Saturday night we decided to try a new pizza place in our area. We are fortunate enough to have SO many great ones, that some slip by.
We checked Yelp for something close and Tony D's popped up!
Thanks as usual to my fellow Yelpers for the reviews! It's the only reason we decided to try it. A lot of the reviews mentioned the, "Drunken Grandma" pizza. A square pizza with vodka sauce and sliced cherry tomatoes. I am happy (but not surprised) to say that you were all right! It was delicious!!! Thin, crisp crust, tasty vodka sauce and sweet cherry tomatoes. Perfect amount of cheese too. Plus you could see and taste the delicious olive oil that must have been drizzled over the crust.
We'll definitely be back!
I'm looking forward to trying their other pizzas.
Sharlene Schmidt Vichness
+5
Excellent!! All our SuperBowl guests were blown away with the veggie and plain pies. Special praise from me on the gluten-free pie! GF is not easy to do well and Tony’s does it really well!
Tony D's is one of the celebrated pizzeria's in Caldwell. Tucked around the corner from the community pub Cloverleaf Tavern, you might be forgiven for missing it. Take away only, but they're bustling. Really cool pies too - they're doing the square sicilian-type pie. Drunken Grandma? Vodka sauce - yes please. Little Italy, with fresh crumbled sausage and long hots? Of course. Both pictured on this review. It's easy to see why this place is so loved among locals, and some of my friends drive 30 mins to pick it up.
It All Starts with your first interaction behind the counter and this was one of the Best with the pleasant Andrea running the show. She talked shop and pizza and made the experience that much better. Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App, Tony Ds did not disappoint. As the Pizza Hulk says, this could be one of the Best Grab and Go Slices out there. The Sauce, Cheese and Crust works great together with the Crispy Crust being the star of the show. I will definitely be back again as part of the Essex County Tournament.
I was very very impressed!! They had my pie ready for me at exactly 510 when I asked for, the thickness was perfect to me. The taste reallyyyy reminded me of star tavern except without all that crack oil they use over there. 🤗. Everyone loved it including my boyfriends dad whose name is tony d also, which is why I came here in the first place and oh also the good reviews. 🤗🤷♀️
Unbelievable Pizza at this place, we called an hour prior to going because the pizza Lina takes an hour, it is well worth waiting for, absolutely delicious and fresh tasting, quality ingredients and fantastic dough. It was so good we wanted more LOL so we split a square slice and a slice of Grandma pie those two were both outstanding as well, I will absolutely be back it was a 20-minute drive for us but it was worth every mile of it
A really wholesome pizza slice made to perfection ! You can’t go wrong with a ‘Drunken Grandma’
Best pizza in the area. Always go grandma pie. Haven’t had anything else on their menu cause their pizza is so good
Great pizza! Definitely on the best in the area. Extremely nice people. Can't go wrong at Tony D's!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Caldwell
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes