We've eaten here several times over the years of our visits and are always so impressed with the food, the staff, and the wines. Everything here is wonderful! We love the ceviches and the oysters Rockefeller! All fish dishes and the scallops are amazing! Eat up!
Cute restaurant. They have a great happy hour deal. Their customer service was on point. Will come back to try their entree next time in town.
Delicious and so fresh! Short vacation but we’ve come here twice now and if we can will come again before we leave. The shrimp were fabulous (and deveined! Ty!!!) the oysters were so good and of course STONE CRAB!!! Oh and they are super welcoming as well. Highly recommend
The food is worth every penny. The rating did not lie. The scallops, lobster bisque, and special: yellow edge grouper are a must! The service was nice. The people were kind. The food was amazing. I will most likely come back when I visit.
We started out with Mac & Cheese Croquettes, mussels and oysters for appetizers. All were amazing! And honestly, the oysters were some of best we’ve had in Key West! For main course, we ordered Scallops and the snapper and both were also delicious. We ended with both desserts, bread pudding and the honey poached pear because we could not decide and let me tell you.. neither disappointed. Both were extremely delicious and flavorful; The perfect way to end our meals.
The staff was extremely attentive and quick. We highly recommend Thirsty Mermaid and will absolutely be back!
If I could give it a higher score I would!
The green Gazpacho is to die for!!!
We both enjoyed our salad. The bacon on my wedge was big pieces that made it even better. The yellowfin tuna was very well seasoned!
A must do in the Keys
We had a lovely dinner at this restaurant while visiting Key West. We had visited Little Pearl, their sister restaurant, and were very impressed. This one had a different vibe but still very cozy and intimate restaurant. Food was very good. I had a giant burger and my husband had the catch of day. Both were excellent. Our server Ava was very friendly and charming, talking to us about the local wildlife. Great job all around!
The Thirsty Mermaid is great! Very delicious food. Friendly service. Beautifully decorated interior. Without doubt worth going to! Have a great day!
Can’t recommend this spot enough. If you are looking for an upscale happy hour at a very affordable price look no further. The oysters were the best I had on the island over the week hands down. Super fresh super cold and delicious. The staff was more than welcoming and happy and helpful. Great little dining space with a small sit up bar. Fresh taps on hand. Check em out!
Found this Gem last year! FANTASTIC!!!and This year was no exception. If you are new to the keys this is a MUST. Happy hour 4 to 6 with $8 small plates! We’re not huge mussel fans but decided to try them. So glad we did they were fantastic and the butter garlic lemon broth was to die for. Service is also top notch.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key West
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes