Just stoped by today, picked up an ex-large sausage and mushroom pizza. The wife and I have been eating Jacks Pizza for a very long time. We just love Jacks and have been loyal customers since the early 1970’s. All their pizzas come with oregano so if you don’t go for that tell them to leave it off. There is no indoor seating, carry out only.
Nothing quite like a plain sausage Jack’s pizza! I don’t know what they do, but this one tastes like no other. Some kind of addictive chemical that makes you crave it fortnightly.😂😂😂
I'm a loyal customer of this place, my favorite toppings are pepperoni and ground sausage. THE best, the picture below is a 10". Good for pizza for single people lol. The pizzas go up to 18" which is considered extra large. In my opinion it is so much better than Papa Johns!
Austin is incredible. My pizza was made to perfection. The Castleton location is by far the best. Thanks Austin for an amazing experience.
Best pizza in town if you love toppings! Just make sure you give them plenty of time to make it. 45 min is a typical wait time but soooo worth it.
After moving away from my hometown of Indianapolis a few years back, I have had such a craving for a Jack's Big Jack pizza all the way from Wilmington, NC! Aside from Malnatti's Pizza in Chicago, I miss you all the most. Your Big Jack X-Large pie is my #1 pizza all-time. If you'll ever do this Yelper a favor and be willing to ship a Big Jack to the Port City in North Carolina, to satisfy this native Hoosier's craving...let me know. 5 Stars.
Friendly staff great prices and one of the best pizzas in the city got to have it every time I come from Florida
If Jack’s made their own crust, they’d be unstoppable! By far my favorite pizza in town!!
When they're on point, the pizza is excellent! Here recently, it's been better for sure. Keep it up!
I'm in my mid 50's and have been have Jack's Pizza as often as I can since I was a kid. It's harder these days as our Jack's in Greenfield closed several years back as have some of the east Indy options, and some of the others are hit and miss on on quality and service. Today I went to this Castleton location for the first time and was very happy. The food was just as I remembered it and the staff was excellent, friendly and fast. Breadsticks were good with plenty of cheese dip. Hot and fresh pizza with abundant toppings and just the right amount of cheese...pizza as it's meant to be.
Thanks Much for giving me another option for the wife and my Jack's Pizza cravings!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes