The best Fish in Hampton Bays | Sluurpy updated in June

"With the fireplace and wood paneling this resturant's dining room is amazingly beautiful. Our fish specials were delicious as were the vegetables. We..."

Ashley Schirripa

Dae M

"Great view, friendly foods, and fantastic staff. It’s a very popular restaurant and we waited almost an hour outside, highly recommend go there..."

Tyler Koo

"Saturday night was overcrowded, it was a cold rainy night, and we had to wait more than 1/2 hrs for a table. Maybe we had a party of 18 people. The..."

Poran C

"Food was good and the view is pretty nice. If you are waiting for your table, you should grab a drink by the bar and enjoy the..."

John Ng

"In the heart of beautiful Hamptons on the water. A walking path that wraps around the property along the calm open waters where there is seating that..."

Janine

"My wife and I were struggling to figure out where to eat for our first anniversary, thankfully the server Taylor C. recommended Cowfish to us. We had..."

Scott

"Beautiful venue that fit our entire party upstairs! I got the seared ahi tuna and the blueberry mint lemonade and it was pretty..."

Gloriane Tong

"Exquisite food. Lovely ambiance. Amazing view. Friendly staff. Open year round. What else would you ask for? Excellent experience overall. We will..."

Rossy Ureña

"Happened to find this gem on our way to Montauk for the weekend. Beautiful restaurant, the food was incredible. Service was great, Ryan was our..."

Nichole Danaher

"This was recommended to us by multiple people and we initially thought it would be too fancy to bring young kids to but it turned out to be a perfect..."

Jeff H

Oakland's Restaurant & Marina

87/100 (1294 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Wheelchair Accessible

"Food was delicious ! Service was good ! Great to sit outside with the great view of the ocean. The flash fried calamari was very fresh and tender...."

Tracy Tracy

"I absolutely love love love this place!! Oakland's is an amazing restaurant with delicious seafood and beautiful views. It is not often that water..."

Emily Schiller

"If it’s two or three of you, skip the dining room and sit at the bar. Great service, great drinks. Justin’s a great bartender. If he’s working,..."

Anthony Bradley

"One of the best meals at a restaurant that I have ever had. I can't find one negative to speak of. The waiter was diligent. The scenery was lovely...."

Aaron Moore

"Excellent dining experience! The excellent quality of food and service has always been consistent . The sunsets are..."

Pathways For Wellness - Debbie

"Excellent location with spectacular views and sunsets. My favorite dish is the Vegetable & Chicken Penne which has a large portion that I usually..."

Richard Heiles

"This was one of our best seafood restaurant experiences. We had grilled swordfish with grilled flatbread. Scenic view, well-designed facility, with..."

Sean ainechi

"My second time here and it was fantastic. Spent some time at the bar while waiting to be seated, and the drinks were delicious. Note this place does..."

Asli Pisano

"Love this restaurant. The food is well prepared, presented, and scrumptious. Bartenders were very attentive for the entire time we were there and it..."

Scott Rispaud

"Back at Oakland's They don't take reservations so make sure you come early. If you come early you can get drinks from the bar and some appetizers..."

Carol Cooper

"This place hits all the high notes. Friendly service, great food and a fabulous view facing the water. I’m not a big seafood fan, but the halibut..."

Susan

"I was wonderful. The location is a bit remote that makes it even more charming. We vee been there on a Saturday afternoon and enjoyed the bar eith..."

MG Gro

"Front desk issues, They made us wait almost an hour when we walked in. Some strange seating arrangements. We walked in at 4:10 They told us a 40..."

MarieAnn Guastella

"Came here with elderly parents. Stephanie was outstanding hostess and was patient and seated us in picture perfect table. We remember her from last..."

Margaret Feerick

"Great place. Fun.. live music in the bar. Views are amazing. Great service. No reservations, wait to be seated. Price in the Middle..."

pablo rodriguez

Canal Cafe

87/100 (1294 ratings)

Calamari and Chips and Guacamole

Guacamole and Chips

Lobster Roll

Montauk Brewing Company Summer Ale

Fried Chicken Sandwich

Rum Punch and Margarita

Shrimp

Poached Shrimp Cocktail

Half Chicken Sandwich with Cole Slaw and Fries

"This is a local establishment offering some local fare, like clams, and orher seafood. The place is small and can get busy, but have a drink and..."

Regina Fugat

"Always a fun & delicious meal at Canal Cafe! Lovely setting overlooking the water, laid back atmosphere, with terrific food and great service. Fish &..."

Alyra Hoffman

"Cute, very busy, place with nice view of the marina. Service was good. Food was average, cocktails were good. May try again in the off season when..."

Cynthia Kirk

"Very nice atmosphere on the marina. We headed here for lunch and ordered the large lobster roll, ceasar salad and two cocktails. Our bill was $169.00..."

Rachel Romma

"The lentil soup did not seem homemade even though the description definitely made it sound as if it was. There was nothing special about it and the..."

November Girl

"Had a wonderful lunch at Canal Cafe today. We enjoyed the escarole & bean soup, Lobster salad, salmon (cooked to perfection) and shrimp tacos. The..."

Theresa Lovallo

"Went with my hb for brunch and food was really good. Big portions. Staff is super friendly. AMAZING hospitality. Unfortunately we weren’t able to..."

M P

"Staycation worthy!!!! Enjoy the water-view while sipping their fresh brewed iced tea. Food is..."

Pathways For Wellness - Debbie

"Stopped here for lunch on a business trip based on reviews. Nice spot on the water with both indoor and outdoor seating. Service was friendly and..."

Adriane Jimenez

"Great food and service overlooking the water. Outside seating is fun when weather is good. Inside seating is nice and cosy around the bar area. May..."

Gerald

Out Of The Blue Seafood

Free off-street parking

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"As we were parking, we noticed how quickly people were walking up to the restaurant. What we didn’t realize was that seating was very limited. 3..."

S Johnson

"A humble looking place that surprised us with how great the food was. The fish and chips were delicious with a perfectly thin and crispy batter and..."

Andrew Fisher

"Great seafood — we got steamers, oysters, and calamari, but if we’re in the area we’ll come back to try more..."

Louie

"This was my 3rd time dining here . I had the halibut dinner with steamed potato and grilled zucchini .Absolutly delicious! I had French fries added..."

Kim

"If your looking for great fresh seafood then this is the place. We came here as a group and there was plenty of seating available. Great spot if your..."

Mehmed Ak

"Priced slightly higher than you'd expect for a seafood market / restaurant, this place is laid back and casual, with a fresh seafood flair. My spouse..."

Peter Falco

"This place is absolutely amazing everyone was very kind that worked there. A few tables and chairs inside also you can pick up raw sea food to go...."

Nathan Campbell

"This little spot offers fresh seafood to either take home to prepare yourself or enjoy take out or dine-in options. I always enjoy the Fried Oysters..."

Jacqueline Vita

"I’ve driven by this place many times and hadn’t stopped. Until recently I did, and what a lovely surprise. The food was good, the staff was..."

Stephanie Nascimento

"Easily the best fresh and smoked fish and shellfish restaurant we've come across on LI. Everything you want from the sea, steamed to perfection and..."

Sharif Hassan

"We’ve always enjoyed Joe’s Out of the Blue in Hampton Bays as a local seafood spot both for fresh seafood amen! And also for fresh fish,..."

David Yoo

"If you really want good seafood and are willing to overlook some incidentals as plastic silverware and no table cloths this is the place to go. The..."

Michael Miller

"Loved the steamers and crabcakes. Great little place for a quick bite. Partial table service but friendly and helpful..."

Courtney Rauch

Buckley's Inn Between

82/100 (1141 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"I always prefer local restaurants to fancy chains. Even though it is not a fancy restaurant, and the food style is different, you always feel like..."

Sean ainechi

"Food here was really good. I had the sheppards's pie which had more meat than I was expecting. Could have done with more veggies to balance it. Same..."

Joe M.

"It's a cool place for a beer or a simple American meal. Old fashioned but great with a very good atmosphere. The plates are really (really!)..."

Mademoiselle Flora

"My parents like this place and come all the time. Good list of burgers, sandwhiches and pub style food. Decent amount of specials too. Seems like a..."

John “JV”

"We decided to go to Buckley's last minute for dinner. We were a party of 7 and they got us in right away. The service was amazing and the food was..."

Gina-Marie DeGiorgio

"Great! Pub food and then some! You can get healthy alternatives, soups, salads, grill chicken. Everything we ordered was delicious and fresh. Nice..."

Robert Flannigan

"Great local Irish bar with solid good food, spot on Irish dishes and awesome service. Whether you eat in or take out, the portions fit the prices and..."

J

"Wings were over cooked and dry, but the flavor was ok. Bartender was excellent . He was also the waiter, probably because they were understaffed. ..."

russ1818 W

"An American inn like British and Irish inns with a pub/tavern in the front and a dining area in the back. Irish decor. Typical gastropub menu. Great..."

Len Dest

"This is always our go to place when in Hampton Bays. I've never had anything but a great experience and great food..."

Bruno K

"Marinated steak tidbits are excellent. Then again there’s always a Ruben and some soup never disappointed, good fresh food and cold..."

DB

"It has a vibrant atmosphere, good food with large portions, and great..."

Brandon Vincent

"Located in the heart of Hampton Bays, this pub is hopping. We happened upon a festive celebration including live music and an Irish Bagpiper playing...."

Jacqueline Vita

"I got a really good ice tea cocktail, think it was called the 18 hole or something haha very sorry i dont remember the name but thats close enough..."

BIZ

"Solid and consistently amazing food. A regular for me and my visiting..."

Lee Harrison

"Excellent restaurant. The food was great, and the staff was super..."

Lou Esposito

"Food was amazing had the chicken pot pie omg loved it. Place is nice definitely coming back for..."

Dominick Ricciardi

78 Foster Restaurant & Bar

Wheelchair Accessible

"I love this place. Ladies behind the bar are great people mix amazing drinks. The food is amazing even something as simple as a burger is top notch...."

Jenn Tinnin

"I had the Chicken Francaise and it was probably the best I have ever had.. Congrats Helene on a great place.. Best of luck..."

Freddie Bonaire

"First evening at Fosters & didn’t disappoint! Splendid Tuna, Salmon & “78”..."

Jerry W Harrelson

"We enjoyed our first visit to 78 Foster thoroughly. The cocktails were complimented by excellent appetizers (baked clams were incredible), the..."

Scott Kassner

"Always a Pleasure! Great seafood staff live music and happy hour! What's not to love? See ya..."

Rob Salmaggi

"Never had a bad meal there. All the people I’ve introduced it to, have felt the same. I’ve turned quite a few friends into regulars. I just wish..."

Mary Ferraro

"Food was absolutely wonderful. Had band playing out on the deck/patio . Service was excellent. Prices good. Will be going..."

Elaine Oliver

"We have rave reviews. We are there every Friday night and we are going back tonight because they have BLOWFISH on the..."

Allyson Barone Scerri

"Excellent atmosphere ,excellent food ,the Margaritas and the Rum punch were unbelievable . Special Thanks to Jackie and her Mom for making us feel at..."

Nigel Braithwaite Sr.

"The best food and service restaurant you will ever go to. Well..."

Jacqueline Helen

"The bartender Shawn was the best. Such a hustling guy he was able to handle the entire bar on his own and it was full. I will go back when I'm in..."

Scott Rispaud

"I came up from Florida for a visit, and my boyfriend took me here for a fine dining experience. Our server Matthew was attentive and service was on..."

Joanne Jarvis

"Really good soup options. And awesome salad. The lobster roll was pretty good, and with excellent..."

Garrison Pease

"Hidden gem of hamptonbays . Best menu in town when it comes to varities . Service is superb . Delicious..."

surimaribo24

"My wife and I absolutely love this place. The food is always excellent, personal favorite is the tuna appetizer. The staff is always friendly and the..."

Tom Pekar

"Food was fresh and very well done. I had the tuna and it was great. Restaurant is attached to a fish market so seafood is a big plus here. Service..."

Thomas Fusco

"I can’t say enough incredible things about this restaurant! The owner is so incredibly sweet and friendly and always makes sure her guests are..."

Vincenzo Masone

"My wife and I had dinner here last night. Everything was great, we were seated right away, the service was excellent, the atmosphere terrific, except..."

James Carine

"Came for happy hour after reading Dan's Papers' review. Friendly place ask for Mary, Ashley or Helen. It reminds me of grammer school where the..."

Michael Tillman

"We had a very tasty seafood dinner tonight. Due to floodings, it must have been a real stressful weekend for the Restaurant staff, but we still had..."

Lukas Endres

Matsulin Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"So glad we found this restaurant. My husband and I wanted Peeking Duck so I searched online for local restaurants that serve it. Matsulin came up in..."

Donna Racioppi

"We had dinner here last night for the first time. We were greeted so warmly when we arrived and seated right away. The staff is so attentive and..."

Sunita Sukhu

"One of my favorite places in the Hamptons for fresh, delicious Asian food. Great variety, generous portions, and reasonable prices make this place a..."

Robert Peirce

"Great place. Friendly, spacious, clean and great food. The fried calamari might be the best I've had... Well seasoned and served over a finely diced..."

Sandra A

"Matsulin is an awesome Asian-fusion style restaurant, offering excellent options for sushi, as well as Chinese & Thai-style dishes. A lot of..."

Amanda Mercurio

"Matsulin has the best Asian food out East on Long Island. The dishes are incredible and the restaurant gives you options on how the dish is prepared..."

JohnPierre Herrera

"It was very delicious! The service was very..."

calimali

"Excellent food- the restaurant was quite empty all but 3-4 tables. But still the food took time to arrive- almost always a good sign- and so it was..."

Tim Allen

"I had an extreme foodgasm! The food is great here and the atmosphere is very homely. Staff is friendly. I keep asking my friend when we'll go here..."

Shanice Davis

"Best Pad Thai I have ever had. I would recommend..."

Ceyhun Gungor

Sundays On The Bay

78/100 (1077 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Off season here can be very chill. It's generally pretty easy to get a table once the tourists have gone home and the food is definitely worth the..."

Robyn Baranowski

"The food and drinks in this place was amazing Great kids menu and amazing atmosphere Really enjoyed my time at this establishment Very clean and..."

Daniel Alarcon

"I had the lobster salad while my friend had the lobster roll. Hers was a little bland while mine was quite tasty with the mangoes and cashews on it...."

Elizabeth Stelling

"First time eating here, pleasant atmosphere, friendly staff and food was good. My wife and I had burgers that were cooked perfectly. Stuffed clams..."

Darren Buttacavoli

"This was our second time coming here, and it was even better than the last time. The appetizers were AMAZING! We ordered their crab dip, steak bites..."

saroasha engineer

"Wonderful place! The location was perfect (weather helped out), service was prompt and friendly, and the food was amazing. All around..."

Angela Brown

"Amazing lunch experience! Our first time to the Hamptons; everything was delicious and service was top notch. Food delivered fast and flavorful...."

Jennifer Stewart

"-Once again we drove the 40 minutes to have Amazing Sunday's Burger!!! Yes, they have amazing seafood with amazing presentations. A beautiful day, we..."

Joyce S

"Tasty cocktails, appetizers, entrees and dessert! There was also some live music! We had a great table overlooking the dock which allowed us a..."

Nicole Jala

"At around $50/head+ for two courses and drinks this is a pricey eat but mostly hits the target. You basically have only two choices if you want to..."

msutube11

Inn Spot On The Bay

Accepts American Express

Free off-street parking

"If you are looking for a quiet, comfy, and homey spot for a getaway, The Inn Spot is the place to be. The Villas are clean and feels just like home...."

Kristina Monzon

"A truly memorable dining experience. Outdoor, with a bay view, unhurried, the staff attentive without being obsequious. Then the food...Duck such as..."

Patrick Hogan

"Went here for dinner on a whim with my husband. The food was impeccable, the view was just as incredible & the staff was very accommodating &..."

ChristiAnne Reyes

"My Thanksgiving dinner was delicious! From appetizer to dessert, I had a plant-based wonderful meal. If you are looking for healthy, plant-based..."

Peggy Haug Kraus

"This place is a hidden gem! (Hospitality is..."

Linda Shay

"Water, water everywhere. Sitting pretty right on the bay, the vista is impressive. Outdoor seating on the porch gives you optimal views and gentle..."

Jacqueline Vita

"Homey and very personable, the food was delicious and the chef comes out to see how everything is. The staff is very friendly. I feel like we have..."

Danielle R. Salentino-Huebner

"Great views, perfect location, TONS of vegan options, lots of fun activities near by, and Amazing..."

Alecia Moore

"One of my favorite places on the East End. Great food, friendly service and breath taking views. I recommend The Inn Spot on the Bay to anyone..."

Morgan Dillon

"We ate dinner here on a whim one evening on a drive from NY, highly recommended! Great view, great..."

Pamela McLaren

"My fiancee took me last night for valentine's day for the 7 course dinner. Chocolate dinner with wine pairing. Had an absolute wonderful time the..."

Chrissy Capobianco

"Located directly on the waterfront the Inn Spot was perfect for our one night stay. Very cozy space with expected amenities for a bungalow feel room...."

Jeffrey Pammer

"Cute spot. Rooms are very small but nicely acquainted. Bathroom had a cool skylight and gorgeous rain head faucet. Love being able to walk right to..."

Aja Aktay

"I came to the Inn Spot on the Bay with a friend for their vegan three course dinner a few weeks ago. The service was great and the atmosphere was..."

adrienne drenckhahn

"A real delight at the waters edges just across from the US Coast Guard Station, on Lighthouse Road. The Inn Spot on the Bay is a quaint inn not to be..."

Jacqueline Vita

"We had a great experience staying here. Besides the location being beautiful, the staff was extremely accommodating and helpful with anything we..."

Nick Jagodzinski

"Beautiful spot on the water. This is one of the few places that says they have waterfront views that actually does have waterfront views. The owner..."

Sarah Doar

"Went to the Inn Spot by the Bay with my boyfriend for a weekend stay in the Hamptons. Got set up in one of their cute and romantic villas. First..."

Morgan Dillon

"The food was very delicious!! The view was absolutely beautiful too! Also, the staff are very friendly. It was very windy that night and a staff..."

Kayla Stein

"Wonderful restaurant. Great ambiance, really personable staff and terrific food. To top it off many gluten free options which were delicious!..."

Earl Dozier

"There is no way to put into words how much we adore this place and ALL of their staff. We vacation here multiple times a year and got engaged here..."

Ryan Cook

"Amazing, hotel was bought under new management. Everything is brand new. Cottages are updated, clean and the scenery is just..."

Celia Allen

"Having breakfast and enjoying the panoramic views of the Bay was so relaxing! The professional, courteous served us delicious food. We will..."

De

Tully's

"Really nice staff and you get double the amount of food compared to other places. Had the lobster rolls and they came with waffle fries so what’s..."

Peter Dahdouh

"This fish market and restaurant makes the best lobsters on the eastern south fork. 3 & 4 pound were steamed and delicious! We did pick up and brought..."

Carolyn Newson

"Amazing little stop on the way down to the beach! We went twice, first for soft shell crab sandwich - it was great. Second time we got the hot..."

Tory Buckley

"Stopped in the market to grab some fresh fish on the way home from the beach and spontaneously also got a Qt of Seafood Gumbo. Let me tell you my..."

Kerrie Jordan

"Thank you Tully’s for providing the community with fresh fish daily! Especially during these difficult times ! The market is immaculate and the..."

Anna Marie

"First of all, when reviewing roadside seafood locations "decor" could be confusing, but this place was great-picnic tables and all. We went there..."

Brian M

"We love our Clam Chowder & sweet potato fries. Each visit to the Beach involves a trip over to Tully's but its so worth it. Can't wait till the..."

Tirzah Hailey

"Had the Crab Cake sliders and a side of fries, shared it with my wife delicious and only $18 highly recommend. Also has a garden to eat in overall..."

Ricky Gordon

"Best clam chowder I’ve had in a long time. A must have. The shrimp, flounder and conch fritters were good..."

Terry M

"Nice outdoors place to have a quick bite.It Fresh seafood. Please either stop serving that lobster roll of yours or change the preparation..."

Reset

There are 13 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Fish in Hampton Bays

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Michael Tillman

Susan Messina

Lorraine Mareno

Brittany McElhiney

Hatchman

Frank Morgano

Scott Rispaud

Andrea Conyngham

Miamaher lofland

Kadir Ozbek

Natalia Ilina

Mike Styckle

DIANA P.

Kamille Jenkins

Harrison Kang

Emily DelGiorno

Kelly M. Mueller

Melissa L

Arlenee Lopez-Ferguson

Frances Molinari

Michael Mosolino

Pete Pedone

Kristy Lyn

Sabastian Wallace

M P

S Clark

Nicole Pellegrino

Anthony Fontana

Daniel Antoniazzi

Chuck Watson

Richard Heiles

Sree Sreenivasan

Scott Orban

Alison Lee

Ellen Botwin

Andrea Asencio

Michelle Rebhun

Alona Kornberg

Pahola Tene

Ricky Reda

Patricia McEnery

Susan Gill Orange

Suzan Gulay

Alison Johnson

Michele DeRosso

Kaitlin Humphrey

Leslie Boulin

Bridgette Pezzino

Enid Viana Obrien

Liz Beckman-Holdsworth

Brian Wilkinson

Ashley Schirripa

Dae M

Tyler Koo

Poran C

John Ng

Janine

Scott

Gloriane Tong

Rossy Ureña

Nichole Danaher

Jeff H

Tracy Tracy

Emily Schiller

Anthony Bradley

Aaron Moore

Pathways For Wellness - Debbie

Richard Heiles