Great view, good food. Nice dinner good service. I had a special request for no salt and they were great to not add salt to anything I ate, very accommodating. The food was very good and the service was great. Not rushed but enough time to enjoy your meal and awesome key lime tart. The reviews are old, I was pleased with everything.
BLECK!. The worst food and service in a HIGHLY rated resort.
Service, taste and quality missing, but the worst is the management. The manager is one of those key swingers that you have seen parodied in movies and on TV restaurant makeover shows. Thinks he knows the business but it all smoke and mirrors. Kind of cocky and arrogant and false warmth and hospitality. We at dinner at the restaurant and then later sat next to him at the bar Pierre's across the street later. He spoke so terribly of the guests at the hotel and Cheeca management that we said we would never eat at any of the restaurants at Cheeca again, he didn't recognize us from dinner only an hour prior. We had a home in Islamorada and are down here 4-6 times a year but get mistaken as tourists all the time and have seen this treatment at a lot of the restaurants in this area....shame on you!
We had the Blue Swimmers crab dip as an appetizer. It was fantastic. I had the Swordfish for dinner along with a glass of ice wine. The two complimented each other very well. Our server, Claire, made our dinning experience that much more enjoyable. She offered some recommendations, was tentative, and very sweet. If you get the chance to have dinner here, ask for Claire to be your waitress and I’m also willing to guarantee that you will have a wonderful evening. 😊
My husband and I decided to try Atlantic's Edge for our Anniversary. Our waitress was very quiet but warmed up by the end. We had the Churrasco skirt steak, Garden salad with grilled chicken, Mocha Martini, cappuccino and an amazing dessert. Everything was wonderful and would definitely return. The view was perfect. If you're in a rush this isn't the restaurant for you because it does take a while for everything. The Millers...
Absolutely lovely!!
Great atmosphere. Fantastic views from outdoor dining. Food was fantastic! We tried many different things and all were good. The mango mojito is delicious! Service was a few notches short of a 5 star review some of the time. Didn’t seem overly organized because two waiters chose to argue over our table right next to our table haha the server we did end up with was great!! We would love to come back on our next trip and know we will enjoy everything again.
The restaurant is inside the iconic Cheeca Lodge & Spa. When you are escorted to the table there is a choice to sit ON THE BEACH under the palms overlooking the ocean - there are birds, boats, jet skis, people walking the pier, lounging on the beach and playing and relaxing. It’s a picture postcard spot. I paid $31 for a delicious Mahi Mahi Blackened and placed over a huge pile of fresh fresh field greens with sliced baby tomatoes. It was sooo good!
Such a Beautiful setting, and the food is delicious! For breakfast, The Brioche French Toast is a great pick, and for dinner, the mahi fish dish was excellent. All fresh ingredients in both the meals and drinks-Quick service and friendly staff. Truly a special place.
The atmosphere, the hotel, the service, all of this impeccable. I regret not choosing this hotel for my stay, the place I was staying at was disappointing in every way…but this place took away my hunger and sadness 10 out of 10. My server Paula deserves a raise!
We had some excellent fish and had a wonderful time. Service was impeccable. Great music and atmosphere. Beautiful views. Just a great night with friends.
We had an amazing experience at this restaurant. Wife and I went deep sea fishing in the morning. We caught some Mahi, Tuna and Triple Tail. Brought it to the restaurant. They said they will happily cook it for us. Boy did they do a job! Cooked blackened, fried and seared. Everything was delicious. Also, the sushi chef made us our own poke bowl and sushi with our tuna. It was amazing! Beautiful atmosphere and excellent service. Will definitely be back when in the keys!
Thanks to the amazing staff, chefs and manager!
We had very good dinner experience here. They have pretty decent menu, good service and astonishing view. Food was delicious, fresh and perfect portion sizing 👌🏽
We were enjoying Live music and cozy outdoor fire spots afterwards.
Perfect place for weekend getaway!
Atlantics Edge is a fantastic dining experience! We had a party of 10 to celebrate a birthday and Rolando took care of us. The service was excellent; the atmosphere was beautiful, and the food was delicious! Highly recommend the Brussel sprouts starter and key lime pie for dessert! Sooooo good!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Islamorada
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes