hit this spot if he hasn’t already. Could use a little more sauce (imo) but solid 7.5/10. Better then seaside cafe at the mansion.
Great pizza, unique joint! Prices for toppings are expensive. Came out pretty fast considering how busy they were. Served hot! Very tasty. Gave us plates and napkins :) clean eat in area.
Good customizable pizza slice! Great staff!
The best pizza I’ve ever eaten! Went here on my trip at about 1 AM and this place was jammed packed. Great service and big portion size.
Visit my YouTube Channel/THUMPER RUSTY, for all of the vids I've done from around the country!
**** BESTEST PIZZA ****
"IN ALL THE WEST"...
Get a "LOADED sLiCe" or the "Whole FaNgDaNgLeD Pie"
You won't be "Shootin' Blanks" cause it'll make your partner "GO WILD!" And get Ur PIZZA and METAL FIX "ALL 'N' ONE" on METAL MONDAY!
ATTENTION: Unless it's BLUES 30... Oh, Yeah!
At's Italiano...
At's Parmigiano...
At's Mozzarello...
At's Oregano...
WARNING: This place can get loud ANYTIME!
Great pizza and the prices are perfect! Nice quick bite to eat when you want to keep seeing the sights!
Just my thought & opinion
+5
Great pizza no matter what time of day or night u pick it up! Fresh hot by the slice or whole.. made to order any way u like! Staff is great 😊 keep up the good work!
The pizza is great, but the subs are a underrated treasure. Get ‘em warmed, cheesy- great stuff. Price is great too! For Key West, you wont find a better, pizza or sub at a better price. Kit and Mike are awesome too!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key West
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes