Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge provided an exceptional experience in every aspect. The atmosphere exuded charm with its rustic, dimly lit, and romantic ambiance. The addition of low-volume live music enhanced the overall experience. The service was outstanding, and the food was simply exquisite. The Beef Wellington, along with all the sides, was delightful. I'm already looking forward to my next visit. Highly recommend for a special evening out.
The entree food was delicious. There was a long wait for the food but the server did tell us the kitchen was behind. The atmosphere was very dim. A bit too dim for my preference. When we were there they had a singer and she was hitting octaves that were quite piercing and even distracting at times. We were seated in the corner upstairs and when we put our elbows on the table the top tipped the whole table. They did not have beer on draft and the desert was mediocre. I didn’t love the bread pudding.
Just went here with my fiancé for my birthday today. The atmosphere was a classic 40s vibe, and the food was AMAZING.
Our waiter, Elijah, was outstanding and very helpful with any questions we had about the menu (someone please give this man a raise!)
We will definitely be coming back here in the future!
Went for a birthday dinner. Drinks were not great. Hard to get down, bothe drinks. No one asked if we liked them or checked on us or offered anything else. Dinner was amazing. The chocolate cake was AWFUL. Very dry, icing was hard and sent it back. Again, no one asked if we like it or how it was. They just took it back and then charged us for it. Overall, it is nice but not worth the 200.00+ dollars.
Went to dinner with a culinary friend, as we both enjoy trying new places around the city and when traveling.
Waitress was sweet & answered our questions knowledgeably and honestly. She gave us enough info for us to make the best decisions for us without trying to just increase the bill.
The food was amazing and the drinks were well made, too!
Beautiful date night out. The bartender and staff waited on us like we were long time guests. This was 1st time here we walked in straight to the bar no reservations. Cocktails and ambiance made me feel like I was in an OG movie. Beautiful restaurant. We ordered chop salad crab cakes & 20oz delmonico- + the drinks are served with rock candy we had a few 8 out of 10! The rest of the menu looked amazing we will be back 100%. Ty Your Friend JC
This is a cool place with very good food. Some of the dishes including desserts on the menu are outstanding. Other options are somewhat less perfect, but everything is generally above average. My only complaint like other reviewers is the prices are very high and overall there's a feeling that you could have done better for the amount of money spent here.
Extravagant with luxurious flavors.
We went for our anniversary and were not disappointed. To clear the air.... yes, it's expensive. Should you eat like this all the time? No. However, when you want to treat yourself or someone, this is an excellent choice.
The drinks are delicious, the food more so.
I got the Delmonico steak. A hearty portion of beef that was cooked to perfect temp and abundant with juice. The show stoper was the sticky toffee pudding. Best I've had by far. In conclusion, it's expensive, but you are paying for an outstanding meal full of flavor and hearty portions. 15/10
Highly recommend giving Geraldine’s a try. I had heard great things about their Beef Wellington and I was not disappointed. Simply one of the best meals I’ve ever had. Our server Kara made great recommendations for wine pairing and appetizers, she was awesome. Definitely will be back again soon!
We enjoyed celebrating our anniversary at Geraldine’s. Great food, service and atmosphere including live music.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes