Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Apple pie in Brooklyn

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
89/100 (2130 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Cafe
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Breakfast
Apple pie
Café
American
Café
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"My god! This place is dangerous to have within walking distance, because it is just too good. I have been here 3 times in a 3 week span and dont..."
Amish Rohatgi
"The pies from this place are amazingly delicious! My favorite is the Lemon Chess Pie - the best! This last time we had a cappuccino from Variety..."
Adriana De Pitkin
"We were staying in Manhattan and made a special trip to Brooklyn just for these pies. Our son and daughter-in-law turned us on to Four and Twenty..."
Missy Padilla Runyon
"The salted caramel apple pie was divine! Undoubtedly one of the best pie slices that I have ever had...."
Armando Martins
"I’m a sucker for the Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie ($44) by 4&20! My friend who is a Brooklynite introduced me to 4&20 and I think I’ve made..."
Talisa
"Friendly staff and delicious pies! Must try the salty honey! The apple is also drool worthy. Wasn’t huge on the coconut and chocolate varieties...."
Angie h
"I’ve been eating pie from this place for years but finally made it down to the mothership to try it in person. The place is cute! Lots of seating..."
Riki Rosenthal
"Great spot and incredibly friendly staff. The pie is divine, the lemon chess pie is a perfect balance of sweet and savory and the apple pie cannot be..."
Nickelas Trepanier
"One of the best coffee spots I have been to. The pie is top notch! I wasn’t sure which one to get so I had a couple slices. The coffee was made..."
Seth Kleinglass
"This place was unbelievable, they make all different type of pies. I got the salted caramel and a latte..."
Oscar Villalba
"I've been coming here on&off for years from Queens - recommend this place to all.. usually, I am not a pie person, but ILoveThisPlaceSoVeryMuch.💗..."
L Brady
"Upon passing Four and Twenty Blackbird, you may not know what this establishment sold if not for the outdoor stand directing you to pie… but any..."
Jessica Mark
"This is my favorite pie! I been coming for years, every time I'm in Brooklyn. My favorite is the honey and salted apple. The pies are expensive but..."
Marelis Zapata
"Tried a majority of their pies and they're all super good. I would say for the most part they are on the decadent/heavy side, so brace yourself for a..."
Leah Cranston
"Four and Twenty Blackbirds is the gold standard for pies. They make the best pies from coast to coast. My favorite pies are the salted caramel apple,..."
S. Reid
"Very cozy place with a huge wooden table for two persons. I ordered oat latte and pumpkin pie with whipped cream. I am intolerant of too much sugar..."
Yukiko Ikeda
"Hands down the best apple pie I have *ever* had. I had the caramel apple crumble pie and it was amazing. Go now!! Super cool, super chill vibe in the..."
Anna Zuver
Pies 'n' Thighs
87/100 (20132 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Salad
Mac and cheese
Chicken And Waffles
Waffles
Chicken Sandwich
Crawfish
Catfish
Sandwiches
Apple pie
Burger
Biscuits and gravy
Cakes
Fish
Pork
Pancakes
Pasta
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"If you are in Brooklyn and don't eat here I'm sorry for your loss. The atmosphere is great. Friendly and helpful staff with quaint little tables. ..."
Michael Costanzo
""Mixed Feelings at Pie&Thigh Brooklyn" My visit to Pie&Thigh in Brooklyn had its ups and downs. Despite having high expectations, the chicken turned..."
Sukkaj Noonvongsa
"First time in and I will be returning. Customer service is exceptional, welcomed as soon as I walked in, looked at the menu and it was hard to..."
shaquana lance
"We arrived at 11 am on a Saturday. While there was no wait, the table space was limited. Most tables are outside, so plan accordingly. We decided to..."
Megan Crawford
"It's pretty hard to find good Southern food in NYC and this place fits the bill. I am from Louisiana and the taste is authentic to what we have down..."
L. Rocha
"I haven’t been here in a few years as I’m not in the neighborhood much but we went back and to my surprise not much has changed. The chicken has..."
Justin Mickaliger
"What a great little spot. Food was great I got Chicken and Waffles, loaded fries and for desert I got the chocolate pie. Amazing service, very..."
Christian
"Came here on a rainy Sunday, ordered two chicken biscuit sandwiches to go and some baked goods. The turn around was very quick and the staff was..."
Lorene Pereira
"Est. 2006 Layout/atmosphere *Three tables in front of restaurant near bakery display; more tables in the back room; covered outdoor dining in street..."
Daniel Pino
"I’ve visited Pies n’ Thighs three times now and have enjoyed my experience each time. The food has stayed consistent throughout. Crispy and moist..."
Carly
"Delicious fried chicken and southern sides! 4 of us had brunch in this small but delicious spot. Seating is limited so come early, but the food is..."
Yousef Alowayed
"good atmosphere and nice service I ordered a piece of sour cherry pear pie & banjo & coffee I think I will miss this taste 😋 especially the cherry..."
양꿍똠
"Stayed at a hotel nearby and it was a chilly June night. Luckily we found this place around the corner and we were able to get a table inside. Our..."
Nicole De La Torre
"Fantastic chicken, great service. Pies were in redible. Share a box so you have room for desert! Second visit did not..."
John Ortiz
"We came here for a quick brunch before we started our Christmas shopping. We got here early but, there was still a wait. We ordered a chicken biscuit..."
Lady Ace
"Wow we were probably lucky because our waiter was awesome! The service was great and speedy. Food quality is high. Our biscuits arrived hot and..."
Joe za
"Classic spot for chicken and waffles Don’t miss out Comfort food as it’s finest Book a reservation if you can Oh the dessert bourbon pecan pie..."
Jonathan Ong
Brennan & Carr Restaurant Inc
84/100 (2411 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Chowder
Roast Beef
Juice & Smoothies
Juice & Smoothies
Apple pie
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
Hamburgers
Beef
Wings
Clam Chowder
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Love this place it’s so cute. Sitting down in this place it felt like I time traveled back in time. I can’t believe I just found out about it...."
Confessions of a Food Freak
"By far one of the best sandwiches in Brooklyn. Worth the hype… can’t say I tried the Gargiulo burger, that seemed like overkill, but the broth is..."
Daniel Genis
"Finally made it, didn’t realize I was down the block from @brennanandcarr , roast beef and gravy was delish , roast beef nice and medium rare and..."
DIMITRI LASKAS
"Went to compare their roast beef with Rolln Roaster and ordered to go. Got home and they put a burger in the bag instead. May have been the wrong..."
Jonah Wagan
""I recently had the pleasure of trying the Gargiulo Burger at Brennan & Carr and it was absolutely amazing! The combination of tender roast beef and..."
Cj Ninebot
"Horrifying vegetarians for generations, this place has the beef. Well-loved, dark wood interior is a cross between your corner diner and a Bavarian..."
James Koster
"Brennan and Carr and Roll N Roast are two great roast beef Brooklyn institutions. Both are great and both worth a visit. Personally, I prefer roll n..."
Norman Conquest
"The chicken wings were fried to perfection. The roast beef sandwich was moist and flavorful. Onion rings - perfect crisp. The blueberry pie a la mode..."
Christine Nicole Herrera
"I’ve been meaning to come here for years and I am SO glad I did. Had lunch here on a Sunday with my girlfriend - we both had roast beef with..."
Eliot W
"Top of the line place.. Great food , place is clean and the people are very nice. I wish they can do a little better on there price and accept..."
Floor cleaning services
"This place has the best roast beef in Brooklyn hands down. Make sure to get a side of beef broth for dunking you won't regret it. Cheese fries..."
Lynda Sigwanz
"burgers, roast beef, a classic dine-in experience, they got it all. one of my favorite local posts. defines nostrand and ave U just being there. very..."
Alex Paseka
"One word, AMAZING. If you want melt in your mouth roast beef then this is the place to go. And DO NOT MISS the pie. We split a slice of blueberry and..."
Jacqui M
"I don't like roast beef but I enjoyed the roast beef from here. They soak it in a delicious beef broth or u can get the broth on the side for dipping..."
Isaac Wei
"This was my first time at Brennan and Carr, and I loved it! It was like stepping back in time. They don't have a huge selection but what they have is..."
Jonquel NYC
"Their beef broth tasted a bit too salty for me. Corn fritters and roast beef sandwich were..."
dies christine
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use