The Melting Pot

The Melting Pot, Indianapolis 5650 E 86th St - Indianapolis

Now open
American
• Sit down

83/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite The Melting Pot's dish?

Ratings and reviews

83
/100
Based on 6814 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of The Melting Pot suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of The Melting Pot

TA

Trip
Last update on 01/01/2024
4,0
183 Reviews
Opentable
Opentable
Last update on 04/12/2023
4,0
3318 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 29/12/2023
4,5
2108 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 04/12/2023
4,0
989 Reviews

YP

Yellow pages
Last update on 05/06/2020
4,5
16 Reviews

R

Restaurantji
Last update on 26/12/2020
3,8
140 Reviews

Menu The Melting Pot

  • First Course
    • Wisconsin Cheddar
    • Quattro Formaggio
    • Classic Alpine*
    • Spinach Artichoke
    • Charcuterie Board
  • Second Course
    • Melting Pot House*
    • Caesar
    • California
  • Third Course: Big Night Out
    • Premium Filet Mignon^
    • Teriyaki-Marinated Sirloin^
    • Herb-Crusted Chicken Breast^
    • Shrimp^
    • Atlantic Salmon^
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

Facebook
Angie Bilka
+5
Unique, romantic, and delish! Every bite is amazing! Our server was very attentive and great! We know exactly what we want when we come here. The timing on the start to transition in meals was perfectly timed. She received 2 more tables with newbies and started getting busy but remained on schedule. I say newbies because people have to understand that if you are new and come here, the server has to take a good 5-10 minutes just to explain the menu and safety on the food. That can sometimes delay the timing on arrival to table which we take into consideration. We come here on bdays, date nights, Valentines, and anniversaries and my hubby and I love it! We come here expecting a 2 hr dining experience which is very romantic. We have been together for 15 yrs and we feel like we are back in the days dating again when we first met everytime we come here . He opens my door and makes me feel special when we come here. Now my hubby is adding it to his bday list which is awesome for me! I see other reviews on people not happy waiting but when you come here, it is not your normal dine and go, it needs to be expected to set some "extra time" aside. We always order a bottle of wine along with the the 4 course meal and select the Borgon...style. My husband selected the 4 hands Cab and it was a great choice! We can sit back and enjoy our glasses until our app arrives. We both love the spin & art but this time we tried green goddess cheese and wow so delish also! We both love the California salad with candied nuts (We tried the others and this is the best). My husband orders land and sea (filet, shrimp, chix) while I always order 3stks. We can then share which I love. Towards the end the amazing chocolate that we can never finish because we are so full and satisfied! We are willing to pay more to dine here because the experience. I am a part of fondue club and get the emails for the free choc strawberries for my bday and they are ginormous and amazing! I was able to take them home at end of meal. I can't say enough about how happy we are when we come here!! TY!
Facebook
Staci Rector
+5
Stephanie was a wonderful server. Food was spectacular with a high five to the new addons. Only one issue was that the people next to us broght their 5 year old. Do not bring your child to a place that takes 2 hrs to eat. You annoid us!
5
Cassie Hull
+5
Went here with friends on a Wednesday. Our server, Bri I think, was great. She was awesome. The salads and entree and dessert were great. We got the Wisconsin cheese appetizer, and we didn't care for it that much. Maybe if it was cooking longer? But they dump in all the ingredients in front of you and you just wait for the cheese to melt...I dunno it just didn't taste right to us. But really everything ends was great. The variety of items to dip for the dessert was excellent.
5
Madison Peppler
+5
Anthony was AMAZING ! This was our first time here and we have zero idea what we were doing, he explained ALL of our options and everything we could do or combine things with! Every piece of this 4 course meal was AMAZING! The different flavors and styles of thing was great!! Over all our experience was fantastic! The waiter was so understanding and quick to be of assistance! 10/10 highly recommended!!!
5
Danielle Campton
+5
Came here for a much needed girls night. Our server was Nikki and she was very attentive and sweet. The food was amazing (did the steak plate) and the dipping sauces were phenomenal (I'm dreaming about the curry yogurt). Highly recommend!!!
4
Mande Watkins
+4
The server was outstanding. Made us very comfortable. I ordered roses for the table prior to arriving, and there was one missing, but the manager personally brought it over halfway through dinner without us mentioning it, making the number correct. We were celebrating a birthday, and there was a personalized card on the table, which was sweet. There was a hair in our dessert that clearly wasn't ours, but our server quickly set this right. We were also charged for an alcoholic drink that we didn't order that was $14, so I'm lucky I checked the bil prior to paying. When bringing it up to the server, we were told there was a drunk employee the establishment was dealing with, and they would remove the charge, which they did. That felt a little unnecessary. Overall, it was probably my least favorite Melting Pot experience, but I'll still be back seeing that this is my favorite restaurant. Update: emailed regional manager as suggested about one week ago and never received response. Yes, I checked my spam folder.
5
Richard K
+5
The Melting Pot is a restaurant like no other and it is one that you cannot go to if you are in a rush. My wife and I have been here multiple times and it always takes longer than planned. That is because we enjoy the atmosphere so much and being able to take your time and cook your own food as you are ready! The seasonings and sauces provided are always delicious and being able to cook your own food allows you to cook things as rare or as well as you prefer. The Knob Creek Old Fashioned's are on point as well and highly recommended! We were also able to make our entire meal Gluten Free which is a new development for my wife. We will return again!
5
Amanda
+5
My soon to be daughter in law surprised my son with a date, including close friends & myself. We had a secluded room for our party that included roses & rose petals across the table. The food & service were amazing! Plan on being there a while. The experience is well worth it!
5
Michelle
+5
Evelyn was our AMAZING server and she was wonderful. She really knew her stuff and was very courteous. Our entire meal was perfect! We will definitely be back to the Castleton location.
4
Michael Pettrone
+4
I made reservations for anniversary dinner for my family. Service was great. Food was delicious.
5
Chris Bennett
+5
We went for my wife's birthday. It was amazing. We did the private dining option. Highly recommend it, we had a great evening. The staff was awesome!
5
Brittany Moore
+5
We had a great time! They set our table up with flowers and candle lit, super romantic and a fun experience! We will definitely be back, our server was amazing, although I cannot remember her name 😞

Description

Timetable

Now Open
Monday:
04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday:
04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday:
04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Thursday:
04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Friday:
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday:
12:00 PM - 09:00 PM

Book a table with

Opentable
Opentable

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Facebook
Facebook

YP

Yellow pages

R

Restaurantji

Info

Compare the best restaurants near The Melting Pot

The Chef reccomend

QR Code Menu

QR Code

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 83 based on 6814 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 317-841-3601

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1