Food was amazing. I admit it wasn't my first choice, but I'm extremely happy we went. Prices are worth what you get
The Henny Piña Colada, the calamari, everything was perfect. Our server Jay went above and beyond. If you want a restaurant that has excellent food and service in City Island, this is the place to go.
Lisa was amazing , the food was great and the customer service was beautiful , lisa made sure we were ok , she did a pretty good job , I would definitely recommend the Lobster Box any day of the week , money well spent.
The food is amazing! Great service..feels like eating at home
Great experience. Celebrated my Grand Aunts 95th Birthday. Food, Service and Decor were excellent!! Thank you Lobster Box for a wonderful afternoon.
Very friendly and cozy place to enjoy seafood. One of the best hidden spot to have delicious meals at New York City. Our waiter is very professional and even offering us free cake for dessert.
I was a little confused about why this place was the only one on City Island that didn't have a line going down the street. If I had to guess it might be the prices? My wife and I stopped in for margaritas and the Clams Casino. The margaritas were strong and tasty, and the Clams Casino was okay. The service was good, and the place seemed okay. It's pretty pricey for what it is, but it might be worth it to pay the extra money and not wait on a line for 2 hours.
Awesome seafood restaurant, located at famous City Island. Many delicious quality food to choose from, and of course the lobster. Great friendly staff. Fairly priced, compared to other restaurant in the area. Highly recommended, I'll certainly will go back again, and again.
The food was excellent. PiñaColada is outstanding. The staff is amazing!!!
The food was great. We went there to celebrate my grandmother's 92nd Birthday. We ordered the fried calamari and coconut shrimp as an appetizer.
My son's ordered the shrimp and fries, my wife and grandmother ordered the twin lobster tails, and I had the shrimp and ribs.
We ordered a cheese cake to put a candle in and sing happy birthday. I'm not a cheese cake eater and I thought it was good and my grandmother loved it. The portion sizes were very good.
The food was great. Nice and Clean beautiful inside.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in City Island
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes