Kassandra Solsrud
Great bagel place in Brooklyn! They have a full deli. There are many bagel options with various cream cheese options. They are also a selection of chips, pickles, jams, sweets and more to shop from. The staff is friendly. Will definitely be returning!
marsilla fujisawa
Bagel here is so fresh! One of the best in Brooklyn. I also got the halva from here and it’s fantastic. Coffee is also good. I visited when its raining so only one table provided to eat inside.
Jon
Best lox bagels in nyc. Fancy Pants and Peter Shelsky's were both amazing. Service is smooth and friendly.
Felix Stekolshchik
I ordered two bagels with salmon from there. Food was super good and the service was really pleasant. I was with my dog and i was looking for my food on the pick up tray. An employee saw me looking and asked for my name. I didn't have to go inside (I couldn't bring my dog in) and he brought the food out to me. That was super nice of them and as always the food was bomb. They have the best bagels and the salmon is always top notch. Plus I love pickled tomatoes.
HANE Xxxx
Great quality food, but $12 for dark rye bread is too much (the bread was amazing). You can find red caviar, smoked sturgeon, liver pate, tofu cream cheese and other delicacies here on top of usually expected bagels and cured salmon.
The shopping system is confusing, you have to take a ticket for some reason.
Travelbug
Wow, the pastrami sandwich not cheap but was so delicious and worth every dime. It was as juicy as it was a bbq briskets.
Their salmon lox/ smoked salmon looked very good as well. Hope to fry that next time!
Kasey B
Lox bagel was delicious - bagel was perfectly toasted, good balance of cream cheese. The latkes were good size but pretty greasy and soggy.
Asad C
Best bagel in New York, hands down.
Christopher Harmon
As a southern guy who works in Brooklyn throughout the year, fish for breakfast was not something I thought I'd be into. The 'Member of the Tribe' bagel was absolutely delicious. And even though I'm from the south, I do not care for sweet tea. The Subtle Tea they sold there was perfect.
Mark Clark
Don't sleep on Shelky's 🥯🐟 The best of Brooklyn and top 5 in NYC.
Maisie Lokeinsky
I figured I'd take gamble and got the Brooklyn Native thinking it sounded interesting but maybe a bit too overwhelming with so many different kinds of fish. But I really enjoyed it, everything came together really well!
I also got some house picked herring on the side with picked onions and cream. I was brought right back to my childhood.
Not to mention the decor and vibe of the place is a wonderful and charming homage to the Jewish culture.
Brian Khorshad
I stopped by Shelsky’s one Sunday morning for a bagel, and was blown away. I got one of, if not the best, lox bagels I’ve had in the city. The servers were also very friendly and it felt like a proper neighborhood joint with very friendly people.
Yue Gao
I ordered a Peter Shelsky bagel with tofu cream cheese and it was so, so good!!! It was sour, sweet and rich! Highly recommended!
Carol Román
If you like a chewy - I mean CHEWY bagel, this is your place. The first bagel I had was “stick to the roof of your mouth” chewy. Didn’t seem right. Almost as if the bagel wasn’t allowed to rest after baking. That bagel had salmon cream cheese, which was only ok. The salmon flavor didn’t really come through. Second experience, bagel was still chewy, but not as much. Crunchy exterior and lots of seeds, which I appreciate. This bagel had the white fish salad, that was a hit. Not too salty like others usually are. Trying the pastrami next. Coffee is just average.
Jacalyn Yang
Ordered smoked salmon, whitefish salad, scallion cream cheese, and vegetable cream cheese. Order was ready to pick up and the person carefully checked to make sure everything I ordered was in the bag. Very much appreciated!
Janice Mitchell Hurowitz
If you love lox ... You will really lol this place. Small seating area. We were 4 and stopped in while picking up son.
We sat at the two tall bar tables by the window front. We had a great time. Peter, the owner is really nice. Take-out mostly. Different kinds of
Lox , so many amazing sandwich combos that I suggest checking out the menu online before going.
Sara McGovern
I just had the pastrami salmon with horseradish sauce sandwich and it was fantastic. This shop is truly neighborhood gem, so glad we have a place like this nearby.
Nema Dera
If you love lox ... You will really love this place. Different kinds of lox , so many amazing sandwich combos that I suggest checking out the menu online before going.
Emma Anderson
Loved the food. Not the wait. It was crammed. But it was worth the time.
Joe Hasazi
Shelsky’s sturgeon puts Barney Greengass’s to shame! Also best rugelach and halava in NYC!!
Lauren Berman Kaufman
An instant classic! The tuna! The salmon bacon! Could stay there all day!
Ferry van Lier
The best place to get the freshest fish. For sure, fresh haring.
Michael Morganelli
Lobster roll’s a great value! Also, don’t miss their pickles.
Kees FaesenKloet
The store is a glorious Brooklyn treasure - I go in and want to buy everything! The smoked fish is incredible and the rugelach spactacular. Stop reading this and just go.
Catherine Hamilton
So if you're looking for ah-mazing smoked salmon and other delicious treats, this is the place! I will definitely be back next time I'm in town!!
Mélissa Leclézio
The best bagel I've ever had and an excellent service. Try the Great Gatsby!
Jill Green
Peter the owner is so great and has made the new space on Court Street right off of Atlantic Ave a great spot. Awesome quality food! Mazel : )))
Bridget O'Connor
Dump Trump? How do you like him now? You can keep your smoked fish!
Dana L. Withall
Good thing we don’t have Shelsky’s in San Diego! I’d be broke!
Ben Austin
Where have these guys been all my life? No need to to go to the Lower East Side anymore for some serious appetizing. I got the Brooklyn Transplant sandwich via Seamless and it was delivered in 11 MINUTES. Food is delicious... can't wait to try the chicken liver.
Jascha Narveson
Just bit in to The Gatsby sandwich: these people are artists.
Sam Harris
Does love come on a bagel? It does at Shelsky's!
Robert Aaron Rosenberg
Breakfast was a hit, didn't buy enough food.
Rob Schlederer
Mind bending. Try the Gatsby.
Marti Minker
Yummy!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes