Fayetteville Pie Company

Fayetteville Pie Company is my go to place for comfort food. Le Pie Mac is TO DIE FOR. The pies are on point and I love that they used locally resourced ingredients. Most people complain about the price without realizing these pies are made with the best ingredients and care! They’re made fresh every day! And to top it off the customer service is always great. FPC will always have my business.

Finally got a chance to try this unique restaurant. Inside is cute how it is set up. I ended up getting 1 savory pie (Earth to Table) and 1 sweet (PD & J). Was a little surprised at the price of the savory pie but was totally worth it. The combination and flavors were very good and had a really good crust. The pie doesn't look very big but it was very filling and to be honest kind of had to force myself to eat the last couple bites...too good to waste. The sweet was also good..was glad they chose strawberry jam instead of the dreaded grape! My only criticism on this pie is I wish the PB flavor of the mousse stood out a little more. Definitely want to try other items when they switch out their menu.

May 2021 It's been a few years since I came here. We were passing through and I decided to revisit. Their pies were still good (some better than others), and the service was decent. I had ordered online ahead of time. When I got there at the indicated time, my order had not been assembled yet. I don't know if this was laziness or because I had ordered all unbaked pies and they didn't have refrigerator space to hold completed orders. Something they should work on. Nevertheless, the staff were friendly and I only had to wait a few minutes for my order to be ready. I really like the Honey BBQ Chicken, sweet and spicy with yummy cornbread. The Shepherd's Pie was good, but I don't like how they flavored the meat (exactly how escapes me sadly). Note the cookie crusts for the sweet pies are very thin. I was a little disappointed in the Matcha Pomegranate. They used real matcha, but the flavor was very overpowered by the pomegranate. The Graham Cracker Smacker was very (milk) chocolatey with a few mini marshmallows and very thin graham cracker crust.

The pies are interestingly enough pot pies savory and sweet. While I will say pot pie type food is NOT my thing I would suggest you try it. Now it was the customer service and the 80's Music Bingo that will keep me coming back if the continue to do it. This is an inside two story restaurant with a simple menu and very pleasant staff

Staff (or maybe owners I'm not sure) were awesome. They even mentioned other local restaurants for me to visit the next time I'm in the area. The place was super clean and tidy. Nothing looked out of place. The food- it was delicious. (Wasn't a fan of the olives on the tacolicious pie, but I pulled them off). Otherwise the savory pie (tacolicious) was great, and the crust had a perfect texture. Honestly I'd happily eat the cust plain, the texture was THAT perfect. The hot chocolate pie was equally as good. I can't wait until I'm in the area so I can stop by again (and even though their menu is small, they told me it changes every couple weeks or so, that way they can use only the freshest ingredients). 10/10. Stop here. Enjoy a good meal, and a quiet environment.