A great ice cream spot down by the water. All the flavors we sampled were good. They also had 5 vegan options. Cookie jar was the choice I chose, although they didnt have chocotorta, which is odd since the Domino Park location usually has this flavor.
Yes it’s pricey, but this neighborhood is heavy with tourism so it’s expected. I don’t mind if the product is good quality and this ice cream is worth it.
Way better then BK Ice cream factory that’s close by!
The unique choices are fun, ice cream is top quality, creamy and flavors smack together.
Staff is nice and let you try options, the decor is carnival fun vibe. Definitely check it out if your in the area they have more flavors then most.
Personally I like Van Luwen better.
A delicious ball of goodness. OddFellows' flavors slap!! Perfect spot to grab a scoop before going for a walk near the Brooklyn Bridge.
Popped by on a sunny Sunday afternoon and got some ice creams and a break from the afternoon heat. I got the raspberry rosé cider flavour which was delicious. Perfect spot for an ice cream and a stroll along the harbour on a nice day!
A great ice cream spot down by the water. All the flavors we sampled were good. They also had 5 vegan options. I ended up getting vegan grasshopper which I would recommend to anyone that likes mint chocolate.
Yes it’s pricey… but this neighborhood is heavy with tourism so it’s expected. I don’t mind if the product is good quality and this ice cream is worth it.
really tasty ice cream, and the price of the 6-scoop set is quite good for the amount of ice cream you get!
Amazing ice cream, good number of options (17 flavors including 5 vegan options (3 sorbets)), decent prices, a great deal with flight option (6 reasonable mini scoops for $10) and a minute away from Dumbo viewpoints & parks where you can sit and enjoy the Manhattan skyline.
Our favorite flavors were the PB and J, chocotorta and Brooklyn blackout with Olive oil getting a special mention. The texture and amount of sweetness was perfect.
The mini scoop amounts are good to enough to not get over in few spoons. They also sell pints and wine.
Quite expensive for what it is but I guess they’re paying high rent over here and there must be a lot of disposable income in the neighborhood, lol. Small assortment of unusual flavors, we liked the miso caramel. The matcha, soso. Pleasant room but look out in summer, last time we tried there was a huge line.
One the best tasting ice-cream we've had, great quality, is was not sweet which I loved, creamy and smooth. Would go back!
Ice cream was pretty solid. Nothing to really stand out though. Flavors were interesting, I got a coffee sticky bun, for a double scoop for $8.50.
The place had an old timey retro feel which was cool. Would go again, as the location is great to grab a cup and walk around DUMBO
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Brooklyn
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes