New York Deli
1853 N Casaloma Dr, 54913-7980 - Appleton
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#89 of 266 restaurants in Appleton
Updated on
American
Deli
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
59/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 920-734-3354
🌐 Website:
http://www.newyorkdeliappleton.com
📍
Address:
1853 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
265
Google reviews
Hands down the best deli in the valley. I always go with the special and haven't been let down yet! The girls working have awesome customer service and constantly ensure the customers are happy. I can not stress this enough...if you've never been here you're missing out.
Google
I ordered one sandwich to go. I sat and waited and waited. I saw the people that ordered after me, get there hot sandwiches first, then the guy that ordered the same damn sandwich as I did get his before me. I was taking a break during the day of working and this place is a cool plate waste of time. Took my refund and left and will. Ever return
Read more
Google
Seriously great food! Plenty of sit down area if you want to eat there, or carry out if your short on time; orders come out quickly! Variety of fountain or bottled beverages to choose from in addition to great coffee drinks and smoothies. Atmosphere is quiet and comfortable, and the staff are really friendly. This is a place I'll frequently come back to now that I've discovered it! **Update, currently not serving coffees, but the rest of their menu continues to impress! Still my go-to!
Read more
Google
1st time eating here ( wrong item in my to go order)
2nd time... Told them about my 1st experience and one again I was given the wrong sandwich in my bag.
Strike 3 was when waiting to get my order the worker in the back was asked by a customer to clean up a table. She walked over and cleaned up the trash on the table (with gloves on) and walked into the kitchen and went back to work with the same gloves. Didn't wash her hands and felt the need to keep touching the wrapping paper for the sandwiches and everything around her without changing gloves.
Read more
Google
Love Boars head meats! Glad we found somewhere to buy the lunch meat and great sandwiches!
Google
What a treat New York Deli is! Absolutely delectable menu served in a New York-themed cafe; there is even an artifact from the Twin Towers on display. The staff is friendly, prices are reasonable for the quality, and there are dessert options available to finish off your meal. Very pleased! I highly recommend the Mediterranean Wrap.
Read more
Google
Went twice meatball sub was okay got soggy real fast plus i waited about 25 minutes because the girl making it dropped the first one. Got the chef salad today and it wad very small for 8.50 and was described as having swiss and cheddar with ham and Turkey on it which were all sliced and rolled up on the side of the plate. Overall not worth the price
Read more
Google
Nice location off the beaten path of Wisconsin Ave. Plenty of space and food was amazing!! I had the french dip with au ju. Best I've ever had. Bought a NY cheesecake to go and happy to say it was excellent! Service only made the experience only better.
Google
Explore more in Appleton
Help improve this page: