Sluurpy
Reset

There are 10 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Ithaca

There are 10 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cornell Dairy Bar
98/100 (615 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Sorbet and Blueberry Ice Cream
Strawberry and Cookies and Creme Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream in a Sugar Cone Kiddie Size
Seneca Sunset Sorbet
Grape
Chocolate Milk
Mint Chocolate Chip
Brownie Sunday
Sandwiches
Honey Crunch
Gelato
California Roll
Salad
Raspberry Custard
Ice Cream
Orange Cream Soda
Two Scoops on a Waffle Cone
Mint Chocolate Cookie
Sit down
American
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Cheap Eats
"Loved visiting the new Cornell Dairy Bar. Last time I visited, it was in a different location. Loved new dairy bar! Service was fast and efficient. I..."
Margaret Hahn
"First time to try Bavarian Raspberry Fudge and I loved it!!! I've never tried anything like it before and I highly recommend it. Looking forward to..."
Christopher Lasa (Chris)
"Ice cream was amazing! Rich and thick, there where 7 of us so we ordered a variety of flavors. Staff was nice and attentive. Chocolate milk was also..."
hannah D
"Not to be missed. The ice creams and the flavors are simply amazing. They are always in rotation. Some of the texture of ice creams were incredible...."
Santosh Shetty
"As this is located in my school (I graduated last summer tho), hopefully, this review is not biased but I will always say that I lovvveeee knowing..."
Anne Dewanto
"Amazing ice cream, amazing staff, amazing pricing, amazing portions...I think that covers it. Everything is made by them, and when the milk is from..."
Rawad Elias
"Lots of good flavors of ice cream sourced from their own cows (Cornell University) on..."
Sherri Geissinger
"Great place to stop by during the summer! Sundaes are big!! Excellent customer..."
Addison Dodge
"Get an iconic scoop of ice cream and set out on the Cornell Botanical Gardens for a perfect summer..."
Kushal D
"A great spot to visit it you are exploring campus. Excellent ice cream that make wonderful shakes. You can buy dairy products and maple syrup in bulk..."
Greg Knapp
Smart Yogurt
93/100 (16 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
"Great vibe!!! The decor and atmosphere is very similar with the yogurt place down the road, but it's worth the extra couple hundred feet (next to..."
Timothy Smith
"I never liked frozen yogurt but Smart Yogurt converted me. That's how awesome it is. They have two locations - one on Route 13 heading out of town..."
Catherine Norton-Barker
""
Galit Poole
""
B G
Collegetown Bagels
89/100 (2136 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Gluten Free Options
Cafe
Vegan Options
American
Fast Food
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Breakfast
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Salad
Toasts
Breakfast Sandwich
Ice Cream
Bagels
Paninis
Café
American
Café
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Late Night
Lunch
Drinks
Cheap Eats
"Nova lox with cream cheese, tomatoes, onions and capers on a toasted Rosemary Salt bagel. On the side with an Iced Matcha Latte. It was a perfect..."
Beauti Unique
"Love this spot! Beautiful atmosphere. SOO many options. Staff very friendly. Quick service. Indoor and some outdoor seating. Highly..."
Jess
"DELISH!!! I loved the vibe, coffee, bagels and variety. I had to stop myself from visiting a third time before heading back to the Mitten state. Also..."
Elizabeth Woodford
"This place was recommended by some friends and Cornell Alumni. Plenty of space to sit and talk inside. Lots of options (not just bagels). I had a..."
Travis Gylling
"Glad Collegetown Bagels is still around! They were smaller and on the other side of College Ave when 30+ years ago. When I was just there last..."
Jeff Lee
"Have been to the area few times, but first visit to Collegetown Bagels, I must say it’s much more than the name says. Lots of varieties, food &..."
Robert Lo
"Great food, although I really don't understand the whole push towards massive salt crystals on rosemary bagels. Eating there is always a treat, in..."
An Zhang
"Delicious bagels. The bagel menu is extensive so i took a while to decide. The smooth menu was also big. You can customize the smoothie with whatever..."
Hong Hanh Dinh
"Went in College Town Bagel just to see what the talk was all about this place. My son and I had a Brunch at the place and gotta say, my taste buds..."
Timothy Greenwalt
"Absolutely the best bagel 🥯 shop hands down … I grew up in Brooklyn and I know good bagels… take it from me this place is worth the stop and..."
bulldod23
"Great place for coffee, snacks, sweets and excellent vibe to enjoy the weather. Loved the bagel especially the egg/Pesto one with the..."
Gaurav Kalani
"Good place for good sandwiches. Frickin chickin and Milanese are good if you like..."
Anuj Ashok
"Food is amazing, service is just as great. We have been everyday since we have been visiting Ithaca. The New Yorker, Italian, and Round House..."
Aaron Berger
"Ordered the Brooklyn on a Rosemary Salt bagel. Bagel was delicious, but the cheese could have used a little more time to melt. Would definitely..."
Danny Allegretti
"Yummy sandwiches and bagels, a staple for Cornell students. They have a variety of options that cater to different diets, including halal. That being..."
Sommaya H.
Purity Ice Cream Co
84/100 (3605 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Cheesecake
Ice Cream
Cupcakes
Cakes
Sandwiches
Pancakes
Café
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Cheap Eats
"Purity Ice Cream Co. is seriously awesome! 🍦⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I recently swung by for a scoop of their butter pecan, mocha, and strawberry flavors,..."
Sarat Pidaparthi
"Had to stop in here while visiting Ithaca - as its a famous local spot! Super cute ice cream parlor! It was busy on a Saturday night & the wait..."
Heather Boswick
"We had a great lunch here. The burgers were juicy and delicious. I've always loved going to Purity Ice Cream but this was my first visit in years. ..."
Vito Brancato
"Fries chicken is really great! So are the sweet potato fries! I did feel they could have had more sweet potato fries in the order though! I didn’t..."
Stefania I
"Great ice cream! Amazing selection of flavors and wide variety of their deserts. In the back they serve food too. Parking is easy peasy. The coffee..."
Matt Daniel
"First time here but it won't be the last! We loved how easy it was to order- you can use a tablet and look through all the options, or you can order..."
K S
"Not quite a 4 star but better than a 3 star. Love the variety, the commitment to renewable energy and the retro vibe. The ice cream was both a good..."
Emma Tamlin
"I'm a big fried chicken sandwich guy. For some weird reason. Compared to all the fried chickens I've had in town. This one is the best. Breading is..."
Dan F
"Delicious. I got a sundae with chocolate cupcakes and two flavors. Happy trails was one! I also stopped by on my way out of town to grab dry ice, you..."
Elizabeth Woodford
"If you’re looking for a unique spot to grab some ice cream, check this place out! I’ve been here twice now (a few years apart) and both times..."
Murielle Fedorko
"Purity has been around for a long time, and for good reason. The amount of choices in flavors alone is astounding. They do have nondairy options, if..."
Melissa S.
"Absolutely fantastic ice cream spot! Stopped here while in town to visit. Staff was friendly. Everything tastes fresh. My apple crisp Sunday was..."
Andrew Scarpulla
"This is THE must-go ice cream place that every tourist and most locals go to. An Ithaca institution since the 1930s, Purity has tons of flavors...."
Thomas Craver
"I love Purity Ice Cream! The many flavors are absolutely delicious! I'd like to try them all! It's nice they accommodate different..."
Linda Burns
"Strawberry and pistachio 5/5, And chocolate raspberry 3/5! They have great quality. It was not artificial flavor and not too sweet! Very..."
Chunhee Hong
"They forgot to give this very red woman more root beer after SHE spilled her own root beer. Would have been 5 stars if this event did not occur...."
Andrew Reardon
Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop
83/100 (676 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
Ice Cream
Café
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Great quality and great on a hot day! Variety of flavors, with chocolate, cherry, and another kind of dip for the soft serve. Would..."
Yotfus96
"I absolutely love going to Sweet Melissa's for delicious soft serve ice cream. I live in Dallas and come home every July for a visit. One of my..."
Peggy Richards
"Had a flurry with orange-vanilla swirl. Easily the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Can’t wait until I’m back in town to get..."
Bill Boroson
"Lovely people working the counter. Friendly, good listeners, patient and honor their stamped cards from years back. ..."
Valerie Jordan-Mount
"Yummy! I had the Large one in a cup but it was an Extra large serving..."
Haider Niaz
"One of the best ice cream I’ve ever..."
Ethan Pae
"Excellent ice cream with great options. See why everyone loves this..."
David Berkowitz
"Sweet Melissa's has the best vegan ice cream made with coconut milk..."
Miriam Epstein
"Loved the lemon ricotta (hard) ice cream with chocolate dip! Cash only, no seating on the premises. If you can't make it during their limited open..."
Cynthia Heider
"Sure, it’s a pretty basic looking spot but you could tell it would be good with all the people in the parking lot enjoying their icecream. Cash..."
Crystal Monkman
"Sweet Melissas is the spot!! Melissa is awesome and the ice cream never disappoints. It’s the perfect place to go to after a hot day of swimming in..."
Via Carpenter
"The peanut butter strawberry sundae was..."
Andrew Ceurter
"I'm sure you've had ice cream, but you've never had this ice cream. As the locals know (and pretty much everyone now) the hard serve is where things..."
Anna G
"Sweet Melissa's serves up the best soft serve I have had. There's just something special about it. They have vegan ice cream and their own home made..."
A. Lambert
Collegetown Bagels
83/100 (683 ratings)
Quick Bites
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Cafe
American
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Drinks
Chocolate Covered Cheesecake
Salad
Everything Wheat Bagel
Egg on a Bagel Sandwich and Coffee
Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese
Bagel with Egg and Ham
Everything Bagel w Lox
Tiramisu with a Juice Bom
Breakfast Sandwich
Ice Cream
Pizza Bagel
Bagels
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Cider
Panini
Breakfast Sandwich
Bacon Sandwich
Chicken Sausage Egg and Pepper Jack Cheese on a Za'Atar Bagel
Sit down
American
Café
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Gift Cards Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Cheap Eats
"CTB is a great place to have a quick bite when in Ithaca. The bagels and the sandwiches are good. Prices are also very reasonable. There are no table..."
William Ho
"Overwhelmed choice on the menu solved by just specifying what we wanted, and it was made to order! Delicious bagels and filling was exactly as we..."
Tony Heher
"Great bagels! The menu was overwhelming and I didn’t know where to look first to figure out my order. Ended up with a great plain bagel. The turkey..."
Matt Daniel
"Fantastic food. Amazing vegan options. The cookie butter chai was banger. Also the poppyseed bagel with veggie cream cheese hit the spot. Highly..."
joe pines
"Great place for sandwiches and bagels! Sandwiches are good! Also they have good breakfast sandwiches! Coffee was great. Indoor and outdoor seating. ..."
Alexander Shyshla
"Very nice place to eat breakfast/lunch and friendly staff. My only point is you have to be in one line to make an order, then go to another line..."
Salem Alnahdi
"The hype about this place is worth it. Everything is super efficient while still being very welcoming and casual. Huge amount of options for food, as..."
Jax Syms
"I’m coming from New York City which some say is famous for a little doughy ball of heaven known as the bagel, and I’d gladly eat these bagels and..."
David Berkowitz
"We have breakfast here frequently when we visit Ithaca. Food and coffee are very good. Cool atmosphere. Staff is friendly but they recently changed..."
Don Allen
"Great options! Vegans and veg heads friendly! Had the power plant breakfast sandwich. Vegan sausage, egg on bagel. Downtown Ithaca..."
Julie LeBeau
"Good bagels. Had a Bronx Bagel with a za'atar bagel, chicken sausage, pepper jack and avacado. I like the mediterranean twist with the Za'atar..."
Mike Graz
"It was a wait for our order (sandwich and coffee ordered separately, which TBH didn't make much sense to me...) BUT it was well worth it. I recommend..."
Justin Sisenstein
"The bagels here are great! Service was fast, do take note that drinks and food are ordered at separate counters! You order food first, then get a..."
Angelle Doherty
"A lovely place for a delicious breakfast. Bagels were super good and delicious, the almond cookie was great and the coffee..."
Wassim Ayass
"10 outta 10 you should get breakfast here. Best breakfast sandwich I’ve had in a long time. It’s laid back and in the heart of Ithaca. Do..."
Elliot Jacobson
15 Below
81/100 (112 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Breakfast
Ice Cream
Café
American
Fast food
Breakfast
Mid-range
Cheap Eats
"I definitely recommend this place it’s so delicious. The first ice-cream place I tried in Ithaca. Might stick with it as my primary ice-cream..."
Bamba Ndiaye
"Great service and amazing ice cream for such a cute little shop. Definitely..."
jay
"Absolutely amazing ice cream. Craft before your eyes. So creamy and delicious! 10 out of 10 would..."
Cara Duke
"Great ice cream! Absolutely worth..."
Andrew A
"#1 and Hong Kong Milk Tea were both excellent. It's cool to watch it being..."
Andrew Dickson
"I love this place. Definitely going again, they have a amazing variety of icecream and it was so cool to see it being made. Nice and cheep for the..."
Addison Moore
"I am so excited to have an ice cream shop like this in Ithaca! I got strawberry ice cream topped with whipped cream, blueberries, kiwi, and mango,..."
Madly Nadly
"Parking is a little difficult in this area, but the ice cream itself is most delicious. Service is a little slow but it is a craft experience. I'd..."
Joy Monroe
"Great Oreo ice cream and even better service! Jelly babies a..."
Anthony Hillan
"Rolled ice cream in cheapest and great taste..."
Jananthan Paramsothy
"The most entertaining Ice cream in Ithaca. All the flavors are delicious. Can be a little slow at busy times as each dish is made to order but it's..."
Nick Tubbs
"So good! The server was super fast and it is so yummy and fun to..."
Abigail Haycraft
Coltivare
79/100 (461 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Barbecue Shrimp Cocktail
Meatballs
Ice Cream
Prosciutto
Gelato
Pasta
Creme Brulee
Salad
Cakes
Bruschette
Crab
Pesto
Scallops
Fish
Duck
Pork
Risotto
Crème Brulée
Pizza
Salmon
Pork Belly
Burger
Bruschetta Trio
Panna Cotta
Buffalo Cauliflower
Cheese and Charcuterie Plate
BBQ burger
Ribs
Short Rib Pasta
Charcuterie board
Shrimp
Gimmie Coffee Crème Bruleé
Beef
Sit down
American
Accepts Credit Cards
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Reservations
Street Parking
Seating
Cash Only
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"The food was really good! The staff were very nice. The portion sizes are in consistent though, with the desert being humongous. The veggie burger..."
Matt Daniel
"The staff were very attentive and kept pace with the meal, very appropriate for the occasion. I ordered both the Apple Fest macaroni and a..."
Daniel Goldhorn
"We had our wedding welcome dinner here and it was a wonderful venue! It could accommodate 80 people comfortably and the food was delicious! Nikita..."
Amanda Pustis
"Amazing experience, the waitstaff was quick and attentive. The food was outstanding. I will recommend the Buffalo cauliflower as an appetizer, it..."
Hannah Freelove
"Great overall experience service/setting. NOLA shrimp and meatballs were good appetizers and my short rib was perfectly cooked. Mom found the bbq..."
Jeff Fields
"Hand's down one of the best meals I've had out in a long time. Beautiful atmosphere and the wait staff was very attentive. 10 out of..."
Kristy
"Do yourself a favor and make this place part of your Ithaca experience! Born and raised in Southwest Louisiana, I don’t trust restaurants up north..."
Megan Poole
"Very nice ambiance and menu. Lots of mixed drink, wine and craft beer choices. Food was delicious! Service was friendly and excellent. Great place..."
Dan Fields (The Ride Abides)
"Excellent service, tasty selections artfully plated in an inviting setting. Very attentive and friendly staff. Creative menu choices with delicious..."
Ed Fischer
"Great ambiance, lots of bricks and a very Innovative interior where food and raw materials are part of the decor that makes this place unique from..."
Mohamed Badaoui Najjar
"My wife and I got married in Ithaca in July 2022, and Coltivare was an amazing place to have our rehearsal dinner and day-after brunch. The food was..."
William Leach
Friendly's
77/100 (479 ratings)
Restaurants
Dessert
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Ice Cream
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"OK I can't love this place more after today. Our waitress was very busy with customers but her smile and patience was a 10 plus. After receiving my..."
Irene Wilson
"They have the juiciest burgers ever. It’s so good. The butter pecan Sunday was also delicious, my favorite. Order your food in advance as they are..."
Bamba Ndiaye
"Visiting from out of town, was cool to see this place is still around. we were apprehensive because of the negative reviews but the staff was great...."
Brian Villanueva
"The chef was amazing! Very involved with what her customers want. And the taste was awesome! The wait staff could have been a little more attentive..."
Esther Snavely
"Great server, fun atmosphere. Even got serenaded by the staff because their radio doesn't work. Perks of having the restaurant to myself. A+ good..."
S. S.
Yogurt Crazy
70/100 (319 ratings)
Restaurants
Ice Cream
"After a long day of hiking, then getting clean after we ran out of places to eat. Thankfully D.P. Dough was open at 11 and delivered our food. We..."
Emily Karsten
"The quality of the food is like 6 to 7 out of 10. However it's the only late night restaurant in town and they have great service, so that makes up..."
Cory Walaitis
"These are the type of people that you want to make a calzone for you. Food was delivered fast, hot and delicious. We got two calzones, the garlic..."
Caitlin Lawrence
"I ordered a calzone and the cheese sticks. They were delicious. The people working were very friendly and had my food out quickly. Best food..."
Ryan Friedman
"calzones are good and its super clutch to have someplace open late at..."
A Gallagher
"the food was fresh & hot and the workers were SO..."
Abigail Gordon
"Been ordering from them for years now and can honestly say they’re one of the best, especially late night, restaurants around. Great Calzones as..."
Paul Morgan
"They must put cocaine in those calzones. How do you make a creation this good. The oozing cheese off the soft fresh bread crust dipped into the..."
Jonathan Segal
"I have loved DP Dough since my own college days at UMass Amherst 30 years ago. The quality of calzones are even better now and I am never..."
kelly Molito
"Seriously the best calzone I have ever had. People who work here are to the point and honest (no BS about wait times). Highly recommend the Bro Zone..."
Joseph Spak
"I've ordered you guys on and off for years ( I work nights). Recently I lost my phone while doing some late night post-work dog walking on a sketchy..."
Jonni Campbell
"Good calzones with a ton of selection. This place is a staple to many in Ithaca, but I rarely find myself going or ordering. Takes on average 10-20..."
Nathan Adara
"Ate lunch at the Green St. location at least a handful of times a month. LOVED the End Zone - beef and onions and green peppers... so good! Franchise..."
Phil
"DP Dough. Man. What can I say about this place? You come out of one of the pubs near commons after a night of drinking. It's late. And you are..."
Bhargav Sanketi
"An Ithaca classic. DP Dough serves up the best, most fresh, customizable calzones along with some awesome cheesy bacon tots and an amazing calzone..."
Meagan T
"this is my go to when i go to ithaca. arriving in ithaca at 1 am? no problem! dp dough has got you. i've had so many delicious calzones but i'm dying..."
Eva Spak
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use