Pizza Secret
72 5th Ave., 11217 - Brooklyn
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#490 of 3044 restaurants in Brooklyn
Updated on
€€
Italian
Pizza
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
64/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 929-337-6245
🌐 Website:
http://www.pizzasecretnyc.com
📍
Address:
72 5th Ave., Brooklyn
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
487
Google reviews
The gluten-free pizza crust was very good, so that raises my rating. But the service was chaotic and neglected us. They could have made a lot more $$$ off my table. We had to flag down the manager to get another round of drinks. We didn't get one of our ordered dishes. And we wanted dessert and coffee but were sick of sitting around. Good food though, we just wanted more of it.
Read more
Google
Really really good Americana pizza. No wonder they got featured in New York Times (top 17). Crust was just right and the spiced honey is delicious. Colleen our server was very warm and kind.
Google
I love this place! Great late night vibes. Food was great, and especially the dessert. If you love Nutella you will love the desserts. Our server was great, so sweet and nice. She even gave us a free shot at the end of the night. 10/10 would recommend
Google
This was our second time at Pizza secret. Both experiences were incredible. Our hostess Colleen was so attentive and gave amazing recommendations. The award winning Americana pizza was so delicious. We will definitely be back for more!
Google
Pizza secret is pizza heaven. It is #17 of the top 50 pizzas in the US, ranked by Italians. Definitely try the viola & pancetta pizza with purple potato sauce… all delicious Neapolitan pizza.
Google
Authentic Napolitano style pizza and restaurant. The food was very delicious and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. The restaurant was very beautiful and looked like it was straight from Napoli. Try the zucchini pie it was super delicious !
Google
This is an amazing pizza, totally worth being nominated in the top 50 in the US! If you like Neapolitan pizza, this place is a must!
Google
My favourite pizzas in the city!
Don't get fooled by the interior design, it's very authentic and great pizzas. Always easy to get a table.
Google
Solid Neapolitan style pizza but less boring than usual fare: better dough (slightly tangy from longer fermentation and better flour), great toppings, nice seasoning. And the staff is amazing too. Great job overall!
Google
Came here solo while I was visiting in Brooklyn.
I'm not an expert on Napoletana style pizza but I thought it was delicious and flavorful. The crust was so good. Could have had a 2nd pizza.
A little pricey for one pizza but the quality is there. They were live streaming the pizza artist making some of the orders. That was a lot of fun to watch.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Brooklyn
Help improve this page: