Yellow Brick Pizza

We ordered 3 pizzas and the cheesy garlic bread. Yummy!!!!! My 12 yo at his entire pizza! I got the Fresh Prince and it was delish! A little salty, but not bad otherwise. My husband got the Dante Inferno and it was H-O-T!!!! Friendly and fast service! Order from them! Help a local pizzeria out!!!!! You won't regret it!

The food was great although I didn't care of the pizza crust edge, it was too hard to eat. The tap root beer is worth $3.50 a glass as it was rich and flavorful. The offer a great selection for meat eater's as well as veggie people. The service was outstanding. The prices are a little high for a pizza place but it was a nice special occasion splurge.

Yellow Brick is in the Bexley area on the corner of Oak and 18th. From the looks of the inside it appears to be a hipster pizza place/bar. Standard pizza style is in between thin and traditional, cut into slices, but they also offer a Chicago style deep dish. Yellow Brick is often compared to Dewey's or Mellow Mushroom and seems to be a fair comparison. There are a lot of artisan creations for different pizza combinations. My group ordered a variety to try a bit of everything. We got a small Spicy Chicken Corn Chowder, a small Jerry Lee Lewis, a small Cheese, a small Meggie's Veggie, a Large Pepperoni and Onion Tristano's Chicago Stuffed Pizza, a large order of Garlic cheese bread, and a side salad. All of that was $91, which honestly is a fair price based on the quality & quantity of the dough/sauce/cheese/toppings and the size of the pizzas (their small pizza is 10"). Every pizza was quite good with the star of the standard pizzas being the Spicy Chicken Corn Chowder. My personal favorite out of everything was their Chicago style deep dish - loaded with cheese and made the right way for a stuffed pie. In my opinion their Chicago style is better than Giordano's. Garlic cheese bread and salad were average at best. Overall I rate their regular pizzas a 4.6, the Chicago style a 4.8, the sides a 4.3, and the price for the quality a 4.5 I also liked this place more than Dewey's and Mellow Mushroom, due to the better artisan selection for pizzas and the option to get Chicago style deep dish. Since Google doesn't allow decimal reviews, I rounded up to a 5.

This place was great! Nice to find a place that isn’t a chain that has vegan cheese. We loved the different selections of beer (tons to choose from). One ran out halfway thru the pour so my husband got that one for free. And another they forgot to put on our bill. We brought it to their attention but they still didn’t charge us. Who does that?! Absolutely delicious pizzas. Very funky decorations. If we lived anywhere near here, it would be a regular for us.