Sunset Bagels

Name: Sunset Bagels
Address: 4903 5th Ave, Brooklyn, 11220-1906, US
Telephone: +1 718-437-0905
Rating: 3.5

4903 5th Ave, 11220-1906 - Brooklyn

Recommended by Sluurpy: 2021

🏆 #2667 of 3082 restaurants in Brooklyn

Updated on 31 May 2026

Known for: bakeries chocolate brownie cheeseburger oreo cake

★★★★★ ★★★★★

3.5/5

734 recommendations

+14

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY

Popularity

100/100

Quality

48/100

Data Completeness

56/100

Menu — Popular Dishes at Sunset Bagels

📊 Menu Insights

🍽️

309 dishes

Variety: High

💰

€1-152

Mid-range

🌱

4 vegetarian

Options available

📋

29 categories

Structured menu

3.5/5

Sluurpometro: 70/100

Sluurpy Score

734 total reviews

TA Trip

3.5/5

9 reviews

G Google

3.6/5

661 reviews

F Foursquare

2.5/5

58 reviews

G Grubhub

4.0/5

6 reviews

Rating distribution

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 718-437-0905

🌐 Website: http://sunsetbagelsbrooklyn.com/

📍 Address: 4903 5th Ave, Brooklyn

🕐 Opening Hours

Open now Closes at 11:59 PM

Monday1 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Tuesday2 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Wednesday3 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Thursday4 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Friday5 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Saturday6 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

Sunday7 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM

🍽️ Menu - Menu

📷 Photos (11+)

+3
more photos

Google Reviews

3.6/5

★★★★★

661 Google reviews

Rebecca Allor

a week ago

★★★★★ 5/5

I’m not from the area, but I come to the city often to visit family. This is a mandatory stop for us. We always get a bacon, egg and cheese bagel and we’re never disappointed.

Google

dionna goldstein

4 months ago

★★☆☆☆ 2/5

The food here is good but the probability of you getting what you ordered is slim to none. I use to go here for lunch every day but got tired of getting the wrong order. Either the girls up front are taking the order down wrong or there’s a communication issue with the chefs because I was given the wrong order 4 days in a row! That’s when I decided To find a new lunch spot. Bummer cause the food is tasty but not worth it to be paying and eating something I didn’t order on a daily basis!

Google

Jennifer Moore

2 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

The service was great. The bagels delicious. There is plenty of seating. I got a bagel with egg to go. It was perfectly wrapped and stayed warm. The mango tea was fantastic.

Google

RKO1035

2 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

On 5th Avenue in Sunset park with a Chinese owner and staff had business black t shirts and no outlandish outfits and who were so efficient and courteous. Wanted a bagel and the bagel was tasty with cream cheese. In NYC it's called a "Smear"! Place was crowded and decent seating area, but oh so on my list if the occasion arises to be in the area again. Little gems are in my black book.

Google

Tee A

3 months ago

★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

I’ve been ordering from this place ever since it opened. And it’s sad to say that as of lately the food has gotten so terrible.I ordered a 49st Mexican Panini. The chicken I got not only was WAYYYY over cooked but it felt like plastic in my mouth. As if it was cooked from earlier in the day and just reheated. Even the avocado was brown! This isn’t the first time I’ve dealt with something like this. It’s either the order is wrong and I have to return it or the food just isn’t to expectations(freshness). In the past few months I’ve either sent back food and had them “fix it” only for the food they send to either be wrong or just as horrible. At this point I’d much rather order from sunset dinner. It’s a shame what this place has come to. I don’t even want a refund or for someone to change my order. Just want to warn everyone considering to order from here, not to waste their time. It’s a huge hit or miss with them.

Google

Pebles Urena

a month ago

★★★★★ 5/5

This place has the food so fresh so tasty so good words can’t even express what I want to say about it trust me I know about food and this here there really doing there best to put a smile on your face and your taste buds oh man it’s like the food is made with love and very clean environment friendly staff it’s like being home here and everything you order is guaranteed to be fresh and made with love I know that for a fact there are many places that don’t even care about your feedback but at sunset bagels they DO CARE trust me customer satisfaction is there number one priority as well as there cleanliness and there staff so friendly and polite I would come here and eat every day I love sunset bagels

Google

Alicia Roman

3 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Breakfast it was delicious cofee on point love this place delivery fast

Google

Stuart Little

2 months ago

★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

Very Expensive + the chubby kid at night does not answer the phone calls on purpose. I was right outside my car looking at him on his phone with no customers inside ignoring my phone calla to order food. Also Sometimes there is no one at the counter & take very long to get your order done.

Google

Explore more in Brooklyn

By specialty

Recommended pages

Help improve this page:

← Back to all restaurants in Brooklyn

Sunset Bagels

Sluurpy Quality Index

Menu — Popular Dishes at Sunset Bagels

📊 Menu Insights

Rating distribution

Contact Information

🕐 Opening Hours

🍽️ Menu - Menu

Beverages

Smoothies and Shakes

Tea and Coffee

Special Coffee

Freshly Squeezed Juice

Breakfast

Eggs

French Toast

Hot Oatmeal

Omelettes and Breakfast

Breakfast Wraps

Pancakes and Waffles

Bagels and Flagels

Soups

Specialty Salads

Cold Sandwiches

Specialty Sandwiches

Extraordinary Specials

Grilled Panini

Lunch Wraps

1/2 lb. Flame Broiled Black Angus Burger

Classic Burgers

Chimi Churri

Quesadillas

Made to Order

Dinner Platters

Muffins and Pastries

Desserts

Cold Salads

📷 Photos (11+)

Google Reviews

Rebecca Allor

dionna goldstein

Jennifer Moore

RKO1035

Tee A

Pebles Urena

Alicia Roman

Stuart Little

Other restaurants similar in Brooklyn

Explore more in Brooklyn

By specialty

Recommended pages

🍽️ Suggest a dish

Thank you!

⚠️ Report error

Thank you!

🚫 Report closed

Thank you!