Samantha Koeninger Rittgers
+5
We love O Pie O! It is our go to spot at all times. The wine selection is by far one of the best in the city and the empanadas and soup exceed our expectations every time! We usually skip dessert but not here! The pies are so good I have started buying them as gifts to take to dinner parties, birthday parties, Thanksgiving and Christmas! I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant and cannot wait to return!
If you're going just for pie you're doing it wrong! Absolutely get the pie (honey vinegar) but also try everything else! I know the menu is ever changing but we were lucky enough to be served some of the most incredible dishes I've ever tried. Including tomato pie, chicken confit, and the most amazing fried green tomato sandwich. We will go back! We will take everyone we know!!
Simple and delicious, exactly how I love it. I popped in about a half hour before closing time and there was still a delightful amount of things to choose from. If I had a refrigerator at my disposal I would have taken home one of their pre-baked chicken pot pies. Happy my friend got me hip to this place. It was both filling and fulfilling.
One of the best pies I have ever had. Really delicious. They do have coffee and other packaged cold beverages, however, it would have been great if they had some other hot options like tea.
Can a place be bad if it has "pie" in the name of the eatery? Obviously the answer is no, no it can't. Arriving at 11:45 for lunch was a really good idea. The place fills up quickly. Some outdoor seating is available. The staff were super friendly and the food just different enough that you feel you have eaten someplace out of the ordinary.
I finally made the trip here after hearing about it for several years and it was well worth it! The dark chocolate pie was incredible. I ate my entire slice, though I shouldn't have. You can get a slice or an entire pie, but I think you want to order it ahead of time. I would get it again in a heartbeat! They had a lot to offer, including quiche, lunch items, wine, beer, cocktails and coffee from Urbana Cafe. It was too cold for the patio, but I would like to come back in the summer or spring to sit out there and try the lemon pie.
Wow. Just, Wow. Excellent Pie restaurant! We were out celebrating Pi day and found this place on Google maps. This place is impressive. I am not a fan of crust but the crust here is amazing. Puff pastry like. Like, perfectly laminated. They make sweet pies and savory pies. I had the Aussie beef. It was out of this world. Perfect balance of meaty, salty sweetness. For dessert, we had a slice of Honey & Vinegar pie and a slice of Lemon pie with whipped cream. The Vinegar & Honey pie had some course salt on top that really help balance out the sweetness. We are definitely going to return here. Service was fast and polite. The place was very clean. Nothing to complain about here.
I'm impressed. The flavors are there in the food. The pocket I had was great: the buttered crust was on point. My wife liked the quiche. I also tried the beer shake; I'm not totally there yet but the choice of Nitro Milk Stout was a good choice.
Add-on: thanks for recognising math teachers on Pi Day.
I had the bumbleberry pie. I was expecting the pie to be super tart but to my surprise the flavors were well balanced and fruity, I ate it all in one setting. I ended up buying two slices of bourbon pecan pie and lemon pie to take home to my mom! Let’s just say that bourbon pecan pie better be around this fall! I’m coming for it! Thanks for great pies.
Stopped in over the weekend. Beautiful establishment, great patio. And Oh my gosh that honey vinegar pie was INCREDIBLE (as you can tell I couldn’t stop by self from taking a bite before my photo). I could have probably have eaten an entire pie and not just a slice. Sad I was only in Cininatti for the weekend. Hopefully they will ship to Omaha soon lol 😂 😉
Great pies and a very welcoming staff. Cute decor and clean tables. They had a great pie selection but I had the quiche, which was outstanding. The salted Carmel pie is a great choice! Wish they were closer to Rhode Island!
Picked this place based on reviews, it did not disappoint! Nighttime atmosphere was dark and calm. Staff was friendly. Food was fantastic. Would never have picked the Honey Vinegar without the recommendations from this app. It was delish!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Cincinnati
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes