N.y. Plate

5808 Melton Rd, 46403-2905 - Gary
★★★★★ ★★★★★
85/100
439 recommendations

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

85/100
Sluurpy Score
439 total reviews
Google
4.2/5
342 reviews
Facebook
4.3/5
11 reviews
Grubhub
3.5/5
10 reviews
Menupix
5.0/5
1 reviews
Restaurantji
4.3/5
75 reviews

Contact Information

📍 Address: 5808 Melton Rd, Gary

Google Reviews (8)

A

Ariale Schell

a month ago
★★★★★ 5/5
We absolutely loved finding this place. It's not shiny or flashy, it was kind of hidden but the taste of the food, the size of the portions, and the price per meal made it an amazing experience. If you go you have to make sure to try the Cheetos Menu and those Mozzarella sticks with the cheese dip makes my mouth water just thinking about it. The portions were huge and well worth the money spent on it. If we drive thru there again, we will definitely be stopping.
Read more
Google
S

sparkle percy

a year ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
I love this place it was a good place to pick preseason food my whole family loved it I love to get their bowls so far I've had the New York Plate the Brooklyn plate the Flamin Hot cheese sticks or daughter had the fries and my other family members had things as well so so far everything that I have tasted has been good. I recommend this place to a lot of people if you want to try something different in this is one of the latest to try something different and get full and still have food left over.
Read more
Google
L

Louie Vasquez

3 months ago
★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
They deserve no stars this restaurant is horrible. They’re not even putting steak in their meals that are supposed to have steak they’re advertised steak but instead it’s substituted with Gyro meat. I ate some of the food started feeling sick because the hummus was no good and was throwing up most of the night
Read more
Google
C

Carie Allendorf

2 months ago
★★★☆☆ 3/5
Mmmmm I'm not sure what to say. Service seemed so so. Small building you can dine in but I prefer more space. Lot of customers hanging out waiting for food. Huge portions. I'm going to give another try.
Google
Y

Yxvng Dapri

a month ago
★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
Been here about 3 times for the most part the food is ok. But today while eating the nachos i felt something pierce my tongue so i spit the food out come to find out it was a staple in my nachos probably will never eat here again.
Google
C

Chelsea

2 years ago
★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
First off, I was already HIGHLY skeptical of this place. I just moved up here from FL and haven’t seen a single good restaurant to eat at. I was really excited to find this place close to my house. I read reviews beforehand of course which made me hesitant to order from here, but I bit the bullet and did....and I regret it. I ordered the hummus, something I make at my house from scratch ALL the time. It looked good and I was about to dive in when I noticed this thick, black hair follicle in there. I automatically lost my appetite and threw it out. I also ordered the Gyro plate with extra “special sauce” on the side. I was HUGELY disappointed when I discovered this “special sauce”, which is typically tzatziki sauce Greek places use (also another thing I know how to make at home from scratch) was simply....RANCH DRESSING?!?! Someone stated this in a previous review but I didn’t want to believe them (I take it back!). It was soaked allll over the pita, which was the only good tasting thing. The meat was alright but you could taste the grease...not enough lettuce and the rice? Well, the rice creeped me out and didn’t taste that good either because it’s Orange...never seen Mediterranean rice look like that. All in all, I should have listened to the reviews and stayed away from this place. I DEFINITELY, will not be eating here again due to everything being wrong, wrong, WRONG! I will stick with the Greek place in the Southlake Mall in Merrillville for my Greek fix.
Read more
Google
D

Dee Mohaugany

2 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Fast service. Gyro plate. Special sauce tastes like some type of ranch formula. Misspelled words on the menu (over 9 words).
Google
B

Barbara Hooker

2 months ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Food was good but the girl at the counter spoke so softly i could barely hear her
Google

📊 Compare with Other Restaurants

Restaurant Score Google Tripadvisor Reviews
The Beauty Trap 70% - - 0
KFC 70% 2.7/5 - 244
Sharks 87% 4.2/5 - 424
Broadway BBQ 72% 4.1/5 3.5/5 586
18th Street Brewery 80% 4.5/5 4.5/5 287
McDonald's 70% 3.4/5 - 4,338

Other Restaurants in Gary

Smokin' Hot Barbecue, Llc

⭐ 100.0 (9 reviews)

Fabys Tacos

⭐ 100.0 (4 reviews)

Bugsys Tavern

⭐ 100.0 (1 reviews)

Ono's Pizza

⭐ 98.7 (16 reviews)

The Brasserie

⭐ 95.0 (82 reviews)

Captain's House

⭐ 94.2 (188 reviews)

Help us improve

← Back to all restaurants in Gary

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that N.y. Plate has permanently closed?