Sluurpy
Reset

There are 15 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Appleton

There are 15 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carmella's
90/100 (2360 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Saltimbocca
Eggplant
Pasta
Ice Cream
Salad
Gelato
Crab
Cupcakes
Scallops
Cakes
Calamari
Lamb
Pesto
Risotto
Fish
Calamares
Pork
Salmon
Antipasti
Sandwiches
Ragu
Paninis
Shrimp
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Lobster
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Late Night
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I cannot rave enough about this place. It's become a ritual for my Aunt and I when she comes home for a visit... We order an appetizer, each order an..."
Keisha Balch
"I've never much ventured out of my comfort zone in food. I'm used to commercial fastfood-esk experiences. But my date insisted that I try this place...."
Victoria Englebert
"I made reservations for a group of 10. Our table was ready before we arrived. We had a wonderful waiter, Frankie, who took great care of us; he was..."
Chelsea Cook
"We love it here! Our daughter was recently diagnosed with Celiac's disease. Our server today thoughtfully asked if she had a gluten allergy when we..."
Tara Otto Hagman
"We went for a late lunch, we were greeted with smiles and our server Franklyn was great! He accommodated our every ask. Food was wonderful, wine was..."
Dawn Bellow
"On a recommendation we decided to eat here. From the moment we walked in we were greeted with smiles and welcomes. After we were seated, our..."
Melissa Cootway
"Awesome food and service. We had Michael as our waiter. He took very good care of us! The food was excellent as was sitting outside in back! We..."
Tim Gill
"Met some friends here for my birthday. Wonderful food ( I had the scampi), friendly and attentive service, good wine and even great coffee! I love..."
Doreen Vedral
"Everything was delicious. Our waitress was very friendly as well. Very happy we decided to check this place out. It's the best Italian food I have..."
Yen Nicol
"I stumbled upon this place while shopping in Appleton today. It being tucked in the mini-mall, it was hard to know it was there. Being in a..."
Anna M. Johnson
"Been here several times and everytime the food is amazing and service is top notch! Thanks for such a great food..."
Jamie Springhetti Buchberger
"Delicious ravioli with pesto last night, as well as a surprise treat for my birthday! Excellent service as..."
Senora P. Meyer
"Great service. We dined outside, a bit chilly at the start, but then they turned on the heaters and all was well. Very attentive waitstaff. Great..."
Sue Knutson Bellmer
"Growing up in an Italian Family, it is hard to compare Italian Restaurants and their authenticity to what I am used to; so with that being said, I..."
Maria Terese
"Jasmine offered incredible service and our food was absolutely delicious. My new favorite spot in Appleton! Can't wait to come back and try some of..."
Rachel Fricke
"Ive only been here a handful of times. Im never disappointed when I come. The food is fresh and from scratch. Love..."
Crystal Guevara
"I’ve been in Appleton, WI all week and this was the best dinner hands down. A bit on the costly side, but totally worth spending the companies..."
Trina Gregory
"Great food and service, atmosphere is very nice also, menu is fair for pricing. The area needs more restaurants like this one, it's a great..."
Q L
"Could not have been more impressed! Amazing atmosphere and service (one of the most helpful servers I have ever had at a restaurant), but the food..."
Brad Pomplun
"Staff was so friendly and inviting! Food was amazing! Can't wait to eat here..."
Fawn S
"First time ever eating at Carmella’s and I must say, it was truly the BEST! Brian was our server and he did such an amazing job. He was..."
S SHIPMAN
Luigis Pizza Of Appleton
90/100 (338 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub
89/100 (405 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Pizza
Pizza
American
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
American
Bar
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Best pizza in the Valley, hands down. Upgrade to the garlic butter crust. You won't be..."
Nikki Paffenroth
"We stopped there for dinner last night for the first time and it was outstanding! The service, the food such a great staff! We are coming back..."
Deb Cheslak Schuh
"Great decor and large, diverse menu. Will was a very helpful server. Will definitely be..."
Eric J Gauthier
"I'm from Chicago and love my thin crust and stuffed. This is Chicago style pizza as far as I'm concerned! The Italian sausage is phenomenal and we..."
Heather McTague- Gledhill
"Best pizza and lasagna but also don't miss the Friday fish!! Yum!!! Can't speak for all the other items on the menu because that is all I ever order..."
Lee Rahr
"Great food, great service, and I can bring the dog on the patio. What not to..."
Victoria Morrow
"I loved the place. The food was amazing and the staff were so nice and..."
Steph Hoffmann
"Excellent waiter and excellent food! we had the Coco : mild sauce, spicy sausage, black olives, roasted garlic, mushrooms, artichoke hearts and coco..."
Deb Robbins Van Handel
"The BBQ chicken pizza is the best in town. Great drinks had a Twix and Pomegranate Martini 🍸 and they were awesome. We will be back and will let..."
RaDeena Steve Sinclair
"We went out with our friends and decide to have dinner here . First time here for all of us ! The Pizza was phenomenal!! One friend had a chicken..."
Raymond Mueller
"I had the stuffed pizza (capone) and it is the best pizza in the area. Wish I would have tried it..."
Dave Jackson
"It wasn't very busy, new waiter who was professional. Food was great and nice bar and food area. Kids were happy to play some video..."
Jeff Krysiak
"Excellent food and service!! Variety to choose from on the menu! Definitely..."
Jenni Argall
"Great food and nice place to have dinner with family and..."
Jude Hoffmann
"The best pizza I've had in a long time! Love the Thin crust,appetizers and adult..."
Richard Watry
"Great pizza, fantastic atmosphere, friendly service. Will definitely go..."
Dani Green
"That Four Cheese Ravioli is soooooo damn..."
Robert Bender
"Great pizza every time! Love the spicy sausage and zesty sauce is a..."
Megan Rose
"This is the best pizza place in NE WI. They make amazing food and have a great staff. Even when they forgot my order on one occasion, the owner..."
Jonathon Schlinder
"The owners were so friendly and the pizzas and drinks were so good. Can't wait to go..."
Jenna Lemke
"The food was great - bruschetta, calzone and a pizza. Ashley was awesome. The place is very well decorated. My only, very slight, issue was that it..."
Roger Trovato
"This spot is first-rate and spacious, the menu was yummy and the prices were very inexpensive. quick, efficient service and very welcoming waiters. I..."
Josue Griffith
"Love this place. Their pizza is very good. If you like a bit of spice make sure to try the zesty sauce. Not to hot, just enough to add an extra burst..."
Nick Jansen
"Best pizza in Appleton. Always great service & their pizza is the..."
Bella Johnson
"We had a wonderful perch dinner tonight. The staff was extra careful with cleaning and masks, and the tables in use were spaced for proper..."
bhfulcer
"Some of the best pizza in the fox cities. Ordered curbside pick-up and our food was ready when..."
Patrick Hartel
Home Run Pizza
86/100 (508 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Fish
Pizza
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Delicious food in a clean restaurant. Friday fish fry dinner was awesome. My wife and I ate here for our first time tonight. It was a very pleasant..."
M Chedd
"Pizza is kind of expensive, but absolutely worth the money. If you like thin crust, this place has some of the best. It has kind of a smoky flavor..."
Ben Runnoe
"So, new owners. Nice people. Still really good. They are doing a great job holding the torch. Great pizza, Good fish..."
Anthony Collins
"Took a bite while in the car. It was so good ordered another one for my daughter. Awesome staff, will ordered again..."
Isaac Dyer
"If we go out for pizza Home Run is our choice. We always get the 12" pizza which is just right for the 2 of us. Thin, crispy crust is just perfect...."
Patricia Katzman
Sals
85/100 (836 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The most friendly staff who never fail to make you feel welcome with a smile no matter how busy. The food is always spot on with no bad choices to be..."
Carol Davids
"Sal's pizza never lets you down! Great pizza, don't get me started on those awesome garlic knots! All around great..."
Jessica Koleske
"Great pizza at a reasonable price! The garlic rolls are a delicious..."
Luanne Recker Gilmore
"Awesome place! The best pizza west of the NY metro area. It reminds me of home. Also love that you can have it by the..."
Steve Hopper
"After being in Wisconsin for 2 years, I finally found good pizza. This is a genuine NY pizza..."
Jeff Zeidner
"Fantastic pizza! Great price and great staff. A must stop when in..."
Lisa Lindstrom Gotelaere
"Great pizza slice, great price amazing garlic roll comes with..."
Shelley Nulton
"I called in a pick up order. When i arrived, i was informed that their delivery driver accidentally took my pizza on a delivery. I was disappointed..."
Chris Hummell
"Every time Im there it’s the best. Never had a bad..."
Jon Stacy
"Wonderful! All their pizza and food is divine! Especially love the lasagna..."
Sandy Drifka
"Proppa! Great pizza, great service! A must..."
Mike Cannon
"The best Buffalo Chicken pizza! They are supper friendly even when you come in all fucked up after bar..."
Kent Long
"I tried out Sal's Pizza while visiting Appleton recently. They sell pizza by the slice, and had a variety of options to choose from. I was greeted..."
Robert Long
"This pie is Legit! Great deal on the slices and bread roll. This is a for sure stop anytime I'm in Appleton! The sauce rocks...cheese is balanced..."
Dice The Mopar Guy
"Only real NY style pizza in the valley (that I know of). So for that alone this is good. Atmosphere is also great, a usually lots of people in the..."
Ben Runnoe
"We never vist Appleton without stopping at Sal's for a slice! Generous slices of thin crust pizza. Great variety. Pizza is fantastic and the rolls..."
Margaret Namio
"Best pizza around. We love the Barbecue chicken pizza. I order it every time I go there, which is often. Garlic rolls are to die for. I could eat..."
Bonnie Drews
Victoria's
84/100 (2511 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Scallops
Clams
Cheesecake
Alfredo
Meatballs
Cheesecakes
Lasagne
Tortellini
Tortelloni
Shrimp
Pesto
Fish
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"We went to dinner last night with some friends . We had a drink in the bar and then went to go get seated . We were promptly seated and our waitress..."
Wendy Kleinhans
"Awesome food.great service.the portions are more than enough.would highly..."
Becky Krueger Schimke
"Great food great atmoshere...love it!!!! Great service..huge menu..you can never finish your..."
Dave Mikloczak
"We stop here when we go to broadway shows and love it!! Last night it was very busy, we sat down and had to wait a long time until a server..."
Kimberly LaCount
"We were seated immediately. In taking our order, our Waiter, Jesse Amico asked if we were going to the Play. He made sure we had plenty of time...."
Darla M. Lorenz
"Very good food and service .. I highly recommend this to anyone thats looking for a great..."
Jeremy Alquist
"They always have awesome service & food. Their take out service is excellent too. Yesterday they brought my order out to to my vehicle. I highly..."
Tammy Lee Kudrick
"Absolutely amazing! The wait for the food was a little long but DEFINITELY worth the wait! I'll be back for sure!! You get tons of food for a decent..."
Kacie Elizabeth
"This is one of our favorite restaurants! The food is amazing every time. The portions are huge, and our waiter was..."
Michele O'Malley Gregesich
"I’ve been coming here for at least ten year and I love it. Their bottles of wine are very reasonably priced which I love. This place is known for..."
Paige Hietpas
"There are reasons why Victoria’s has been an Italian food staple in the Valley for almost 40 years; their food, service, hospitality, and quality,..."
Timothy
"This place is insane! Everything has always been delicious. Service is good. The portions are huge!! When you order make sure want multiple meals of..."
Heather Bell
"BRANT S WAS A WONDERFUL WAITER. Because of him and the delicious food we will definitely be coming back when we move here from KY. He was attentive..."
A S
"My absolute favorite place. I'm never disappointed when I go there. Portions are great. The food is amazing. And the staff is beyond..."
Amy Brunette
"Pictured is what I took home. Lunch with Mom included cannelloni alfredo and linguine with marsala sauce and mushrooms. I added tenderloin for $5..."
Wendy Ulrich
"It was so nice to be back at Victoria’s after losing the Green Bay location years ago. Safe to say its still a favorite of mine. My food was..."
Melissa Thurlow
"Our family of 7 had a tasty dinner Saturday night. Our waitress was great & talked us through a couple dishes. The kids had pizza & meatballs. My..."
Mathew Goeldner
Victorias Italian Crusine
84/100 (896 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We went to dinner last night with some friends . We had a drink in the bar and then went to go get seated . We were promptly seated and our waitress..."
Wendy Kleinhans
"Awesome food.great service.the portions are more than enough.would highly..."
Becky Krueger Schimke
"Great food great atmoshere...love it!!!! Great service..huge menu..you can never finish your..."
Dave Mikloczak
"We stop here when we go to broadway shows and love it!! Last night it was very busy, we sat down and had to wait a long time until a server..."
Kimberly LaCount
"We were seated immediately. In taking our order, our Waiter, Jesse Amico asked if we were going to the Play. He made sure we had plenty of time...."
Darla M. Lorenz
"Very good food and service .. I highly recommend this to anyone thats looking for a great..."
Jeremy Alquist
"They always have awesome service & food. Their take out service is excellent too. Yesterday they brought my order out to to my vehicle. I highly..."
Tammy Lee Kudrick
"Absolutely amazing! The wait for the food was a little long but DEFINITELY worth the wait! I'll be back for sure!! You get tons of food for a decent..."
Kacie Elizabeth
"This is one of our favorite restaurants! The food is amazing every time. The portions are huge, and our waiter was..."
Michele O'Malley Gregesich
"I’ve been coming here for at least ten year and I love it. Their bottles of wine are very reasonably priced which I love. This place is known for..."
Paige Hietpas
"Victoria's is very interesting. You can take your prom or homecoming date here like I did and it would still have the nice level of formality, or you..."
Joseph Nowak
"Best in the Fox Valley. Best food in the Fox Valley at a great price! I love Noe's Sauce over gnocchi with a cup of cheese tortellini soup. Oh, so..."
Mark H.
"Depends on what you want. Victoria's is great if you want massive portions of decent, mainstream, American-Italian food. The menu is extensive, the..."
Chris
"My husband and I went here for dinner. The server was nice but could have been more knowledgeable about helping us make selections because there are..."
KLowe
"Talk about quick, nice service. Good was good for the great price. Prices were crazy good for the portion u got. Tried the app's, pasta and..."
Lots Of Food To Eat
"Amazing!!. My husband and I made our annual trip to Appleton/Green Bay for our anniversary Packer game. We enjoyed a wonderful stay in Appleton and..."
Asallen1962
"Huge portions, SO yummy. Anytime im in the green bay area, i ALWAYS put a stop at victoria's on my agenda! they offer HUGE portions, plus tastey..."
MissPiggy
"A favorite for us. My daughter says she would go just for the bread basket. The rolls ARE baked fresh and usually delicious. I love their crisp,..."
Mor
"Come with an Appetite. Come with an appetite or order out with a group. This is the perfect venue for the college crowd on a..."
Renee
"Good food. Huge..."
Mr. Roncindo
"Great specials for 2. Really good food. Point blank. Old school..."
Havlos
"The Best So Far. I haven't been to every respectable restaurant in the Fox Valley but this is my favorite so far. I literally feel like I am ripping..."
Tom Langel
"It was good food, needs to be more authentic..."
David Pfeifer
"There are reasons why Victoria’s has been an Italian food staple in the Valley for almost 40 years; their food, service, hospitality, and quality,..."
Timothy
"This place is insane! Everything has always been delicious. Service is good. The portions are huge!! When you order make sure want multiple meals of..."
Heather Bell
"BRANT S WAS A WONDERFUL WAITER. Because of him and the delicious food we will definitely be coming back when we move here from KY. He was attentive..."
A S
"My absolute favorite place. I'm never disappointed when I go there. Portions are great. The food is amazing. And the staff is beyond..."
Amy Brunette
"Pictured is what I took home. Lunch with Mom included cannelloni alfredo and linguine with marsala sauce and mushrooms. I added tenderloin for $5..."
Wendy Ulrich
"It was so nice to be back at Victoria’s after losing the Green Bay location years ago. Safe to say its still a favorite of mine. My food was..."
Melissa Thurlow
"Our family of 7 had a tasty dinner Saturday night. Our waitress was great & talked us through a couple dishes. The kids had pizza & meatballs. My..."
Mathew Goeldner
Stucs Pizza
82/100 (917 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Deep dish pizza
Cakes
Pesto
Sandwiches
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My new favorite pizza place. The pizza was outstanding and there is something about their pizza sauce that makes them soar above others. The server..."
Mary Capelle
"Pizza was really good. If you like a lot of sauce it's great for that. We will be back for sure. Staff is friendly and..."
Heather Bell
"This pizza is simply phenomenal. I always try to steer family dinner here whenever I can. Brenda's Fresco deep dish fulfills my pizza fix. 🍕 #1 in..."
Avid Reviewer
"I love their pizza. Everything I go there I eye up the cakes and muffins and by the end of the meal I'm full BUT this time I got some carrot cake yes..."
Cassie Mikulski
"Great deep dish pizza had a meaty one and a taco one, with a bonus they have the toppings on the side to make warming it up easier. Ohh soon cheesy..."
B Sanchez
"We came here in lieu of a recent 1 star review and owner’s response…weird I know…to see if this pizza was ‘garbage’ as described… If it..."
George Schultz
Noodles & Company
80/100 (645 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Fast Food
Fast food
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Noodle
Sit down
Italian
Fast food
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"It was a great experience! Was nice enough yet to sit outside, so Mara and I did just that! Very good food..."
Sue Jape Westphal
"I may not spell his name correctly, but Angelo at this location is amazing! I called for a last minute Mac and cheese and he gave me the best..."
Kayla Mastey
"One of my favorites!! The hardest part is picking which bowl of yummy goodness will I have..."
Lisa Raley
"Sheboygan location better open up..."
Anjalena Karas
"Love Noodles &..."
Wendy Murphy
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
79/100 (566 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Alfredo
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Very good, love the food and as always very good vegetarian options although I feel the menu needs to update to what vegetarian means because I..."
Lalita Correa
"Salad and Zappa Toscana are always great! Pasta dishes are good as well, but the Zuppa is to die for!! Great customer service as..."
Melissa Christensen
"We went for lunch and were promptly seated. Our waitress was great. We had the endless soup, salad and bread sticks. The food was amazing as usual...."
Elaine Burchett
"Absolutely an enjoyable restaurant to dine. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The prices are very reasonable, and it is a clean, relaxing..."
Tohnja Roepcke
"I placed a catering over the phone and the delivery wasn't available. To my surprise everything was included for the Create Your Own Pasta Station...."
Mathieu Labs
"Best place ever to take your special lady fried for some grub before you dive into her olive garden (if you know what I mean).. man, the greens have..."
Kyle SPCR
Garden View Family Restaurant
79/100 (1509 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
American
Mexican
Italian
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Toasts
Sit down
Italian
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Fazoli's
76/100 (962 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Italian
Fast Food
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
"I came through the drive thru with 2 orders and Michelle did an awesome job of taking both orders separately and recommending sweets to enjoy for..."
James Truckey
"Rufus was amazing tonight. He stopped by our table a few times to makes sure things were going good. I'd like to say he remembers how much my son..."
Sam Weyenberg
"Cameo took my drive-thru order and was so at the pickup window. She was pleasant and efficient. I waited just a few minutes and my food was ready...."
Rita McComber
"Excellent service, delicious food and a girl named Hannah was super kind! We had a great experience and we will definitely be..."
sarah parson
"Definitely the best Fazoli’s we’ve been to. The staff are always nice and friendly. Michelle P. Always has the best attitude. I recommend this..."
Marlene Reyes
"Oh Fazoli’s, you never disappoint and this Appleton location lived up to the reputation! Ordered a delicious dish of spaghetti with meatballs,..."
Brendan Gutenschwager
Fazoli's
74/100 (877 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We came here for a quick meal and got Frannie as a host. She was so polite and very helpful. This corporate store is missing out on an amazing..."
Stacy Knaack
"i went into the lobby and lucas was awesome. isaac helped me out when there was an issue w my order. absolute 5 star review from..."
lili cloud
"Had an amazing server! Don't know his name but very nice. Very polite. I do know he's got a 2 month old baby and I want to say thank you for a great..."
Jake Augsburger
"Had their large family meal deal. My kiddos love going..."
Tamera Wilson
"The food and service was great. Serena was very caring and helpful. Thank..."
Kathryn Thompson
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton
74/100 (1345 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
American
Italian
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Fish
Salad
Wings
Sit down
American
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Delivery
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We had pizza bread nuggets tonight and the thin crust was amazing!!! We are down here in Appleton for my daughters birthday and this place was within..."
David Caster
"Stopped here on a whim because pizza sounded good. The place felt kind of chilly but that might have been because we were sitting by am exterior..."
Chelsea Knoll
"Third time I have had delivery and have yet to be disappointed! Absolutely delicious!!!!! Definetly worth the price, quanity and quality is spot on...."
Molly Ræ McGuire
"Glass Nickel is one of our favorite places to get pizza. I just wish they always had muenster cheese so we could have our favorite specialty pizza,..."
Jenny VanderPas
"Great pizza and great service!!! Waiter was very good, had answers and/or options for all of our questions. Honest opinions are refreshing!!!! Will..."
Renee Larson
"Excellent pizza!! Love the Thai pizza!! Also the Portobello pizza is..."
Shavonna Spoor Smelzer
"Very good, excellent pizza and abby our server was Great, will definitely come back..."
Pamela Mayhew
"Had a very bad experience at Unos Appleton and ended up at Glass Nickel. OMG! Amazing food and an amazing waiter. After being ignored at Unos, it..."
Angilla R Young
"Yikes. Some of these reviews are kind of harsh. When you like a place on the whole and receive a single bad experience (which can happen anywhere) -..."
Yuun Murphy
"I’ve been there 3 times in the month of May. Absolutely Love their Alfredo Pizza… You can order with or without the Chicken. I personally get..."
Vicki S
"Fantastic Pizza! We stopped here while on a road trip and we're very happy with our pizzas, definitely someplace I'll be coming back to in the..."
Peter Kilburn
"So glad we chose to stop here while visiting the area. Pizza combinations are crazy delicious! We want to try them All!! Exceptional service. Decent..."
Nocturnalife
"I 100% reccomend this place! I just hands down had the best salad I can honestly say I've ever had in my life. I know, sounds dramatic but I'm not..."
Molly Mc Guire
Sbarro
70/100 (674 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Stopped by around 11am and there were plenty of options for fresh pizza. Pizza, breadsticks, marinara & a drink all for $8.50. It was more than..."
Rebecca J
"Thank you staff for a positive experience and a 110% customer service. The food was amazing I recommend the meatballs and garlic toast. Everyone that..."
Heidi De La Teja
"Love this place! The spinach Stromboli is the..."
Rachel Paulson
"Good location for group choice since it is in the mall food court. Delivery thru DoorDash/Uber makes it convenient to eat at home. Service is very..."
Terry O'Dell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use