Bexley Premier Restaurant
2525 E Main St, 43209-2470 - Columbus
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
Updated on
Italian
French
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
59/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🍽️
Dine-in
🥡
Takeout
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 614-745-3551
🌐 Website:
http://www.bexleypremierrestaurant.com/
📍
Address:
2525 E Main St, Columbus
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
82
Google reviews
I ordered take out, and the food was delicious. The sauce on my chicken sandwich was mild house, and I loved it. The macaroni was on point. I didn’t stay, but I want to come back. They have a nice atmosphere, and a large screen for OSU games. I would look too far into the one star reviews - I didn’t understand that perspective at all. Both staff members, one of which was David the Chef, were extremely personable and very accommodating. David asked for honest feedback, and here it is. The are on UberEATS as well, so I would totally try it from home, or go in to hang out.
Read more
Google
I’m a Bexley resident and have often passed this place. I finally tried it and LOVED IT!! It’s definitely underrated. The drinks are tasty and well balanced. I had an amazing margarita!!!! The second time an old fashioned! We had appetizers. The sliders and beet salad were perfect!! The service was excellent. Spaced perfectly for social distancing!! Huge Tv screen playing sports!! Bar and tables are perfectly distanced! I’m particular about clean restrooms which tell you a lot about a restaurant! Their restroom was very clean!! Thank you! I will be returning specially for game days!!
Read more
Google
Not sure I understand all the hate on the food in this place. The portions were great for the price compared to many upscale restaurants in the Columbus area. The food tasted great - my wife and I had the Short Rib, Chicken "A La Kiev," and the lobster mac and cheese for our entrees. All three were rich in flavor, and dang the lobster mac and cheese was good. We had the bruschetta, calamari, Khachapuri, chicken wings, and sweet chili ravioli as appetizers - all tasted amazing, but the sweet chili ravioli was my personal favorite. Admittedly, we ordered way too much, but have enjoyed the leftovers. For drinks, I had an old-fashioned, and my wife had a Mojito - both very strong. Will definitely visit again!
Read more
Google
We had a wonderful experience in this restaurant! Great selection of food and everything was well made! Staff was very lovely and got everything you needed in a timely fashion! Also a very good selection of cocktails 🍹🍸!
Google
Bexley was in need of an upscale restaurant and Premier fits the niche well. The interior says old school classy with some obvious modern flair. The restrooms were clean and nicely appointed. The menu is not adventurous and most places boast a better wine selection. The food we ordered was prepared well and tasty. Surprisingly parking was an issue. The place was not busy but the lot full. I would be furious, if I were the owner. If you want a nicely appointed traditional restaurant without a wild menu, this place is for you.
Read more
Google
I’m amazed with the food! David is an excellent chef and his service is phenomenal. The bartender Katie is the best with signature drinks as well as cocktails. The ambiance and service overall is enough to keep me coming back!!!!
Google
Bexley Premier was an amazing experience! I went just for some down time to myself and a quick drink after work but I had to have more! My server Katie was fantastic and a wonderful bartender to me! She recommended so many great things! Even the Chef, David, came out to talk with me and offer such great food! David really blew me away with his cooking talent! I even ordered some food for my family to bring home and they can’t stop chatting about the bruschetta, mac and cheese, and the steak! Thank you for such a wonderful experience! Next time I’ll definitely be bringing more people!
Read more
Google
Classy, food was amazing and delicious. Cocktails were on point
Google
Went for Restaurant Week. Service was quick, waiter was attentive, food was excellent! I had the bruschetta, salmon, and cheesecake and would recommend all 3.
Google
Came here for brunch w my wife last Sunday and we were blown away. Food and service was amazing. Decor is beautiful. We will come back and try dinner soon.
Google
Explore more in Columbus
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: