Emily

This is the tastiest burger I've ever had in New York. It's impressively large with rich layers inside, including crispy bits that add a delightful texture. The beef patty is tender, and what makes it special is that you can't customize the ingredients. Perhaps it's the secret to maintaining its unique taste consistently.

One of the best burgers I have ever tried. The portion is humongous, and I really like their special house sauce and caramelized onions. The bomb! However, the bacon is a bit too salty for me. So, my recommendation is not to add bacon to the burger. Besides that, everything is perfect. Live up the hype.

I live in Detroit, and had a colleague recommend Emily since she knew I was going to Brooklyn. I couldn't make it in until about 8pm on a Sunday night, and it absolutely blew my mind. Got the Emmy burger, and the Emily pizza. The Emmy burger is messy but easily one of the best burgers I've ever had, and the pizza was so complicated and rich. The bartender was extremely nice and answered a ton of questions I had, and the patrons were cool too. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the neighborhood

The emmy burger was soo goood better than in and out for sure. Haha. They have this sweet caramalized onion. Bunch of them. The burger bun was nice it has a natural sweet fresh bread aftertaste. The cut was soggy and scrispy at the round edge. Yea i was surprised too. The sauce was good as well it helps the bun the meat soft and flavourful. The fries with it was crispy it is good enough to binge eating when you need some rest from the burger. But personally this portion was 33 something plus tax. This burger was good but the price was just a little pricey to what it offers. However a good nice experience. And a cold free tap water per person.

We usually order the colony pizza for delivery but this was our first time going in person. It was great to get everything right out of the oven. We love the Caesar salad with real anchovies and the colony pizza is the perfect mix of spicy and sweet ingredients. The space is a little small so you might have a wait but the service is quick and pleasant.

Came to Emily with high expectations and a roaring appetite. Left feeling more satisfied than I can remember ever being and in a quandary over whether it was the best burger I’ve ever tried. If you like your burger sloppy and packed out with onion then it’ll be your winner. If you prefer a slightly less packed out piece then you’ll probably side for a more classic burger. The melting, dripping landslide of cheese is very special. If Emily put a Classic American Cheeseburger on their menu then I have no doubt it would be the best burger in the world. The Korean Sticky & Sour Fried Chicken was a surprise actually. Easily one of the best dishes we ordered. Start with the initial saucy flavour and then just the perfect amount of hard crisp before falling away into the soft underside of chicken flesh - truly something to get if you come. Colony Pizza was very solid, had pepperoni and hot honey. I don’t think it beats Village Square Pizza but it was an unexpected delight. The broccoli salad was also a surprise, really beautifully cooked chicken and balanced flavours in the salad.

I’ve been coming here for years, and would guess I’ve been here 25+ times total. It’s my absolute favorite burger & pizza in the city. Until you’ve eaten at this location, you haven’t had their best burger, considering the other locations have a diff style of burger, this is the pinnacle of burgers! Also the pies are so delicious, I’m partial to the Emmy & colony but I’ve tried just about every one of them and they’re all enjoyable. Also, the Korean wings were my personal favorite as well but they took them off the menu last year I believe, but now the same sauce is on chicken fingers (basically) and they’re still incredible. I’m so happy & thankful they’re back! The broccoli salad and watermelon salads are a nice add on since the more substantial dishes tend to be rich, but let’s me honest, you don’t come to Emily for salads. Burger, pizza and Korean chicken and you’ll love every bite!