The best Fish in Islamorada | Sluurpy updated in April

Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

77/100 (3867 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegetarian Friendly

Soups

Seafood

American

Caribbean

Gluten Free Options

Bar

Seafood

American

Bar

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Breakfast

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Fish Sandwich

Lobster

Polenta

Pasta

Burrito

Salad

Omelette

Key lime pie

Crab

Ceviche

Scallops

Cuban Sandwich

Tuna

Sandwiches

Crepes

Cheeseburger

Pesto

Burger

Fish

Chowder

Tapas

Fish Taco

Tacos

Shrimp

Sit down

American

Seafood

Bar

Free Wifi

Accepts Credit Cards

Takeout

Television

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Seating

Accepts American Express

Table Service

Live Music

Wheelchair Accessible

Waterfront

Accepts Discover

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Breakfast

Dinner

Lunch

Brunch

Mid-range

"This was our first time in the Keys, and as recommended by our friends, the Hungry Tarpon was the best for breakfast. The menu offers great breakfast..."

Kristen Rossi

"We had an awesome time here feeding the tarpon, shopping and relaxing by the water. Cute little shops and if you get the shaved ice, get The..."

Sandy McKnight-Lauer

"Giving this a 3.5 mostly because it was just a fun place in a location with a fun funky vibe. Most seating is outdoors so you can watch the goings..."

CLA2000

"🔆🌴 Look at this Bloody Mary! It's Amazing!It's almost like a meal, lol. Very yummy food, the portions are enormous. Great view, and..."

Arseny Arsik

"A great locals place! Wonderful breakfasts and lunches! Sometimes there is a wait, but worth it! Feed the poons while you wait or book a fishing..."

Capt John

"We were there during Costume party and the kids, band and wait staff was fun. We stopped on the way back from Key West to Key Largo. Best fish Tacos..."

Scott

"Tacky Tourist looking for something yummy and we found it. Our family of 3 each had something different.. Fish and chips, fish sandwhich, and shrimp..."

Joy Nazworth

"Great food..we had the shrimp burrito and fish taco! Be prepared for a wait! Feed the tarpon..."

Rc

"Stop here! Eat, feed tarpon and see the fab Keys art. It is a..."

Renee

"Absolute fun! What a great find on the way down the Keys. This waterfront establishment is not short on great comfort food but serves up family..."

Peanutgallery

"Great lunch!. This was a perfect spot to eat a good lunch. You can sit at the bar and look out over the water. The food was really good (some of the..."

Tim Brownell

"Great!. Very happy with everything we ordered. Lobster bisque was great! We had the Blackened fish tacos, shrimp quesadilla, fish basket (large..."

L. Hansen

"My wife had their special of the day, stuffed black grouper. Said it will be quite a while before something will top that meal. Portions were..."

Kevin O'Neill

"Had lunch here before going to feed the Tarpon at Robbie's. The service a crappy but that's because they were understaffed that day. The food was..."

Spencer

"Stopped to see the tarpon at Robbies. Desided to have brunch here. Great service. Lots of choices on the menu. Food was surprisingly fantastic...."

Brenda Haugh Boyd

"This pla e was recommended by everyone that we talked to. Had a delicious fresh tuna roll, very reasonable. Had a brand new waitress that was great!..."

Matt

"We stopped here for breakfast and it was AMAZING! The dish we had was te Hungry Tarpon. It's hash browns, jack cheese, eggs and sausage gravy all on..."

Robert P

"Yummmmmyyyy!!! Service isn't the greatest!! But it sooo..."

Kt

"Shrimp burrito was great! Daiquiris were not so great. Fun..."

Mariah

"My husband and I ate breakfast here 3 times during our trip to Islamorada. I highly recommend the lobster frittata with hashbrowns. The Alligator..."

Lisa Nunez

"Great View. What more could I possible ask For! I had a poor boy shrimp sandwich that was great sitting outside next to the water with..."

Shannon

"Good food and good service.. Like stopping there driving down to the Keys to kick back, have luinch by the water and watching those crazy people feed..."

Lelli

"Rustic Florida all the way. Very good food right on the water. Great place for..."

Joe T

"Outstanding Dinner. Joseph is a great chef, and each time we go to dinner he suprises us with something new. This place is really understated, but..."

ZinnMeister

"Fabulous!. The best breakfast- huge portions! Dinner is also amazing. French Carribean Chef Joseph makes fresh seafood, fabulous prime rib, and other..."

Keyslinds

"Small Place Great Taste!. I love this place, I have to go every time I go back to visit the Keys. Not a fancy restaurant by any means, just a hole in..."

Brian Allen

"The shrimp borrito was awsome! Don't forget to feed the tarpon from the dock's out..."

Melbeachsurfer

"This was a great find -- it's not a palace, but the food was very good and decently priced ($10.95 for a delicious, two thumbs-up shrimp burrito). I..."

Foodsmith

"A little pricey. Their prices are a little pricey considering the atmosphere of the restaurant which is basically a diner (unless you can sit..."

Shari

"From the moment we arrived to the moment we left it was impeccable service, food and a great time. We loved watching people feed and get bit by the..."

Sue Crippa - Mata

"So fantastic! We ate here after feeding the Tarpon 🤣. It was delicious 🤤 the staff was fantastic! The food came to us super quickly and was..."

Meg “Family Travel”

"Feeding the Tarpon was pretty cool, and looking at all artifacts, but when it came time to order food, which came out a decent time frame, I ordered..."

Justin Willett

"I was bummed they were closed on my last trip through Islamorada but they were updating their system. I made sure I stopped by on this trip for..."

Susan Bell

"Great food, service was really friendly . Cool touristy thing to do. Food was large servings and dessert was to die for. Wat hing ppl feed the fish..."

Amanda Campbell

"💕💕🏝️Great location, super fun, atmosphere, great food, mediocre service. The breakfast, pancake tacos were out of this world! And simply..."

Diana G

"Food was very good!! We really enjoyed the macncheese balls!! And the Maui tacos were also great!! Service was a little slow, our guy got bombarded..."

Sherrie Cerrito

"Always love stopping and having lunch on our way to or from Key West. Excellent service and delicious food. Along with great views. The Tarpon and..."

Burmman Jess

"One of our favourite places for food on the planet! The menu choice is excellent, food quick and absolutely delicious...there are so many food..."

Oliver Fytche-Taylor

"It is a tourist trap worth stopping at!! Loved everything! The food was great to and just the right portion to have a little left for the iguanas!..."

Dea Kadolph

"Yummy food, neat environment, unique gift shops, and great entertainment! We enjoyed lunch at the Hungry Tarpon restaurant on our way down to Key..."

Chelsea Cravey

"We enjoyed lunch at this Florida Keys iconic place. Stopped for lunch and to feed the tarpon. The crunchy grouper sandwich was awesome as well as the..."

RD Massengale

"Nice little spot for lunch after a fun time kayaking! Super crowded, but it was Friday afternoon. Had the Korean spicy chicken sliders, they were..."

Andy Bodnar

"Great place to go and people watch. Feed some tarpons as well as have some food and drinks very laid back atmosphere you won't be disappointed. They..."

Jonathon taylor

"Jason is the man. He makes the skinny margaritas in the Keys! The fried conch with the Caribbean sauce is a must. We will definitely be returning..."

Andre Brown

"We chanced on this place and it is amazing!!! The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting. The staff are busy and are on top of their craft. Food..."

Scott Winter

"Fun spot to watch Pelicans sneak fish from buckets meant to feed to Tarpon and watch people’s reaction to Tarpon 3 feet to 8 feet jump for a fish..."

Stacy Klone

Islamorada Fish Company

75/100 (9131 ratings)

Restaurants

Seafood

American

Soups

Seafood

American

Vegan Options

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Gluten Free Options

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Chowder

Tapas

Lobster

Fish Taco

Pasta

Tacos

Salad

Clam Chowder

Fish Sandwich

Crab

Scallops

Clams

Fried shrimp

Oyster

Bass

Key lime pie

Calamari

Sandwiches

Grouper Sandwich

Tuna

Burger

Cakes

Calamares

Pesto

Fish

Shrimp

Fish & chips

Crab Cake

Sit down

American

Seafood

Digital Payments

Accepts Credit Cards

Family style

Dog Friendly

Outdoor Seating

Seating

Takeout

Table Service

Television

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Serves Alcohol

Live Music

Wine and Beer

Parking Available

Waterfront

Free off-street parking

Accepts Discover

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Late Night

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Agradable parada a almorzar en los Cayos de FL. El lugar agradable y familiar, con una gran vista, mar, palmeras y arena. Hay gran variedad de..."

Ramiro Figueroa Araya

"Fantastic food, friendly and prompt waitress. Super water and sunset views. Very clean. Great decor. Open air restaurant. Nice bathrooms. Fun little..."

MAMA Bookasaurus

"Not bad. Not great. Beautiful views. Wonderful atmosphere. Big key lime pie bowl for dessert. Share it. Service was..."

Jim Hughes

"Great food, great..."

Jason

"We (two couples) stopped in for a drink only before going to dinner. We sat at the bar. Service was prompt, polite, and the place was very enjoyable...."

Kate

"Good food and service. We ate breakfast at the restaurant on Marathon, and had key lime "pie" bowls and coffee at the one in Islamorada. It is a..."

FL Food Critic

"We ate down by the water. Beautiful view of boats on the marina. Excellent crab cakes, so so calamari, good selection of drinks and a large kid's..."

Terri O'neill

"Love the atmosphere. You can feed the fish, watch the sunset, enjoy the view. The only thing we didn't like was that they changed their key lime pie..."

JJB

"Really enjoyed it! I was nervous about eating here when i saw the other reviews. I had the wasabi tuna it was great with rice. I also had the clam..."

Agdfall01

"Classic Keys. I really miss it. Service "sucks". Food is fried and pricey. I'd be there right now, if I could. Drinking a bad beer, waiting for..."

Florida Robert

"Great atmosphere on a nice day. Food good for that kind of place. Good stop for a beer, sandwich, and..."

Netwrkr95

"This is a solid yet touristy fish place on the water. It is fun and relaxing, and a good lunch option. I read other reviews about frozen fish,..."

Charles Lyon

"A must visit.... Islamorada Fish Company is the perfect Keys spot to eat and / or get a cold drink. The food, service and atmosphere are all great! I..."

Rich1McK

"Fresh fish, YES! The food, service & entertainment were great! If you ask for the fresh catch you will find it. The stone crab I ordered was the BEST..."

Carol Sipek

"Grouper sandwich was delicious. Fast, friendly service with great..."

Becky

"Good for kids. If there weren't so many great places in Islamorada, this would stand out. But, there are better alternatives. That said, the food was..."

Foodiemom

"Awesome Atmosphere...Great Food!. We loved the Islamorada Fish Co...I mean, who wouldn't love to eat under a GIANT tiki hut on the ocean? We even..."

Kari1211

"The best fish spread ever!. Consistently good, fresh seafood. Waterside dining. Service is sometimes slow due to large crowds (and what does that..."

CLC3

"Great place for a drink and a place to eat on the water. Watch the tarpon and sharks in central area and great..."

Kafue007

"Good food at very decent prices for the area - worth going just to see the sharks that hang out in the water near the seating..."

Linda M

"Always a stop when in The Keys! Wonderful place to sit & have a drink with a great view. Food is usually great & fresh, but my husbands fried grouper..."

Watty

"Favorite Keys Restaurant. I've been going to this restaurant for years. It has gotten a bit touristy but still very good. I personally know one of..."

Santi

"Great food at a nice price but the service was way to slow 2 hours for 4..."

Mr. Dude

"Great lobster bisque...that's all I can vouch..."

Joseph Wiedman

"Fresh seafood. Great food. Great location. Excellent ocean views / atmosphere. Really cool when they fed the tarpon and sharks in the..."

Crystal Collins

"Adorable. The view/entertainment and ambiance alone could drag me back here even if they were serving dog food. Luckily the food and drinks were very..."

Jo

"Great market & Tiki bar. Food great too. Great place to watch fish and watch the sunset over the water. Eat..."

Jim L

"Incedible view, especially at sunset. Food 3/5, service 2/5. Prices $$. Would definitely return and eat for the view..."

John The Traveler

"Great food and incredible ocean view from every table. Our favorite restaurant in the..."

Mark J Lampman

"Great atmosphere but service was a bit slow. Food was okay but not great, not the best in the area but good..."

Tony Cooper

"GREAT PLACE TO RELAX. When you get to the Keys you expect Great Atmosphere, cool breezes and FRESH SEAFOOD. That's exactly what you get at this..."

BariatricTravelers

"Loved it! Nice oceanfront location with lots of shade and comfy chairs. The dolphin fish was especially good. We're even going to hit it up on our..."

Carli Gray

"My second time here. The food so far has been consistently good. Covered outdoor atmosphere. You can bring fish that you caught and they will cook..."

Egirl Kalamanani

"Lovely place. located on the water, fish swimming all around. The perfect atmosphere. Service was excellent, very kind and friendly. The food was..."

Aviv Ron

"Beautiful views, great service, and an all-inclusive family feel is what made this restaurant a gem. I'm not a big seafood guy myself. Oysters were..."

Max Martin

"We had our wedding here Oct 17th and it was amazing. The island beach wedding we dreamed of ! The food was great, the staff friendly, and my..."

Jeniffer Colatriano

"We had a wonderful family dinner here on our vacation to the Keys! Favorites off the menu were the coconut shrimp, ribs, and fish dip. We had very..."

Jo Vic

"Fresh seafood. The seafood tower was amazing. The oysters were so good even the kids asked for a few. The fried whole yellowtail was to die for. The..."

Z Nava

"You truly cannot beat the view here at Islamorada fish company. They had nice live music that helped create a relaxing atmosphere, and the food was..."

Courtney Dust

"Wonderful food and amazing service! Sunset views were beautiful! This was our first time going to this location. We'll be back on our next trip..."

Dawn Rutherford

"Food is OK (oysters are not as fresh vs. other places) but the atmosphere is best. Pick the seats outside next to the ocean to enjoy the breeze in a..."

Danny Quynh Lam Ong

"Finally made to Isamorada Fish Company. Outdoor seating a plenty! Very good tiki vibe next to the water. Huge Tarpon swimming around to look at. ..."

living_maas_life

"This is a very beautiful restaurant located ocean views . the seafood is very fresh and you will have wonderful time with your relatives..."

Hal Ginny

"Great food with an amazing atmosphere. Raphael is the best and had great recommendations. They had tarpon and a manatee come by. The staff provided..."

Dave Pollack

"Islamorada Fish Company is behind Bass Pro Shops Worldwide Sportsman store. The food is very good, decent portions. The blackened Mahi Sandwich was..."

Mile Marker Brian

"Staff were all super friendly and attentive. Our server Tanisha helped me decide on my dish and she was very informative. The atmosphere was..."

Sara Sechrest

"We ate here on Sunday 6th of August. The food was great I had the tuna and the key lime pie as dessert, the service was good and we saw a beautiful..."

Reset

There are 40 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Fish in Islamorada

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Dennis Fitzgerald

M Rasey

Ricardo Yslas

Kimberly Martin

Rhett Banana

Betsy B

Anna

W Gallup (kbsig106)

Shanelle Journey

Stephanie Thuemmel

Robert T

malcolm yunker

MAMA Bookasaurus

A

Foodie

Michelle S

Memphis235

Momster

Lisa Nunez

Mitchell Ackerman

Traveling Man

Laura Gilliam Decker

Sara

Ed From Pompano

Michelle

Feed Me

Drew

Devin

Debatable

Christine

Kristen Richards

Watty

Jessica

Michael McDaniel

RalphFLA

Susan Bell

Julia Danielle Wodesky

Julio Soares

Desy Gato

Doug Lewis

Laura C

Rebecca K

Ben Taber

Mal Rauch

Fidel Balan

John Sommers

Allyson Williams Leonard

Heather Bennett

Dylan Heitkamp

Dave Horner

Lance Hernandez

Wendy Thompson-Fox Grady

Pamela Lees Mather

Richard Glenn Madden

Epiphany Serendipity

Michael Alexander

Bennie Stevens

Tasheba Johnson

Kim Sanders

Sydney Dommer

John Houpt

Drew Ce

Barbara Badish Williamson

Tom Redmond

Erika Alejandra Garcia Diaz

Rufus

Julie

Suzanne