Papa Johns Pizza
902 W Northland Ave, 54914-1421 - Appleton
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#250 of 266 restaurants in Appleton
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
50/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (5)
Photo 1 / 5
100%
Google Reviews
232
Google reviews
Delicious pizza that's made pretty quick! I never had an issue picking one up when some friends and I were hungry. The pineapple they put on is so incredibly good, and I always enjoy the pepper in the box.
Google
I ordered half sausage/half pineapple pizza during a Packer game. It took over 2 hours to get and it was half sausage/ half pepperoni. Nothing like a cold pizza with the wrong toppings....
Google
Disgusting! We ordered a cheese pizza because my family is vegetarian and there was pork chunks mixed in the sauce under the cheese. Plus we ordered ahead of time. 20 mins was the prep time and it took 45 mins to get our order.
Google
This location USED to have the best carryout specials I've ever seen. NOT ANYMORE. Congratulations! By raising your prices, you've just discovered how to lose loyal customers.
Pictured is their pizza back when the price was worth it.
Google
Ordered the new pepperoni stuffed pizza, omg, I was excited, but man it was the most disliked pizza I have ever had, lessened learned hear, will never order from there again
Google
Ordered 2 pizzas and it took about 2 hours to get delivered. When I called they just told me they were busy. I get it but 2 hours???? When I asked for the manager I was told I was already speaking to one. No apology, no offers for discount, very disappointed and will not order Papa John's again! To top that off pizza was cold when it was finally delivered.....
Read more
Google
The way they cook pizza is inconsistent. Normal bake the crust is always doughy and could be cooked a little longer. Well done….it’s always over done almost burnt. I thought well maybe this is how Papa John’s cooks their pizza until I went to another location and surprise it was cooked perfectly. The crust was golden brown and the correct crispness/softness.
Read more
Google
Seriously how is this LIGHT sauce??? There is a reason I put light sauce. Please read the instructions 😩
Google
Explore more in Appleton
Help improve this page: